Skip to main content
AmigoFish

2006 - Tristram Shandy

From Movie of the Year · · 1 hr 30 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Movie of the Year: 2006

Tristram Shandy: A Cock and Bull Story

The Tristram Shandy Podcast Opens the 2006 Bracket

The Tristram Shandy podcast episode kicks off our brand new 2006 bracket on Movie of the Year. After crowning our way through 1971, the Taste Buds turn to a fresh film year. Moreover, we start with one of the strangest comedies of the decade. Michael Winterbottom's Tristram Shandy: A Cock and Bull Story is a film about making a film of an unfilmable book. Consequently, it makes a perfect launch title for a show that loves movies about movies. In this episode, Ryan, Mike, and Greg dig into metafiction, gender, and the prickly chemistry between Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon. Additionally, two new segments make their debut. Above all, we want to set the tone for a wild 2006 season.

About the Film

Laurence Sterne published The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman in nine volumes between 1759 and 1767. The novel is famous for being playful, digressive, and nearly impossible to adapt. Notably, the narrator barely manages to get himself born across hundreds of pages. Winterbottom and his team turned that problem into the whole joke. As a result, the movie follows a fictional crew trying to film the book. Steve Coogan plays a vain version of himself, plus Tristram and his father, Walter. Meanwhile, Rob Brydon plays a needling version of himself and Uncle Toby. The screenplay carries the pseudonym "Martin Hardy," although Frank Cottrell-Boyce actually wrote it. Furthermore, the cast includes Keeley Hawes, Shirley Henderson, Dylan Moran, Naomie Harris, Kelly Macdonald, and Jeremy Northam. Gillian Anderson and Stephen Fry also appear as heightened versions of themselves. You can read more at Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Cock_and_Bull_Story) or the original Roger Ebert review (https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/tristram-shandy-a-cock-and-bull-story-2006).

This is the first film episode of our 2006 season. To explore the wider bracket project, visit the Movie of the Year archive (https://popfilter.co/category/movie-of-the-year/). If you enjoy this Tristram Shandy podcast deep dive, our A Clockwork Orange episode (https://popfilter.co/1971-a-clockwork-orange/) from the 1971 run pairs nicely with this conversation about cinematic form.

Want to hear how the season began? Start with our 2006 season intro (https://popfilter.co/movie-of-the-year-2006-podcast-intro-part-1/), then dig into the 2006 bracket reveal (https://popfilter.co/movies-of-2006-bracket-reveal/) before this episode.

Metafiction and the Unfilmable Novel

Metafiction sits at the center of our first discussion. Sterne wrote a novel that constantly reminds you it is a novel. Similarly, Winterbottom built a movie that keeps reminding you it is a movie. The crew breaks the fourth wall, argues about the script, and screens its own dailies. Therefore, the film becomes a hall of mirrors about storytelling itself. The Taste Buds ask a simple question. How do you adapt a book that mocks the idea of adaptation? Furthermore, we trace the lineage from Sterne to modern self-aware comedies. Films like Adaptation and Day for Night come up as obvious cousins. Ultimately, we argue that Winterbottom found the only honest solution. He filmed the failure instead of the book. Consequently, the movie respects Sterne by refusing to tame him.

The Battle of the Sexes on Screen

Next, we turn to gender and how the film portrays men and women. The male characters chase status, sex, and screen time with comic desperation. Coogan, in particular, frets about his shoe lifts and his billing. Meanwhile, the women in the film often hold the real power. Kelly Macdonald plays Jenny, who grounds Coogan with calm clarity. Naomie Harris plays Jennie, a production assistant who runs circles around the panicking men. Gillian Anderson arrives late and instantly reshapes the production. By contrast, the men flail and posture. So the Taste Buds debate a thorny point. Does the…

Back to Movie of the Year · Report a problem