Podcast episode 48: A History of Modern Linguistics
From History and Philosophy of the Language Sciences · · 28 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In this interview, Randy Harris interviews James McElvenny about his recent book A History of Modern Linguistics.
https://hiphilangsci.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/covers.png
Download (https://hiphilangsci.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/hiphilangsci_048i-ohne.mp3) | Spotify (https://open.spotify.com/show/37JY0M7i0xWqSd32H4fQ1k) | Apple Podcasts (https://podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/history-and-philosophy-of-the-language-sciences/id1493202023) | YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@hiphilangsci)
References for Episode 48
McElvenny, James. 2024. A History of Modern Linguistics: From the beginnings to World War II. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
McElvenny, James. 2025. Entstehung und Entwicklung der modernen Linguistik: Von den Anfängen bis zum Zweiten Weltkrieg. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Transcript by Luca Dinu
JMc: Hi, I’m James McElvenny, and you’re listening to the History and Philosophy of the Language Sciences Podcast, online at hiphilangsci.net. [00:28] There you can find links and references to all the literature we discuss. [00:32] Today we’re going to try something new, and that is that I’m going to become the interviewee, [00:38] so our interviewer today is Randy Harris, and I’ll throw over to him right away, and he can take us from here. [00:45]
RH: Thanks, James. [00:46] Just to dispel the mystery for everybody as to why we’ve switched over, it’s because we’re going to get a chance to talk about your fairly recent book, A History of Linguistics: From the Beginnings to World War II, and I’m really pleased to have the opportunity. [00:59] It’s a great book. [01:00] It’d be a great textbook because it’s a smooth, efficient read but still quite detailed for students’ needs, but also just a really interesting read for linguists in general. [01:11] I learned a lot, and I’m sure everybody would. [01:15] I also wanted to mention, before we get started, another podcast that most listeners probably know about, Ingrid Piller’s Language on the Move. [01:23] The April 10th episode back in 2024 also was about your book, and I’d recommend people go listen to that. [01:29] There’ll be some overlap obviously, but lots of new stuff as well, so… [01:34] All right, let’s get started. [01:36] We’ll start with the most obvious question: What are the beginnings, and what is it that begins? [01:42] You start with William Jones’ 1786 lecture to the Asiatic Society of Calcutta, which is a familiar starting point for the history of modern linguistics, but then you set it aside fairly quickly, so why don’t you tell us what begins and when it begins? [02:00]
JMc: My book is really about the academic discipline of linguistics, and that starts when linguistics becomes institutionalized in universities. It becomes a subject with professors, students, textbooks, and so on. [02:14] This institutionalization happened in Germany in the early 19th century, when the first professorships for comparative grammar were created. [02:22] I believe Franz Bopp was the first to have this descriptor in his job title when he was called to the University of Berlin in 1821, [02:31] but as your question implies, historical-comparative linguistics has generally, in the received historiography, been cast as the first scientific linguistics. [02:43] This is a narrative you can hear even from the mid-19th century, when comparative linguistics was a young field, but it can be doubted whether comparative linguistics was really something revolutionary that swept away everything that came before. [02:58] Comparative linguistics didn’t come out of nowhere. [03:01] It had predecessors, and the approaches that came before it had their own scholarly and scientific validity. [03:09] My scepticism about the received narrative is not new, I should say. [03:13] Anna Morpurgo Davies, in her history of linguistics in the 19th century, also highlights it. And Anna Morpurgo Davies’ work was a major source for me in writing that book, and an inspiration for me in how to…
Back to History and Philosophy of the Language Sciences · Report a problem