
May the Record Reflect
National Institute for Trial AdvocacyAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Monthly
- Typical length:
- about 50 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
May the Record Reflect is a skills-focused podcast for trial lawyers who want to get better at what really happens in the courtroom. Hosted by the National Institute for Trial Advocacy, each episode features experienced judges, advocates, and legal educators sharing practical guidance on trial advocacy, depositions, witness examination, oral communication, jury selection, and courtroom presence—along with ethics, professionalism, and lawyer well‑being. Whether you’re preparing for trial, handling high‑stakes hearings, or looking to sharpen your advocacy skills, May the Record Reflect delivers insights you can put to work right away.
Covers: trial advocacy, litigation, legal education, courtroom presence, witness examination, depositions, jury selection, legal ethics, oral advocacy, artificial intelligence
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at rss.buzzsprout.com. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
May the Record Reflect is a podcast for trial lawyers that covers practical courtroom skills, including advocacy, depositions, witness examination, jury selection, and professionalism. Recent episodes have explored using AI to help trial lawyers prepare, tips for motion practice, the role of direct examination, and the twelve elements of assertive delivery.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- Sari Swears
Both cover: jury selection, trial advocacy - Trial Lawyer Nation
Both cover: jury selection, trial advocacy
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
64. Breaking the Ice: Voir Dire Tips and Tactics, with Judge Cynthia McCollum
· 57 min
As a sitting district court judge and 29-year public defender, NITA Program Director Judge Cynthia McCollum knows a thing or two about jury selection, and in this episode, she opens up about how to get your jurors to open up. She serves up a baker’s dozen of her best tips for getting jurors to talk during voir dire, mistakes she learned from as a public defender, what to know about Batson challenges, and anecdotes about her career trajectory before and on the bench. Topics 3:50 First tip for getting jurors to open up during voir dire 4:47 Second tip 5:45 Judge’s first time in court as a new lawyer 9:48. Third tip 14:24 Fourth tip 18:33 Fifth tip 20:08 Being a public defender, then a judge 24:42 Sixth tip 26:39. Seventh tip 29:28 What it’s like to be a judge 31:48 Eighth tip 33:09 Ninth tip 38:25 Tenth tip 41:31 NITA involvement 45:06 Eleventh tip 48:35 Twelfth tip 50:32 Baker’s dozen tip about Batson 52:39 Signoff questions Quote “Everyone needs to work on their jury selection. It’s not a natural for a lot of people, because you get nervous about asking those tough questions.” Judge Cynthia McCollum Resources Judge Cynthia McCollum (bio (https://www.mncourts.gov/About-The-Courts/Overview/JudicialDirectory/Bio.aspx?jid=1670)) Batson bonuses (file (https://info.nita.org/l/921043/2025-02-12/bzdqv1/921043/17393903229zlfoMhL/Batson_bonuses.pdf)) Minnesota Deposition Skills and Trial Skills (programs (https://www.nita.org/s/category/programs/format/onsite/minnesota/0ZG4W000000PaqHWAS?c__results_layout_state=%7B%7D))
Not rated yet63. Effective Oral Communication, with Mark Caldwell
· 47 min
NITA Program Director and former Resource Director Mark Caldwell joins the podcast to chat about how to effectively communicate with the various audiences in the courtroom to ensure they get — and comprehend — the information they need from you. He shares how to talk to jurors about unfamiliar courtroom procedures and substantive information, why sounding like a tv lawyer is a huge turn-off to jurors, and recommends some of his favorite lawyers from pop culture whose techniques can help trial lawyers refine their courtroom communication style. Topics 3:05 The needs of the courtroom audience 7:14 What “talking like a lawyer” means 10:10 Juror impressions of “lawspeak” 13:53 Communicating procedural and substantive complexity 20:06 How not to sound like a lawyer 27:50 Pop culture examples of legal communication 29:00 Why my cousin Vinny is a great trial lawyer 31:42 Movies and a book to recommend 51:55 Implicit bias training Quote “Don’t be a tv lawyer, but take lessons from what you see on television.” Mark Caldwell Resources Mark Caldwell (bio (https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-s-caldwell-24b49218/)) Colorado Deposition Skills and Trial Skills (programs (https://www.nita.org/s/category/programs/format/onsite/colorado/0ZG4W000000PapIWAS?c__results_layout_state=%7B%7D)) Films, shows, and book (list (https://info.nita.org/l/921043/2025-02-19/c4rftt/921043/1739977805rVTMZIvu/Podcast_resources.pdf))
Not rated yet62. Cross-Examination Math: Less is More, More is Less, with Tom Innes
· 28 min
