Skip to main content
AmigoFish

EP 183 Pt 2: A Monster in Mt. Pleasant by CJ Williams 'Toys in the Attic'

From Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast · · 1 hr 12 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Part 2: After the murders of Karol and Clementine Beavers, fear settled over Mt. Pleasant as investigators searched for a killer hiding in plain sight. Among the young men questioned was Monte Seager, a troubled teen who had crossed paths with Karol at Mount Pleasant High School. His alibi raised no immediate suspicion, and the investigation began to drift, leaving the Mount Pleasant community forever changed—more cautious, more fearful, and still with the truth just out of reach.

Then, months later, another violent attack shook the same community—this time at the Iris Restaurant, where bartender Susan Wheelock was attacked, succumbing to her injuries. The clues in this homicide investigation raised eyebrows, as law enforcement began focusing on Monte Seager. As more evidence began to surface, old suspicions stirred again, pulling the Beavers case back from the shadows. What had once seemed like a trail gone cold now suggested something far more unsettling—a pattern that would take years, forensic persistence, and a series of unexpected turns to bring into focus.

Listen to Ep 181- Part 1 on A Monster in Mount Pleasant first!

Buy A Monster in Mount Pleasant: A Story of Murders and Justice by CJ Williams on AMAZON or ABE BOOKS.

Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill's code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!

Jill's Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club

Join Jill on PATREON for $2- $4 and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill's SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub

Sources, photographs, maps, and other information can be found on Jill's Blog- September 2026

https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2026/09/

Back to Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast · Report a problem