Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Litigating a Chinese Company’s Inclusion on the Pentagon’s List of Chinese Military-Affiliated Companies

From Law, disrupted · · 33 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

John is joined by Derek Shaffer, partner in Quinn Emanuel’s Washington, D.C., office and Co-Chair of the firm’s Government & Regulatory Litigation practice. They discuss Quinn Emanuel client DJI’s successful legal challenge, the first of its kind, to the U.S. government’s designation of the company as a Chinese military company and the D.C. Circuit’s holding that a court may not credit classified reasoning it has not examined.

DJI is the largest drone maker in the world. It is based in Shenzhen, China, and does not produce military drones. Nonetheless, in 2024, it was placed on the Pentagon’s annual list of Chinese military companies. Appearing on the list bars companies from contracting with the Departments of Defense, Homeland Security, and Energy. The designation also often prompts customers worldwide, including police and rescue agencies, to reconsider doing business with the company. DJI received no advance notice or opportunity to respond to the designation, and its requests for reconsideration went unanswered. After DJI sued at the end of 2024, the Pentagon designated it again in early 2025 on new grounds documented in a partially redacted report.

The D.C. District Court rejected most of the Pentagon’s rationales for the designation, including an inaccurate finding that DJI had a facility in a specified zone, theories of indirect Chinese government investment, and allegations of peripheral ties to the Chinese government. However, the court upheld the designation based on a Chinese government technology award received four years earlier and the claim that DJI’s drones contribute to the Chinese military-industrial base. The documentary support for that claim was classified and redacted. The district court declined to review the document, reasoning that relying on it would deny DJI’s right to adversarial process. However, the court credited the characterizations of the document’s contents in the government’s briefs. The court rejected an offer Quinn Emanuel made to have a team lawyer with security clearance review the classified document.

On appeal, Derek argued before the D.C. Circuit that upholding the listing on unexamined classified reasoning violated black-letter administrative law and due process, citing comments by the Supreme Court expressing its discomfort with undisclosed classified evidence in a case involving TikTok. The D.C. Circuit affirmed in part, rejecting the due process challenge, but held that the district court could not credit the classified rationale without examining it. The case has returned to the district court for further proceedings.

Podcast Link: Law-disrupted.fm (https://law-disrupted.fm/?utm_source=podcast_platform&utm_medium=podcast&utm_campaign=episode&utm_content=episode_info&utm_id=001) Host:John B. Quinn (https://www.johnbquinn.com/) Producer: Alexis Hyde (https://www.alexishyde.com/) Music and Editing by: Alexander Rossi (https://www.alexanderrossi.me/)

Back to Law, disrupted · Report a problem