In Episode 62, Philadelphia trial lawyer and NITA Program Director Tom Innes introduces listeners to cross-examination math and how the idea of “less is more” increases the impact of the questions counsel poses to a witness. Control is the name of the game in cross, so Tom also shares how to shepherd witnesses through cross, why to restrict interrogatories in the phrasing of questions, and why less is even more when examining an expert. Timestamps & More Topics 3:06 How to think about cross 3:53 Objectives of cross 5:05 Rules of cross-examination math 6:41 Why concision helps your finder of fact 9:22 Controlling an adverse or difficult witness 10:15 Cross demo 14:12 Omitting the interrogatory 17:00 Expert versus fact witness 18:11 When to break the “cross math” rule 23:26 Signoff questions Quote “Every word you put into a leading question permits the witness to decide which word they will, or they can, disagree with or work around or give you a hard time about.” Tom Innes Resources Tom Innes (bio (https://www.linkedin.com/in/thomas-j-innes-25252315/)) Judge L. Felipe Restrepo (bio (https://www.ussc.gov/about/who-we-are/commisioners/judge-luis-felipe-restrepo)) Mary DeFusco (bio (https://www1.villanova.edu/university/law/faculty-scholarship/faculty-directory/adjunct-faculty.html)) Building Trial Skills Philadelphia (program (https://www.nita.org/s/product/building-trial-skills-philadelphia/01tUm000004y2FxIAI))
Not rated yet61. "Don't Be Boring": Creating Your Commanding Courtroom Presence, with Steve Wood and Laurie Gilbertson
· 1 hr 27 min
In 2021, former prosecutor Steve Wood told May the Record Reflect that to grow as a trial advocate, he had to accept that he is “insufferably boring.” What did he mean by that? And, how can it help you grow as an advocate as well? In this self-deprecating but entirely serious conversation, Steve and fellow former prosecutor Laurie Gilbertson talk about the neuroscience of boredom, multisensory engagement in the courtroom, telling a compelling story, and how it all adds up to self-confidence and stronger advocacy for your client. Topics 3:27 What it means to be “insufferably boring” in court 5:55 Neuroscience behind boredom 9:06 Why trials are boring 15:11 Bored judges, bored jurors 28:35 Resting postures for hands 37:07 Role of storytelling 42:42 When storytelling is most important 49:36 Repeating yourself without being boring 57:27 Confidence 1:01:36 Preparation, notes, and delivery 1:14:56 Great Hollywood courtroom performances 1:21:00 Signoff questions Quote “Our task as trial lawyers, as I see it, is to do three things. One, admit that we’re boring — all of us, all the time. Two, with the aid of people like Laurie, do the things that we can do to be less boring. And then three, never fall prey to the conceit that at any given time a majority of the trier of fact is paying attention. Assume the opposite. But what we can do, most primarily, is introduce change into the courtroom environment. That’s our mission.” Steve Wood “. . . what I found often is that jurors who have watched so much tv, who have watched so many movies, who have read legal thrillers, who have maybe listened to true-crime podcasts — some of them, if not many of them, expect to be entertained, and when you, as the attorney, are not kind of doing all these things that Steve is talking about in terms of interjecting that change and keeping them entertained, a lot of the jurors are surprised that court is actually that boring. They expect it to be a lot more interesting.” Laurie Gilbertson Resources Steve Wood (bio (https://www.mccarter.com/people/steven-p-wood/)) Laurie Gilbertson (bio (https://www.tribecablueconsulting.com/about)) Top 10 Tips that Make a Difference, with Steve Wood (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/21-top-10-tips-that-make-a-difference-with-steve-wood/01t4W00000DaBoPQAV)) Thinking with Your Hands: The Surprising Science Behind How Gestures Shape Our Thoughts (book (https://www.publishersweekly.com/9781541600805))
Not rated yet60. Demystifying Depositions, with Jason Young
· 47 min
In this rebroadcast of our 2022 interview, we gather all sorts of admissions—about depositions—from NITA NextGen alumni Jason Young. After taking and defending thousands of depositions throughout his career, he’s no-nonsense and has figured out how to make the challenges easier on himself, his clients, and his witnesses. Jason also talks about the crucial work–life decisions all lawyers face as they begin their careers. Topics 3:46 The hard part of taking depositions 5:55 Federal rules related to depositions 9:13 Witnesses, both expert and lay 11:36 Role of social media 15:10 When to video-record a deposition 17:35 The hard part of dealing with witnesses 19:40 Timelines for expert witnesses, plaintiff versus defendant 22:07 Subpoenas 25:00 Obnoxious opposing counsel 30:50 Preparing your witness 34:42 Protecting your witness 37:53 Remote depositions 40:31 Work–life balance and advice for new lawyers 44:35 Signoff questions Quote “What a lot of inexperienced deposition lawyers have a problem with is they are terrified of the unknown in depositions and afraid to follow up on things, know how to shut things down, and that really scares a lot of people. And I guess the thinking with depositions a lot of times is, you want to know more. If there’s information that’s going to come out that’s going to hurt me, I want to know it in a deposition. If there’s additional facts I need or something I didn’t know, I’d rather find out in a depo than in trial.” Jason Young Resources Jason Young (bio (https://www.pearlschneider.com/our-team/jason-r-young-attorney)) Blog interview (The Legal Advocate (https://go.pardot.com/l/921043/2022-03-08/rly6f/921043/1646760713gD7oz7GT/Asked_and_Answered_Jason_Young.pdf)) Federal Rules of Evidence with Objections (book (https://www.nita.org/s/product/federal-rules-of-evidence-with-objections-as-amended-to-december-1-2023/01t8a000008kDHTAA2)) NITA Deposition programs (registration (https://www.nita.org/s/category/programs/program-type/deposition-skills/0ZG4W000000PawEWAS?c__results_layout_state=%7B%7D))
