
Hillbilly Crime Investigates
Elizabeth JonesAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Daily
- Typical length:
- about 15 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
Hillbilly Crime is an independent Appalachian investigative podcast hosted by Elizabeth Jones. From the mountains of Eastern Kentucky, we dive deep into crime, corruption, power, and the real stories affecting rural communities that rarely make national headlines.
As a single mom in recovery building an investigative media network from my living room, this podcast follows the truth wherever it leads — from courtroom documents and public records to the lived experiences of people in Appalachia.
If you believe small towns deserve real journalism, you’re in the right place.
Covers: true crime, investigative journalism, appalachian communities, court trials, public corruption, criminal justice, christian prophecy, rural kentucky
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at anchor.fm. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
Hillbilly Crime is an independent investigative podcast from Eastern Kentucky that examines crime, corruption and power in rural Appalachia. Recent episodes cover a murder trial involving Sonia Exelby, the shooting of a district judge in Letcher County, Kentucky, and a fatal stabbing in Elko, Nevada.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- Week In Review
Both cover: public corruption, criminal justice, true crime - Dead Serious
Both cover: court trials, criminal justice, true crime - The Weekly Rap Sheet
Both cover: court trials, true crime
Similar shows
Explore more
Episodes
What Convicted Richard Allen?
· 1 hr 55 min
In this video, the host of Hillbilly Crime provides an introduction to the Delphi murders case (3:52 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=232s)), focusing on the 2017 deaths of Abby Williams and Libby German and the subsequent investigation that led to the conviction of Richard Allen (10:07 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=607s), 1:12:06 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=4326s)). Key elements covered include: - The Crime: The two girls went missing on February 13, 2017, after visiting trails near the Monan High Bridge and were found deceased the next day (14:19 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=859s), 28:26 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=1706s)). - Bridge Guy: Libby German captured footage of a man on the bridge before they were taken; this recording became a central piece of evidence (9:17 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=557s), 29:13 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=1753s)). - Investigation and Arrest: Richard Allen spoke to police in 2017 but was not arrested until 2022 after a volunteer, Kathy Shank, discovered old, misfiled paperwork (36:40 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=2200s), 46:48 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=2808s)). - Evidence: The prosecution utilized a Sig Sauer pistol found at Allen's home, which they claimed matched a cartridge discovered near the bodies, and recordings of Allen's prison calls (39:17 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=2357s), 40:48 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=2448s), 58:16 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=3496s)). - Verdict and Sentence: Richard Allen was convicted on November 11, 2024, and sentenced to 130 years in prison (1:05:21 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=3921s), 1:12:06 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=4326s)). His defense team is currently challenging the conviction through the appellate process (1:12:31 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=4351s)). The host expresses a personal belief in Allen's innocence, suggesting Ron Logan as an alternative person of interest, and outlines plans for future episodes to examine the evidence and trial details more deeply (10:13 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=613s), 11:01 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=661s), 11:46 (https://www.youtube.com/live/nlcwXhdH2IU?t=706s)).
Not rated yetThe Truck Search Found a Broken Necklace. The Cross Asked What Was Missing.
· 10 min
They collected the broken necklace. Was it ever tested? Sgt. Jamie Pearston says she did not submit it for testing. Asked whether somebody else did, she says she doesn’t know. That leaves me wanting the person or lab record that can answer it. She also describes blood-like staining and areas of the truck where she found no blood. The prosecution asks whether rain could remove evidence; she says yes. I want those findings and that answer in front of us before deciding what the truck examination tells us. What record would answer the necklace question: an evidence submission, a lab report or both? Come work through the evidence with us on Hillbilly Crime Time. Holler Sleuths memberships help keep the nightly show on. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yetThe Call Times Didn’t Display. Here’s How Police Recovered Them.
· 8 min
Same phone extraction. Updated software. Now the call times show up. Robert Criscione says the original phone report wasn’t displaying call dates and times. He rebuilt the report with updated Cellebrite software using the same raw extraction from May 2023. Put the old report beside the new one—that’s what I’d want to see. Which fields changed on the page, and what was already in the extracted data? Criscione explains the software issue and how he matched phone numbers to contact names. The defense asked no questions. What would you compare first in the old and new reports to check that explanation? Join us on Hillbilly Crime Time as we work through the testimony. The Holler Sleuths help support the nightly show through memberships. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yetWhat Police Asked Cooper—and What They Didn’t
· 9 min
Police went to speak with Cooper. Did they ask him about drinking? Detective Tyler Bastos says he did not believe he asked about drinking, and he did not seek a blood or urine test. By then, multiple hours had passed. That made me stop. I want to know what officers asked, what Cooper answered and how long it took to get to that interview. Bastos explains how the hospital interviews led police to Cooper; the defense questions the delay and the questions that weren’t asked. His testimony runs across both recorded trial days. What follow-up would you have wanted at that interview, based on what Bastos says officers knew then? We’re going witness by witness on Hillbilly Crime Time. Come back for the nightly show; join the Holler Sleuths if you’d like to support it. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yetA Worn Boot Is Evidence. But What Can This Detective Say It Means?
