Skip to main content
AmigoFish

THE BLOODY BENDERS OF KS - The True Story of America's First Serial Killer Family

From Just Killing Time Β· Β· 51 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

πŸ”¨ The Bloody Benders of Kansas: America's First Serial Killer Family | Just Killing Time

The Bloody Benders were a German-speaking family of four β€” Pa, Ma, John Jr., and Kate Bender β€” who ran a roadside inn on the Osage Trail in Labette County, Kansas between 1871 and 1873, and murdered at least eleven travelers before vanishing without a trace. Historians still debate whether their true victim count exceeds twenty. This week on Just Killing Time, host Elizabeth Stanton digs into the full, documented history of the Benders β€” the hammer-and-trapdoor murder method, the disappearance of Dr. William York that finally exposed them, the discovery of "Hell's Half-Acre," and the century-and-a-half-long mystery of what actually happened to the family after they fled Kansas.

🩸 WHAT YOU'LL LEARN IN THIS EPISODE:

β€’ How the Bender family used their cabin's canvas curtain and hidden trapdoor to kill guests seated at their own dinner table

β€’ Why Kate Bender's spiritualist "healing" business β€” she advertised as "Professor Miss Katie Bender" β€” was actually a system for identifying vulnerable travelers

β€’ The full list of known and suspected victims, including George Longcor and his 18-month-old daughter, Mary Ann

β€’ How Dr. William York's disappearance β€” and his brother Colonel Alexander York's manhunt β€” finally brought the Benders' killing spree to an end

β€’ What searchers found when they dug up the Bender property's orchard, garden, and well in May 1873

β€’ The competing theories on the Benders' fate: vigilante lynching, escape to the Texas–New Mexico border, or something else entirely

β€’ The 1889 Michigan trial of two women accused of being Ma and Kate Bender β€” and why it collapsed

β€’ A real hidden-history connection to Laura Ingalls Wilder and the Little House on the Prairie family, who lived near the Bender inn

β€’ How the Bender case still fascinates true crime historians today, including a modern-day University of Kansas excavation of the property

This case has been called America's first documented serial killings, and it happened along a trail some of you have quite literally driven past on Highway 400 near Cherryvale, Kansas β€” closer to home than you might think. 🌾

πŸ‘» Got your own Time Killer File? Kansas frontier history, Osage Trail family stories, or your own true crime theories β€” I want to hear them. Email me directly, and you might hear your story on a future episode.

🎧 New episodes of Just Killing Time with Elizabeth Stanton drop weekly β€” true crime, conspiracies, and hidden history from the heart of Kansas and beyond.

πŸ“Œ Sources referenced include the Kansas Historical Society, Kansas Memory archives, University of Kansas / Kansas Geological Survey field research, and period newspaper accounts from 1873–1890.

#BloodyBenders #TrueCrimePodcast #KansasHistory #KateBender #SerialKillerHistory #OsageTrail #LabetteCounty #CherryvaleKansas #AmericasFirstSerialKillers #HiddenHistory #TrueCrimeCommunity #JustKillingTime #KansasTrueCrime #FrontierCrime #ColdCase

Back to Just Killing Time Β· Report a problem