Episode 004: Too Close to Call
From Joshua Unfiltered · · 11 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Contact: joshua@joshuaunfiltered.com
Thirteen days before Election Day, Sir Joshua The Historian tells the story of America's disputed elections. It begins in 1800, when the Jefferson–Burr tie forced the first peaceful transfer of power between parties — what Jefferson himself called a revolution that saved the republic. Then 1876, when Samuel Tilden won the people and lost the presidency by one electoral vote; 1960, when Richard Nixon had grounds to fight and refused; and 2000, when 537 Florida votes and a 5–4 Supreme Court ruling decided it all. The machinery gets patched after every crisis — but each crisis truly ended the same way: with the loser choosing the country.
From the host's own coursework: Sir Joshua's essay "What changed, and what did not change, with the election of Thomas Jefferson to the presidency in 1800?" — arguing that 1800 was a revolution that saved the republic — is published with this episode: https://media.joshuaunfiltered.com/notes/episode-004-election-of-1800-essay.pdf (Sources cited: Joanne B. Freeman, "Affairs of Honor"; Mel Laracey, "The Presidential Newspaper as an Engine of Early American Political Development," 2008.) The episode's account of the party press also draws on the host's Week 5 coursework and Jeffrey L. Pasley, "The Two National 'Gazettes': Newspapers and the Embodiment of American Political Parties" (2000).
Theme music: "Americana" (intro) and "Deliberate Thought" (outro) by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0.
Support: https://joshuaunfiltered.com/support Glossary: https://joshuaunfiltered.com/glossary