Skip to main content
AmigoFish

I TOLD YOU I WOULD KILL HIM - The Lobster Boy Murders - Episode 2

From Just Killing Time · · 43 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

A jury convicted him of murder. Then a judge asked the state where to put him, and the state said it couldn't take him.

Pittsburgh. September 27, 1978. A fifteen-year-old named Donna Stiles buys her wedding dress at the Allegheny Center Mall with her stepmother and her eighteen-year-old fiancé. The ceremony is the next morning. Eight hours later that boy is dead on the sidewalk in front of her, and her father is watching from the living room window.

His name was Jack Layne. He was eighteen. He lived four blocks away on Peralta Street on Pittsburgh's North Side. And twenty-four hours before he died, Grady Stiles Jr. had pulled a gun out of his wheelchair, pointed it at him in front of a witness, and told him he would not live to marry his daughter.

Jack Layne heard that. And the next afternoon he went dress shopping with the man's daughter and then walked into that man's house anyway, because he was eighteen years old and he thought he could get her out.

This is the second of three episodes, and it is not really about a shooting. The shooting takes ninety seconds, and there was never any question who did it — Stiles told police "take me, I'm ready" and gave a full confession on the spot. This episode is about the five months afterward, when the American legal system looked at a man it had just convicted of murder and could not work out what a punishment even was.

After the verdict, a newspaper reporter walked into the judge's chambers and asked how he intended to punish this guy. The judge said he hadn't thought about it. What happened next set the fuse for everything in Episode Three.

IN THIS EPISODE 00:00 — Foreland Street. September 27, 1978. 06:00 — Welcome in, and a catch-up if you're starting here 09:00 — The girl who wanted out: who Donna Stiles was 18:00 — Jack Layne: the person nobody writes about 24:00 — The house on Foreland Street 31:00 — The escalation: the pawn shop, the six days, the phone call 40:00 — "Take me, I'm ready" 45:00 — The strangest trial in Pittsburgh 53:00 — "I hadn't thought of that" 61:00 — Where everybody went 66:00 — Time Killer Files 68:00 — Close

WHAT YOU'LL LEARN Why a fifteen-year-old girl treated marriage as an escape route, and what her father's own defense attorney said about that household. The three-week escalation the prosecution built its case on. What third-degree murder means in Pennsylvania. Why the guilty-plea version of this story that circulates online is wrong. Why a Pittsburgh courtroom in February 1979 filled up with sideshow performers as character witnesses. And how a man convicted of murder came to serve zero days in custody.

SOURCES Pittsburgh Post-Gazette archive reporting, including interviews with prosecutor Robert Vincler, defense attorney Anthony DeCello, and reporters Gabriel Ireton and Paul Maryniak. Post-Gazette contemporaneous trial coverage from February 1979. The Associated Press. Fred Rosen, "Lobster Boy" (1995). Joe Nickell, "Secrets of the Sideshows" (University Press of Kentucky, 2005).

Where the sources conflict, I say so on the record and tell you which way I lean and why.

TIME KILLER FILES Jack Layne was eighteen years old. He lived at 1041 Peralta Street and he had a sister in the neighborhood. He is the only person in this entire story who did nothing wrong, and there is not one paragraph written about his life anywhere I can find. If you know anything about him, or about the Layne family, please reach out. I would like to fix that.

ABOUT Just Killing Time with Elizabeth Stanton covers true crime, conspiracies, and hidden history — researched properly and told straight. Hosted from Derby, Kansas.

Follow the show so the finale arrives automatically. And if this one stayed with you, a rating and a review is the single biggest thing you can do to help somebody else find it.

Content note: this episode discusses homicide and domestic violence.

Back to Just Killing Time · Report a problem