Not rated yet59. At Your Service: Developing as an Advocate through Pro Bono Work, with Angela Vigil and Henry Su
· 1 hr 5 min
The wish to leave the world a better place has long inspired people to attend law school and make a difference in the important ways only trial lawyers can. According to NITA Trustee Angela Vigil and Program Director Henry Su, pro bono publico provides an opportunity both to help those in need of legal counsel and to develop one’s oral advocacy skills. In this episode recognizing both this week's National Celebration of Pro Bono and the fifth anniversary of May the Record Reflect, Angela and Henry discuss a lawyer’s professional responsibilities, the advocacy skillset that pro bono work develops, and how to find pro bono opportunities. They also reveal their favorite tips, common mistakes they see in depositions and trials, and qualities embodied by courtroom superstars. “I think law school lights a fire in smart and curious people for sure, so when you come out of law school, you have an idea of what kind of ways you want to apply these great new skills. That is definitely true in most recent generations and you just get rejuvenated when you talk with them and learn what they want to accomplish. I also think that, more and more, lawyers are listening and understanding that wellness and bringing your whole self to being part of your community is really important. You can’t just be a lawyer who locks yourself in a room and bills a bunch of hours for decades. It’s not healthy, it doesn’t last, it’s not good for you, it doesn’t encourage diversity and community. So, I think we all—and certainly younger-generation lawyers—are recognizing that you’ve got to bring your humanity to being part of your practice as well.” Angela Vigil Topics 6:25 Model Rule of Professional Conduct 6.1 8:40 Pro Bono's impact on access to justice 13:00 Learning trial skills through pro bono service 16:44 Range of pro bono advocacy work 27:35 Inspiration for doing work that is “advisory” 33:45 Generational desire to make a difference 35:37 Wellness and performance 38:16 Obligation to provide competent representation 42:25 Making time for pro bono 46:15 Witnessing skills growth through pro bono 53:00 Common mistakes in depositions and at trial 56:54 Superstar lawyer qualities 58:51 Favorite insider’s tips 1:00:46 Signoff questions Angela Vigil (bio (https://www.bakermckenzie.com/en/people/v/vigil-angela-c)) Henry Su (bio (https://www.linkedin.com/in/henrycsu/)) ABA Model Rule 6.1 (link (https://www.americanbar.org/groups/probono_public_service/policy/aba_model_rule_6_1/)) National Pro Bono Opportunities Guide (state search engine (https://www.probono.net/oppsguide/)) ABA Free Legal Answers volunteer (registration (https://www.americanbar.org/groups/probono_public_service/projects_awards/free-legal-answers/tips-for-providing-pro-bono-through-aba-free-legal-answers/)) May the Record Reflect (Episodes 1 (https://www.nita.org/s/product/1-the-deets-on-the-national-celebration-of-pro-bono/01t4W00000DARxmQAH), 2 (https://www.nita.org/s/product/2-whitney-untiedt-puts-the-pro-in-pro-bono/01t4W00000DARxnQAH), 3 (https://www.nita.org/s/product/3-here-comes-the-judgerobert-mcgahey/01t4W00000DARxoQAH), 4 (https://www.nita.org/s/product/4-whats-love-got-to-do-with-it-stephanie-ledesma-knows/01t4W00000DARxpQAH)) The Resilient Lawyer (podcast episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/40-the-resilient-lawyer-with-henry-su/01t8a000008xg56AAA))
Not rated yet58. It’s Greek to Me Ancient Rhetoric for Trial Lawyers, with Marian Grace Braccia
· 1 hr 12 min
When people hear the term “rhetoric,” they often think of words full of sound and fury signifying nothing. Yet that is a woeful misunderstanding of the beauty and power of persuasive language and argument. In this episode rife with back-to-school vibes, Temple Law Professor Marian Grace Braccia breaks down the where, how, and why rhetorical devices belong in oral and written advocacy; reveals why rhetorical devices have an massive impact, even on the cellular level, on finders of fact; refreshes your recollection on devices you already know while introducing others that belong in your repertoire; and totally geeks out about how fun, easy, and powerful they are to use. Topics 3:30 The road to rhetoric 7:50 Definition of rhetoric and the Queen Philosophy 10:56 What are rhetorical devices? 11:59 The OGs of ancient rhetoric 18:43 Recent rhetoricians 20:59 Aesthetics of rhetoric 27:10 Where to deploy rhetoric at trial 29:12 Rhetoric in oral and written advocacy 33:00 Taking rhetoric too far 35:55 Easiest rhetorical devices to use 40:23 Obama the rhetorician 45:20 Tricolon and antanagoge 50:33 Sources of inspiration 54:09 Favorite devices 55:19 Wait . . . Taylor Swift? 57:40 Pop villains on trial 1:06:23 Signoff questions Quote “On an artistic level, rhetoric and the effective deployment of rhetorical devices give us emotional resonance and memory enhancement and aesthetic pleasure, and even surprise and novelty. Some rhetorical devices like irony or puns introduce the element of surprise and novelty, and they can be amusing or thought provoking, and they make the message more engaging, more memorable.” Marian Grace Braccia Resources Marian Grace Braccia (bio (https://law.temple.edu/contact/marian-g-braccia/)) The Queen Philosophy (webpage (https://liberalarts.org.uk/liberal-arts-education-by-and-for-women/)) Henry V: St. Crispin’s Day (video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyvUemTqJRk)) Renaissance Man: St. Crispin’s Day (video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p2sVd0t-R_M)) Rhetorical devices worksheet (available for download from Episode 58's show notes (https://www.nita.org/s/category/resources/podcasts/0ZG4W0000008pTPWAY?c__results_layout_state=%7B%22page_number%22%3A1%2C%22category_id%22%3A%220ZG4W0000008pTPWAY%22%2C%22refinements%22%3A%5B%5D%2C%22sort_id%22%3A%220qU8a000000LWTU%22%7D) under Resources > Podcasts at nita.org)
