We Should've Had Shovels For Hands
From It‘s Probably (not) Aliens! · · 2 hr 4 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Ancient Aliens wants you to believe the Toba super-eruption 74,000 years ago was an alien population cull, a "cosmic reset button" to wipe out noisy, rebellious humanity 1.0 and replace us with a genetically upgraded, obedient slave race that then built all the pyramids. Tristan walks Scott through the claim piece by piece: the Anunnaki population control panic, the inside-job volcano theory, the genetic upgrade fiction, and the "chosen survivors in alien bunkers" arc, tracing every beat back to a Babylonian myth, a long-debunked bottleneck estimate, and Helena Blavatsky's "root races" (which, spoiler, the Nazis loved).
Then things get current. The same bunker-survivor fantasy powers Mark Zuckerberg's $270 million underground Hawaiian compound, Peter Thiel's New Zealand escape hatches, longtermism, elite pronatalism, and the eco-fascist "humans are the virus" meme that crawled out of 2020. Douglas Rushkoff calls it The Mindset: accumulate enough capital to personally exit the world you helped break. The actual archaeology from Shinfa Metema 1 shows the opposite: Toba survivors made it through not with bunkers but with bow-and-arrow tech, flexible diets, river-corridor mobility, and long-distance obsidian trade networks. Cooperation, not seclusion.
Plus: why Scott thought "Koolau Ranch" was a salad dressing, a sustained argument that every geological term in this episode should be a AAA video game, Candace Owens' theory that Charlie Kirk was a Project Looking Glass time traveller, and Scott's final episode before paternity leave. Build your obsidian handshake network before you need it.
Content note: Discussion of eugenics, eco-fascism, and Malthusian "population control" rhetoric throughout.
Get new episodes early and support the show on Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/probsnotaliens) and Nebula! (https://nebula.tv/probablynotaliens)
Subscribe to It's Probably (not) Aliens for weekly episodes about cool ancient history! And give us a 5-star review if you have the time. It really helps us out!
Tristan Johnson Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/stepback.nebula.tv) | Twitter (https://twitter.com/TristanPEJ) | YouTube (http://www.stepbackhistory.com/)
Scott Niswander Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/scottniswander.bsky.social) | Twitter (https://twitter.com/scottniswander) | YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/user/NerdSyncProductions)
Follow the show on Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/probsnotaliens.bsky.social) or Twitter (https://twitter.com/ProbsNotAliens) for more updates!
Ask us questions and send us topics to talk about at ProbsNotAliens.com (https://probsnotaliens.com/)
Music by Rod Kim (https://rodkim.com/) | Cover art by Skutch (https://twitter.com/Skutchdraws) | Edited by Max
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.