Skip to main content
AmigoFish

63: Lizzie Borden

From Let's Talk Spooky · · 38 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Everybody knows the rhyme. Almost nobody knows the truth. On a mild summer morning in 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were hacked to death inside a locked house on Second Street in Fall River, Massachusetts — and before the police had finished searching for a stranger, the town had already decided who did it. This week we walk through the whole story: the morning of the murders, the cold and comfortless house of a very wealthy man, the shifting testimony, the trial that quietly fell apart, and the acquittal that never really ended. Then we sit with the strangest part of all — how a children's skipping rhyme convicted a woman the court set free, and why we still believe it a hundred and thirty years later.

A story about a hatchet, an inheritance, a house you can still book a room in — and the way a legend can outrun the truth and never look back.

Content note: This episode discusses a real double homicide and describes the injuries involved.

SOURCES & FURTHER READING

- Primary records: Lizzie's inquest testimony & the 1893 trial transcript — famous-trials.com/lizzieborden; witness statements & wills — lizzieandrewborden.com

- Archival: Fall River Historical Society (trial exhibits, crime-scene photos, the Knowlton Papers) — fallriverhistorical.org

- Key books: Cara Robertson, The Trial of Lizzie Borden; Martins & Binette, Parallel Lives (FRHS); Edwin Porter, The Fall River Tragedy (1893, free at gutenberg.org)

- On the hauntings: Joe Nickell, Skeptical Inquirer

Among Others

CONNECT WITH LET'S TALK SPOOKY

- Website: letstalkspooky.com

- Email: ⁠letstalkspookypodcast@gmail.com⁠

- Instagram: @letstalkspookypodcast

- TikTok: @letstalkspookypod

- New episodes every Friday at 8 p.m. EST

If you've got a legend from your corner of the map, send it our way — we read everything.

Stay Curious. Stay Spooky.

Back to Let's Talk Spooky · Report a problem