Not rated yet57. 10 Things You Should Know about Trial Psychology
· 1 hr 7 min
Some of the most important heads to get into are those of the jurors seated for your trial. Fortunately, figuring out what makes people tick is both interesting and fun, and Temple University Director of Advocacy Programs Jules Epstein is here to share the lowdown. Whether he’s busting common courtroom myths, revealing how the camera lies, or delving into the cognitive process of jurors (and your very own self), Jules makes the case that knowing a little trial psychology can give you a competitive edge for the good of your clients. Topics 4:02 Curse of knowledge 10:04 Goldfish attention span 13:47 Slo-mo evidence 19:16 Problems with graphic evidence 24:43 Visuals with words 27:28 Disconnect between science and law 36:30 Camera bias 43:21 Thought processes 48:55 Mythbusting 53:46 Go slow 56:12 Bonus lessons 1:00:15 Collective Wisdom 1:03:55 Signoff questions Quote “A visual guarantees that all twelve, or all eight, or all six jurors will know what something looked like.” Jules Epstein Resources Jules Epstein (bio (https://law.temple.edu/contact/jules-epstein/)) NITA’s free Collective Wisdom articles (link (https://www.nita.org/s/category/resources/articles/0ZG4W000000Pb3cWAC?c__results_layout_state=%7B%7D)) (latest (https://www.nita.org/s/product/collective-wisdom-expert-witnessesthoughts-and-strategies/01t8a000008TGqTAAW)) Point Well Made: Persuasive Oral Advocacy (book (https://www.nita.org/s/product/point-well-made-persuasive-oral-advocacy-second-edition/01t4W00000DAO0PQAX))
Not rated yet56. She Blinded Me with Science, with Judge Ruth McMullin
· 46 min
If you’ve ever been baffled by scientific, technological, or financial evidence in your case or wondered how an expert witness arrived at their conclusions, former Gwinnett County Magistrate Judge Ruth McMullin is back on the podcast to share some know-how. In this episode, she talks about why you need to deep-dive into learning about subjects outside of your college major, what fact-finders want to know about forensics and how to make it easier for them to follow, the subtle things you can learn by using subpoenas, and the impact of bias in forensic evidence. Topics 3:30 Types of forensic evidence 7:40 What’s harder and easier about types of evidence 12:03 What fact-finders want from forensic evidence 13:25 Judges’ versus jurors’ needs 17:33 Simplifying complex evidence for understanding and retention 22:57 Using expert reports 25:40 Impact in the post-truth era 31:43 Judge McMullin’s favorite forensic evidence 35:18 When your agency lacks funding for competing experts 37:35 Use of subpoenas 40:25 Role of bias in forensic evidence 44:05 Signoff questions Quote “Does this [expert] report help, does it hurt, or is it neutral? A lot of times, lawyers will see a report from the opposing side and immediately think, ‘This hurts my case.’ But it you look at it and understand the parameters of that report, it may be neutral. You can save yourself a lot of stress and time if you understand how that evidence plays in with your bigger case. It may help your case, and you may look at the report and say, ‘You know what? This actually supports my theory.’ So, the more you [learn about and question forensic evidence], the more you get comfortable with saying, ‘I don’t have an objection to this report from the other side. I actually want it. I’m glad you got it, thank you.’” Judge Ruth McMullin Resources Judge Ruth McMullin (bio (https://www.linkedin.com/in/ruth-mcmullin-7181893/)) The Great Imposter (podcast episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/35-the-great-pretender-with-judge-ruth-rocker-mcmullin/01t8a000007hS0cAAE))
Not rated yet55. Tell It to the Judge, with Judge Randall Warner and Judge Christopher Whitten
· 48 min
Maricopa County Superior Court Judges Randall Warner and Christopher Whitten team up to talk about telling stories to judges. In this episode, the judges, from their unique vantage point on the bench, reveal what they want to hear or read from counsel, what they don’t, how to write briefs that tell a compelling narrative, where they find inspired (and inspiring) storytelling, and the summer vacations they’re dreaming of. Topics 4:11 Why storytelling matters 7:04 Judges’ versus jurors’ needs 10:35 Storytelling techniques 14:30 Finding inspiration 19:10 Great legal storytellers 21:14 Advantages for both sides of “the v” 24:09 Writing interesting briefs 28:57 Telling the same story at trial as in briefs 30:29 Judges’ pet peeves in briefs 34:40 Opposing counsel’s miscasting your client 38:42 Storytelling about unsympathetic clients 41:47 Signoff questions Quotes “Fundamentally, every case is about a story, whether it’s a technical legal dispute or whether it’s a fact dispute at trial, it’s a competition to see whose story resonates more with whoever’s making the decision, whether it’s a judge or jury.” Judge Randall Warner “Even as we’ve tried cases less and less often, we’ve gotten better and better at collecting facts, and I think that’s made us worse and worse at storytelling.” Judge Christopher Whitten Resources Judge Randall Warner (bio (https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/JudicialBiographies/judicialBio.asp?jdgID=246&jdgUSID=8675)) (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/48-thats-appealing-with-judge-randall-warner/01t8a000008kCadAAE)) Judge Christopher Whitten (bio (https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/JudicialBiographies/judicialBio.asp?jdgID=212&jdgUSID=6980)) (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/43-can-i-get-a-witness-with-hon-christopher-whitten/01t8a000007rFEpAAM)) Building Trial Skills: San Diego (course (https://www.nita.org/s/product/building-trial-skills-san-diego/01t8a000008kD7LAAU)) Dominic Gianna on MTRR (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/50-persuasion-is-an-inside-job-with-dominic-gianna/01tUm000002880rIAA), episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/28-give-em-the-ol-razzle-dazzle-with-dominic-gianna/01t8a0000060mrwAAA)) James Brosnahan on MTRR (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/49-justice-at-trial-with-james-brosnahan/01tUm000001HLQrIAO)) David Mann storytelling (course (https://www.nita.org/s/product/turning-facts-into-a-story/01tUm000001TCA5IAO)) (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/33-the-secrets-of-persuasive-legal-storytelling/01t8a000007hOHeAAM))
Not rated yet54. Are You in Control Getting Real about Witnesses, with Judge Amy Hanley and Adrienne Johnson
· 1 hr 12 min
You've probably heard that in direct examination, controlling your witness is all about witness prep, while in cross, leading questions are the key. Those oft-repeated tenets are true, say podcast guests Judge Amy Hanley and NITA faculty member Adrienne Johnson, but they oversimplify the specific control techniques that actually work and how attorney style, hearing type, and venue factor in. Tune in as they get specific about the part of trial over which we have the least control: examining witnesses. Topics 3:48 One task lawyers often overlook 7:08 Prep is not just for the witness 9:50 Practice questions 13:33 Witness crumbles on the stand 18:52 Leading questions on cross 21:00 Using your voice 26:12 Tips for controlling on cross 32:33 Anecdotes about control in the courtroom 36:05 Developing your trial style 38:30 Impact of venue and regions 41:22 Controlling in different types of proceeding 46:06 Script versus bullet points 55:20 Expecting problems 58:16 Examinations gone wrong, and right 1:07:07 Signoff questions Quote “I think one of the best tools for witness control is some self-control. I always say that often—most of the time—when you get an answer you don’t like from a witness or that is not responsive, usually that’s a ‘you’ problem. You have not phrased the question well to ask the thing that you want an answer to. So the first thing I always think about when I think of a witness being out of control is whether I did a good job with my questions. Did I lead on cross? Am I introducing one fact and not asking for several facts at a time? Did I leave something up to interpretation?” Adrienne Johnson Resources Judge Amy Hanley (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/amy-hanley-51643884/)) Adrienne Johnson (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/adriennecjohnson/)) NITA Women in Trial (course (https://www.nita.org/s/product/nita-women-in-trial/01t8a000008kCZfAAM)) Direct Neglect: Where Is the Love?, with Judge Amy Hanley and Dennericka Brooks (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/42-direct-neglect-where-is-the-love-with-hon-amy-hanley-and-dennericka-brooks/01t8a000007rFEaAAM)) The Tense Trio, with Judge Amy Hanley and Cheryl Brown Wattley (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/32-the-tense-trio-with-judge-amy-hanley-and-cheryl-brown-wattley/01t8a0000078d3GAAQ)) Justice at Trial, with Jim Brosnahan (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/49-justice-at-trial-with-james-brosnahan/01tUm000001HLQrIAO)) Give ‘em the Ol’ Razzle Dazzle, with Dominic Gianna (episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/28-give-em-the-ol-razzle-dazzle-with-dominic-gianna/01t8a0000060mrwAAA))
Not rated yet53. Preparing Your Witness for the Effective Deposition, with Carl Chamberlin and Whitney Untiedt
· 1 hr 15 min
In our second interview on The Effective Deposition, Program Director and author Carl Chamberlin returns to the podcast to talk about witness preparation. Joining him is NITA Trustee and Program Director Whitney Untiedt, and together they share tips and perspectives on witness prep sessions and how to ready your witness for the procedural and substantive aspects of being deposed. Carl and Whitney also talk about the ethics obligations of counsel and the ramifications of the recent ABA Formal Opinion 508. 