Pizza Passion: How a Food Cart Built Pupatella's VPN-Certified Empire
From Industry Night with Nycci Nellis · · 1 hr 13 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
There is a wood fired oven at Pupatella in the Mosaic District built with bricks that came straight from Mount Vesuvius, and a pizza comes out of it in about 90 seconds. What took almost twenty years is everything around it. I went out to Merrifield to sit with the two men who built that, and yes, I ate very well while I did it.
Every independent operator eventually hits the same wall. You are the product. You are behind the counter, you know every regular's order, and the whole thing only works because you are standing there. Enzo Algarme hit that wall and said so out loud, to a stranger, over breakfast. What happened next is the part almost nobody gets to hear, and if you are trying to grow anything in the hospitality industry without wrecking what made it good, this chef interview podcast episode is the most useful hour you will spend this week.
Enzo Algarme came to Northern Virginia from Naples to play soccer and study medicine, and ended up selling Neapolitan pizza out of a cart in Ballston in 2007 because he could not find the food he grew up on. He named it after his grandmother. Michael Berger spent a decade building Elevation Burger and its supply chain before an attorney they happened to share put the two of them in a room together. Today Pupatella is twelve locations across Virginia, Maryland and DC, and the largest group of VPN certified Neapolitan pizzerias in the country.
Key Takeaways - Enzo built a pizza cart because no landlord in Arlington would rent a restaurant to a man with no money in the bank and no restaurant experience.
- VPN certification meant an inspector flew in and worked alongside Enzo for two days before Pupatella got its number, and the standard is still audited today by video.
- Michael replaced a seven distributor supply chain with one national distributor in about seven months without changing a single ingredient on the pizza.
- The hardest part of scaling was not the pizza, it was writing down what Enzo already knew in his hands so that anyone else could be trained on it.
- Pupatella has not raised prices in nearly two years, because buying power on artisan ingredients grew faster than the cost of those ingredients did.
Enzo Algarme said, "My concern was always how do I replicate myself?"
Michael Berger said, "We wanted to be the neighborhood pizzeria but with our Neapolitan flair."
Timestamps
00:00 A wood fired oven, Mount Vesuvius bricks, and 90 second pizza 02:04 How Nycci finally crossed the river to Pupatella 03:19 Naples to Northern Virginia for soccer, then medicine, then neither 05:36 Sunday lunch at his grandmother's table 07:22 Nobody would rent him a restaurant, so he built a cart 09:24 What actually makes a Neapolitan pizza 12:05 Sourcing an oven from Naples and the volcanic stone floor 13:47 Fried street snacks, rice balls, and the first Arlington menu 15:04 Fig and Pig, before unusual toppings were normal 18:11 Michael's road from real estate to Elevation Burger 21:19 The attorney who put them in a room together 25:08 Protecting the product while rebuilding the supply chain 28:43 VPN certification, buffalo mozzarella, and the numbered stores 32:24 Site selection, and why they refused to chase one market 41:06 The hardest part was replicating a person, not a recipe 46:13 What happened to the Dupont Circle location 49:35 Delivery apps, catering, and the price tolerance conversation 56:00 Rapid fire: pineapple, supply chain scares, one ingredient 1:02:23 Pizza masterclass with Chef Enzo 1:12:03 Outro
Connect with Enzo Algarme and Michael Berger Website:https://www.pupatella.com/Instagram:https://www.instagram.com/pupatella_pizza/