Skip to main content
AmigoFish

How Did We Get Here? The History Behind What We Practice | Sheva Deren

From Human & Holy · · 47 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

How did Jewish life come to take the shape we know today? In this conversation, Sheva Deren, a Jewish history teacher in Melbourne, Australia, talks about the upheavals, choices, and debates that shaped Jewish practice.

We explore the Second Temple era, the development of the Jewish calendar and oral law, and the ways halacha (Jewish law) has responded to changing realities. Who gets to decide how Judaism evolves? What is the balance between protecting inherited practice and finding creative responses to new circumstances? And why do certain visible practices, like modesty, receive so much cultural attention in modern Jewish life?

This conversation explores what our ancestors have given us, how questions and disagreements help make the halachic system a living, breathing thing, and why knowing the history behind familiar practices can make them feel more alive.

Support Human & Holy for $18/month at humanandholy.com/join and receive bonus virtual events and resources!

* * * * * * *

A few factual clarifications from the episode: The reference to the sage who calculated the calendar should be Hillel HaSheni, not Hillel HaZaken. The rabbi who debated Saadia Gaon was Aaron ben Meir, in 924 CE. The tefillah directed to the angels is called Machnisei Rachamim.

To inquire about sponsorship & advertising opportunities, please email us at info@humanandholy.com

To support our work, visit humanandholy.com/sponsor.

Find us on Instagram @humanandholy & subscribe to our channel to stay up to date on all our upcoming conversations ✨

Human & Holy podcast is available on all podcast streaming platforms. New episodes every Sunday & Wednesday on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and Google Podcasts.

* * * * * * *

TIMESTAMPS:

00:00 Episode introduction

01:41 Sheva’s path into teaching

03:11 Leaving one chapter and building a new life in Melbourne

06:12 The freedom to try a different path

07:44 Why the Second Temple era fascinates Sheva

11:02 Competing visions of Jewish continuity

12:15 Why rabbinic Judaism became the path most Jews followed

14:14 Jewish life in Babylonia and the question of the new moon

18:09 Calendar disagreements and the practice of Pesach

20:15 How Jewish history helps students connect to their identity

21:47 How Halacha encounters new realities, including IVF

24:45 A halachic responsum on keeping Pesach under persecution in Spain

28:31 Disagreement over prayer and the role of angels

31:50 The Ramban, debate, and the role of questions

34:07 Are we obsessed with modesty?

39:02 Safety and the history of Jewish poetry

41:25 Is there a correlation between emancipation and assimilation?

44:11 Why Jewish history matters to Jewish identity

45:54 Sheva’s message to the women who came before her

47:02 Closing message to listeners

Back to Human & Holy · Report a problem