7:20 Timing and length of prep sessions 12:52 Tips to optimize prep 21:09 Procedure and process of being deposed 23:07 One concept and three rules 28:37 How witnesses should answer 34:15 Answering after an objection 36:21 Handling opposing counsels’ tactics 45:42 Goal of substantive preparation 49:54 Reluctance to disclose 55:57 Ethics obligations 58:28 Demo| 1:02:20 Implications of ABA Formal Op. 508 1:08:03 Signoff questions Quote “We as lawyer operate on ‘our’ time. Our time is valuable, and our time is calculated in six-minute increments, and our time is scheduled to within an inch of our lives, but when we sit down with our witness for a depo prep session, it’s no longer our time. It’s our witness’s time. This is their time to shine.” Whitney Untiedt Resources Carl Chamberlin (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/carl-chamberlin-6708a525/)) Whitney Untiedt (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/whitney-untiedt-9b83489a/)) The Effective Deposition: Techniques and Strategies that Work (book (https://www.nita.org/s/product/the-effective-deposition-techniques-and-strategies-that-work-sixth-edition/01t8a0000060fekAAA)) Beginning the Effective Deposition, with Carl Chamberlin (podcast (https://www.nita.org/s/product/47-beginning-the-effective-deposition-with-carl-chamberlin/01t8a000008b1rUAAQ)) Whitney Untiedt Puts the “Pro” in Pro Bono (podcast (https://www.nita.org/s/product/2-whitney-untiedt-puts-the-pro-in-pro-bono/01t4W00000DARxnQAH)) Deposition Skills: Florida (course (https://www.nita.org/s/product/deposition-skills-florida/01t8a000008kCz9AAE)) ABA Formal Op. 508 (opinion (https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/professional_responsibility/ethics-opinions/aba-formal-opinion-508.pdf))
Not rated yet52. Let's "Speak the Truth" about Voir Dire, with Adam Kendall
· 50 min
Content warning: Mentions of sexual assault. Brief, non-graphic discussions of questioning the venire about sexual assault occur at 32:20–32:59 and 42:25–44:34. Experienced trial lawyers are accustomed to being the ones asking the questions, but in this episode, NITA NextGen faculty member Adam Kendall finds himself in the hot seat for once. He’s answering our questions about voir dire: building rapport with the venire through icebreakers and humor, eliciting useful information from potential jurors while introducing bad facts about your case, and what you can glean from jury questionnaires. Adam also talks about the developing trend of limiting or eliminating peremptory strikes. Topics 3:39 Primary goal of voir dire 4:06 What to pay attention to 5:09 “The quiet one” 9:03 Icebreakers to build rapport 11:18 Voir dire by the judge 14:22 Strong personalities among jurors 16;25 Ideal foreperson qualities 17:50 Eliciting strong opinions and reactions 19:19 Introducing bad facts 21:12 Using humor 24:12 Signaling legal issues 26:27 Nationwide changes in peremptory strikes 32:05 Jury questionnaires 35:53 Online research of the venire 41:50 War stories 46:50 Signoff questions Quote “People who are too eager to be on a jury scare me.” Adam Kendall Resources Adam Kendall (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/adam-kendall-b4559838/)) Building Trial Skills: New Orleans (course (https://www.nita.org/s/product/building-trial-skills-new-orleans/01t8a000007rFrPAAU)) Not Just for Trial! How to Use Exhibits from Day One (Register for Adam's live webcast on March 26, 2024) (https://www.nita.org/s/product/not-just-for-trial-how-to-use-exhibits-from-day-one/01tUm000003HKtRIAW)
Not rated yet51. Depositions: Asked and Answered, with Veronica Finkelstein
· 1 hr 0 min
Taking a deposition presents enough challenge as it is without the interference of obstreperous or obstructive counsel, yet it happens anyway and you must be prepared to deal with it. Following her appearance on a NITA panel webcast on depositions in November 2023, Assistant U.S. Attorney and Wilmington Law professor Veronica Finkelstein returns to NITA’s studio71 to answer viewers’ questions about how to manage misbehavior in the deposition room. She also reveals how to be a passionate advocate for your client without crossing those lines yourself, to reclaim your time when the opposition wastes it, and to wield the unexpected power of a deposition binder. Topics 4:16 Counsel who won’t control their client 8:36 Witnesses “forgetting” their records 12:14 Counsel who try to confuse your witness 15:46 Disruptive, but not inappropriate, objections 19:21 Tracking time wasted on abusive conduct 23:26 Court reporter tracking wasted time 27:21 Being zealous but not obstreperous 29:37 Speaking objections 35:05 Continuing objections 39:51 Written discovery requests 43:36 “The usual stipulations” 46:58 Contents of a deposition binder 57:07 Signoff questions Quote “People get pretty quiet when you have the controlling case in your jurisdiction in your hand and they have nothing.” Veronica Finkelstein Resources Veronica Finkelstein (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/veronica-j-finkelstein-6004418/)) Reduce the Abuse: Managing Obstructive Opposing Counsel During Depositions (webcast (https://www.nita.org/s/product/reduce-the-abuse-managing-obstructive-opposing-counsel-during-depositions/01t8a000008kCZ1AAM)) Building Trial Skills: Colorado (course (https://www.nita.org/s/product/building-trial-skills-colorado/01t8a000007rFzrAAE))
Not rated yet50. Persuasion is an Inside Job, with Dominic Gianna
· 1 hr 2 min
Cognitive bias is a barrier that lawyers must overcome in court—and it’s not just biases of the jurors they must consider, but those, too, of the judge, opposing counsel, expert witnesses, and even one’s own self. New Orleans trial legend Dominic Gianna returns to May the Record Reflect to talk about how persuasion science can help you clear the tricky bias barrier. He presents the five most consequential cognitive biases to trial lawyers, the impact each has on fact finders, and suggests how you can connect with a diversity of jurors in the post-truth era. Topics 4:08 What is cognitive bias? 6:55 Five common cognitive biases 7:35 Confirmation bias 10:40 Anchoring bias 13:31 Hindsight bias 18:00 Availability bias 24:48 Dom’s mantras for helping jurors process information 25:35 Affinity bias 28:52 Stupid lawyer tricks 32:18 Impact of our own biases 34:36 Biases from the bench 39:42 Appealing to a panel of judges 