Why Local Knowledge Beats AI Every Time • Kelsey Caputo
From Keeping It Real Podcast • Secrets Of Top 1% REALTORS ® • Interviews With Real Estate Brokers & Agents · · 43 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Watch this interview on YouTube. (https://youtu.be/e6aEaaWk0Xo)
D.J. Paris sits down with Kelsey Caputo, a fourth-generation Florida Keys resident, licensed general contractor and 2026 NAR 30 Under 30 honoree with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices. They cover what AI gets wrong about Keys waterfront homes, how she uses it to prepare for every appointment, and how she earns the trust of buyers and sellers she may never meet in person.
What you’ll learn
- AI doesn’t know what’s next door. In a market where a waterfront home can sit beside an old mobile home, AI treats nearby sales as comparable when they aren’t. (08:45)
- Get ahead of the AI number. A buyer arrived with an AI suggestion of $800,000 on a home listed at $1.8 million, and Kelsey explains the dock, zoning and rental rules the number ignores. (10:46)
- Look at the house from the outside in. As a general contractor, she checks the roof, windows and sea wall first, because those cost the most. (14:08)
- Say “I don’t know” and connect people. Kelsey says faking it fails with sophisticated clients, and referring them to the right contractor has brought her more clients. (17:54)
- Prep every appointment with AI. She asks what objections and questions a buyer or seller is likely to have before she meets them. (23:17)
“The numbers are always super off. And you never want to argue with the buyer. But what I try to tell buyers is there’s so much that AI doesn’t know yet.”
Kelsey Caputo (at 10:29)
Chapters
00:00 Intro
03:00 Meet Kelsey Caputo
05:32 The Keys market and its buyers
08:29 Why she’s rooting for AI
10:16 The buyer who asked ChatGPT for a fair offer
13:01 What a licensed general contractor sees in a home
17:28 Why she says “I don’t know”
21:15 Winning trust with sellers she has never met
23:05 The prompts she uses before an appointment
25:01 Building a buyer profile for a listing
28:36 Where agents go wrong with AI
33:01 Starting over in a new market
40:45 Homework: ask AI for the objections
This week’s homework
Before your next listing appointment or buyer consultation, open ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini and ask what concerns a seller might have about the property, or what objections a buyer would have in the neighborhood. Pick the objections you are weakest on and prepare your response.
Links from this episode
- Kelsey Caputo’s website (https://kelseycaputorealtor.com/about)
Listen and follow
Listen on Apple Podcasts (https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/id1237389947), Spotify (https://open.spotify.com/show/6lDHbQ8nfuV87QyqiELilc) or YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@keepingitrealpodcast4208). Follow the show on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/topagentinterviews/), Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/keepingitrealpod) and LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/company/27096744/).
This episode is brought to you by Real Geeks (https://www.realgeeks.com/) and Courted.io (https://courted.io/).
Back to Keeping It Real Podcast • Secrets Of Top 1% REALTORS ® • Interviews With Real Estate Brokers & Agents · Report a problem