Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Ep. 144- Who Killed Mandy Stavik? SOLVED After 30 Years

From Hold My Sweet Tea · · 43 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Send us Fan Mail (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2444974/fan_mail/new)

A quiet Washington town goes from “we don’t lock our doors” to “we don’t know who to trust” in a matter of hours. Mandy Stavik is 18, athletic, full of life, and headed out for a run with the family German Shepherd the day after Thanksgiving 1989. Kira comes back without her, and the search turns into a nightmare that lingers for decades.

We walk you through what investigators could piece together early on, including the unsettling scene where Mandy is found in shallow river water and the first-wave DNA evidence sent to the FBI at a time when forensic DNA testing is still new. With no database match and years of leads going nowhere, the case becomes the definition of a cold case, one that reshapes how an entire community sees itself.

Then the story takes a turn that feels almost impossible until you hear the details: a later detective-led DNA sweep, a local man who refuses to give police his DNA, and a bakery manager named Kim Wagner who realizes she may be standing near the only break investigators have left. One thrown-away water cup becomes the missing link, and the DNA match finally puts a name to the unknown male profile. We also dig into the arrest, the shifting explanations, the trial testimony that undercuts the alibi, and the lasting impact Mandy’s name now carries through a scholarship fund.

If you care about true crime, cold cases, DNA evidence, and the real people who live with unanswered questions, you’ll want to hear this one. Subscribe, share the episode with a friend, and leave us a review, then tell us what you think: would you have taken the risk to help solve it?

Back to Hold My Sweet Tea · Report a problem