42:24 Expert witnesses bias impact on testimony, interpretation of evidence 44:09 Cognitive biases of opposing counsel 47:06 Persuasion in the post-truth era 57:51 Signoff questions Quote “Jurors don’t vote for the evidence. They vote for their views, and so as advocates, we have the obligation to our clients to try to understand those views. Where did those views come from? Where are they based? What attitudes, beliefs, and values, led these people, this person—this particular person—to a belief system that is so strong that he or she will ignore information that seemingly contradicts that confirmation bias?” Dominic Gianna Resources Dominic Gianna (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/dominic-gianna-74220895)) Deposition Skills and Trial Skills: New Orleans (courses (https://www.nita.org/s/product/deposition-skills-trial-skills-new-orleans/01t8a000007rFrFAAU)) “Give ’em the Ol’ Razzle Dazzle (podcast episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/28-give-em-the-ol-razzle-dazzle-with-dominic-gianna/01t8a0000060mrwAAA)) “The Secrets of Persuasive Legal Storytelling,” with David Mann (podcast episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/33-the-secrets-of-persuasive-legal-storytelling/01t8a000007hOHeAAM)) “Off Broadway and Into Court,” with Kevin Newbury and Kate Douglas (podcast episode (https://www.nita.org/s/product/39-off-broadway-and-into-court-with-kevin-newbury-and-kate-douglas/01t8a000006W3jlAAC))
Not rated yet49. Justice at Trial, with James Brosnahan
· 1 hr 21 min
Many a young idealist register for law school with visions of Atticus Finch dancing in their heads, but only the rarest few have those dreams come true. NITA Trustee Emeritus and national treasure James Brosnahan is among them. In Episode 49, this legendary legend reflects on a life in law that has included face-to-face encounters with such cognoscenti as Chief Justice Warren Burger, Senator Orrin Hatch, and the Kennedys. He also talks about his viral LinkedIn series on vocal quality and breaks down the six essential qualities of a commanding speaking voice that have served him well over his 60+ years in the courtroom. 4:28 Voice quality videos on LinkedIn 9:05 Evaluating your own voice quality 11:25 Tempo 17:22 Volume 20:53 Tone and mood 25:16 Warmup exercises 28:20 Emphasis and emotion 30:06 Speech harmonizing and collecting voices 35:15 Favorite voices 37:05 Clarity 42:59 Pauses 41:57 Arguing before SCOTUS 52:04 Interrogation by Orrin Hatch 56:21 Controversial representations 1:00:16 Defending the Constitution 1:03:35 Speaking truth to power 1:07:29 Boston Irish and the Kennedy agenda 1:14:39 What Jim has learned at NITA 1:19:03 Signoff questions Quote “The goal, which is not easy, is to be like an actor who can throw the voice up into the second balcony. That’s what you want to do. The equivalent in trial is to be sure that every word that you pronounce is heard by Juror 1 in the back row and Juror 6 in the back row, because if they haven’t heard what you’ve said, it’s like it never happened.” Jim Brosnahan Resources Jim Brosnahan (bio (https://www.mofo.com/people/james-brosnahan)) Jim’s video series (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/jim-brosnahan/)) Justice at Trial: Courtroom Battles and Groundbreaking Cases (book (https://rowman.com/ISBN/9781538174432/Justice-at-Trial-Courtroom-Battles-and-Groundbreaking-Cases)) Publio Delgado, speech harmonizer (YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0T9JHYLQYA))
Not rated yet48. That's Appealing, with Judge Randall Warner
· 51 min
Every trial advocate enters the courtroom hoping for a “one and done” decision that favors their client. But appeals do happen, and if you’re waiting until the verdict is read before you start thinking about what comes next, you’re already bringing up the rear. Judge Randall Warner of the Superior Court of Arizona in Maricopa County joins the podcast to discuss the potential appeal issues you should be thinking about during litigation, the pretrial phase, and at trial; what issues are ripe for appeal (and which ones aren’t) and their impact on your trial strategy; and how to preserve the record for appeal in real time. He also lets you in on what he says are the most undervalued, hence underutilized, tools in your advocacy kit and how you should be using them to your advantage. Topics 3:35 Different considerations for different trials 5:10 Common mistakes 6:13 Basics of appeals 8:59 Reverse-engineering your case 10:24 Appellate specialist on the trial team 11:22 Good appeal issues 13:00 Bundling your issues 14:10 Poor appeal issues 15:06 Pretrial preservation considerations 16:11 Motions in limine} 17:52 Bench memoranda 19:57 Preservation at trial 22:20 Objections and evidence 26:16 Staying in the judge’s good graces 27:17 Jury instructions 31:22 Verdict forms 38:49 Damages 40:38 Bench memorandum for jury instructions 42:12 Motion to acquit 45:26 Career advice to younger self 46:33 Signoff questions Quote “I’m a fan of bundling issues. So, for example, if you’ve got one issue that’s a sufficiency of evidence issue and another that’s a jury instruction issue and a third issue that’s an evidentiary objection or a couple evidentiary objections, and they all point to the same wrong result, those issues — independent of what the standard of review may be on any one of them — kind of work together to create an argument for prejudice for the case overall.” Judge Randall Warner Resources Judge Randall Warner (bio (https://www.superiorcourt.maricopa.gov/JudicialBiographies/judicialBio.asp?jdgID=246&jdgUSID=8675)) “All Mixed Up about Statutes: Distinguishing Interpretation from Application” (article (https://nita.lightning.force.com/lightning/r/Product2/01t8a000008kCadAAE/view)) “All Mixed Up about Mixed Questions” (article (https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/appellate/article/id/2564/)) “Efficiency in Motion” (article (https://iaals.du.edu/sites/default/files/documents/publications/efficiency_in_motion_dispositive_motions.pdf))
Not rated yet47. Beginning the Effective Deposition, with Carl Chamberlin
· 1 hr 26 min
At a time when more cases settle than go to trial, the deposition has become of utmost significance. Our guest Carl Chamberlin draws upon his experience taking and defending depositions in private practice as well as teaching deposition skills for 30 years. As the new author of The Effective Deposition, the topic is top of mind lately for Carl, so he joins us to talk about how to kick off a truly effective deposition with introductory matters and preliminary and substantive questioning techniques—and he even asks a few questions of his own. Topics 3:22 The purpose of depositions 6:20 Difference between gathering information and obtaining information 10:38 Why depositions are important 12:30 Physical settings for remote depositions 14:15 The “usual stipulations” 17:20 Getting commitments 21:27 Commitments in remote depositions 24:42 Preliminary questions 29:51 Structure of substantive questioning 33:30 First demo 36:57 Key phrases for asking open-ended questions 38:25 And ones to avoid 43:01 Drilling down into a substantive topic 44:18 Second demo 1:04:19 Paying attention and listening 1:06:40 Using exhibits 1:10:15 Dealing with interruptions 1:13:56 Carl’s early depositions 1:16:53 The Effective Deposition 1:21:36 Signoff questions Quote “We want to make our questions clear and concise. Simple. The clearer the question, the better the answer. The fewer the objections, the more powerful it is.” Carl Chamberlin Resources Carl Chamberlin (LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/in/carl-chamberlin-6708a525/)) NITA Publications (book (https://www.nita.org/s/category/products/books/0ZG4W000000Pb1xWAC?c__results_layout_state=%7B%7D))
Not rated yet46. The Secrets of Opening Statements, with Brooke Latta
· 35 min
Content Warning: A brief, non-graphic mention of a sex crime case occurring from 29:34 to 30:49. Everyone likes to start off on the right foot, and your opening statement is a crucial place to do it. It’s also Assistant U.S. Attorney Brooke Latta’s favorite part of trial, so she joined the podcast to discuss her best tips on telling the right story, using visual aids for maximum impact, and pulling out all the stops to captivate your jurors. She also talks about some of her own openings at trial and what she holds to be the G.O.A.T. of opening statements. Timestamps & More Topics 3:00 What’s fun about openings? 4:07 Rhetorical and legal goals 6:05 Crafting an opening 8:46 Workshopping it 10:54 Figuring out the right story to tell 13:00 Telling auditory stories for visual consumers 14:36 Some good don’ts 15:30 Visual aids 17:10 Court clearance for visual aids 19:01 Objections 21:53 Case weaknesses 23:50 Closing your opening 24:42 Openings and closings, compare and contrast 26:42 Brooke’s favorite example of a great opening 32:35 Signoff questions Quote “Something I always do is I talk to jurors like they are a friend that I’m having a martini with and I’m sitting across the table from. And I’m just talking to that friend about something that’s a very serious, very important issue — and I’m keeping it simple, I’m keeping it concise — so it’s a serious tone, but it’s casual.” Brooke Latta
Not rated yet45. Courtroom Demeanor, with Shareema Abel
· 50 min
Without a doubt, knowing your client’s case up one side and down the other and understanding and applying the law are critical to your chances of prevailing at trial. But if your demeanor and presentation style lack polish, you might be getting in your own way. Special Counsel to the New York City MTA Inspector General and NITA Program Director Shareema Abel joins May the Record Reflect to talk about courtroom composure, interpersonal conduct, oral advocacy, self-expression, and so much more. Topics 3:05 What is courtroom demeanor? 6:12 Demeanor in challenging situations 8:57 When you know the judge or opposing counsel 12:03 Vocal expression and body language 16:49 Personal style 22:55 Conduct outside the courtroom 26:12 Online proceedings 28:39 Picking yourself up on an off day 32:44 Cross-generational learning at the office 37:45 Neurodivergence 40:16 Feedback on your courtroom demeanor 44:58 Signoff questions Quote “Silence is one of the things that, over the years, I really had to get comfortable with in a courtroom because I remember wanting to fill every second of space and I thought silence was deadly. But as you grow in your career, you realize that you can use silence as a tool, and so oftentimes, especially when you forget a point, it’s ok to have a pregnant pause or use silence, and then return to a podium, to your notes, to remember what you’re saying. Or using silence to make a point after you ask a rhetorical question and using silence when you’re going from topic to topic, because my theory is you should never be talking and moving at the same time.” Shareema Abel Resources Shareema Abel (LinkedIn) NITA Women in Trial (program) Deposition Skills: NYC (program) Building Trial Skills: NYC (program) NITA Women in Trial playlist (Spotify)
Not rated yet