· 9 min
The judge stops to clarify the wording while Detective Matthew Harrington is showing Sophie’s boot. Harrington collected and preserved evidence from the hospital, including clothing, the boot and a phone. The defense asks about his training to interpret the marks. I want to know how we get from what’s visible on the leather to an explanation of how it got there. Harrington wasn’t the collision reconstructionist or a pattern-recognition expert. That tells me to look for who did the further examination and what they could establish. What examination would you want before describing that wear as a mark from this incident? Follow Hillbilly Crime Time for more from the witness stand. Holler Sleuths memberships support our nightly show. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yetHe Had Two Versions.” Sophie’s Brother Explains—and Faces Cross
· 9 min
“He had two versions.” I want to hear exactly what those two versions were. Sophie’s brother, Jackson R., remembers differences in the location and speed Cooper described. On cross, the defense challenges whether he is describing conflicting accounts or separate parts of what happened. Jackson agrees he wasn’t in the truck. So I want y’all to hear the cross too. Before I call two statements a contradiction, I want the actual words side by side and to know whether they describe the same moment. After hearing the cross, which specific detail still sounds inconsistent to you? Bring your questions to the nightly Hillbilly Crime Time show. If you’d like to help support that work, our membership community is the Holler Sleuths. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yetSophie’s Father Explains Why They Drove Her to the ER
· 9 min
He woke up to his wife screaming. Then he was trying to get his daughter to the hospital. Scott R. describes the night Sophie came home and the family’s decision to drive her to Bristol Hospital after calling 911. He also tells the court he can’t put an exact number of minutes on everything. I wouldn’t expect a frightened parent to be counting seconds. I still want the times checked against the calls and hospital records. His uncertainty is part of what he told the jury, and it belongs in the conversation. The defense declined to question him. What recorded time would help most here: the 911 call, their departure or their arrival at the ER? We work through testimony like this on Hillbilly Crime Time every night. Follow along, or join the Holler Sleuths to support the show. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yet“You Weren’t Stopped?” Sophie’s Mother Explains the Hospital Call
· 11 min
Her daughter is in the ER. The doctors need answers. So she calls Cooper. Sophie’s mother, Lynn R., says she needed to know what had happened before Sophie came home. Then comes her question about the truck: “You weren’t stopped?” That’s the exchange I want to sit with. Lynn can tell us what she saw at home, what she did to get help and what she says Cooper told her. She wasn’t there for the ride. I’d put her account beside the recorded calls before trying to fill in those minutes myself. Which part of Lynn’s account would you check against the 911 call first? Come sit in with us on Hillbilly Crime Time for the nightly show. Holler Sleuths memberships help keep it going. Cooper Ouellette trial, concerning the death of Sophie R., 17. Recorded Oct. 29–30, 2026; Ouellette had pleaded not guilty. Edited excerpts, sometimes reordered. Source: Court TV. #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #SophieR #TrialTestimony
Not rated yetPolice Came Back With Questions for Cooper
· 7 min
Officers speak with Cooper Ouellette about the previous night. Listen to the questions they ask and the account he gives as we follow the sequence in the Sophie case. The companion video shows the encounter around the truck when he brought her home. #HillbillyCrime #HillbillyCrimeTime #CooperOuellette #Bodycam
Not rated yetMichael McKinney; The DNA Tales.
· 1 hr 27 min
- In this episode of Hillbilly Crime, host Elizabeth provides a detailed breakdown of the ongoing legal case surrounding the death of Amber Spradlin, who was found dead in Floyd County, Kentucky, in June 2023 (0:03 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=3s) - 4:27 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=267s)). Case Overview and Key Figures: - The Defendants: Michael "MK" McKinney III faces a murder charge and complicity to tampering with evidence. His father, Dr. Michael McKinney II, and Josh Mullins are also charged with evidence tampering (5:21 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=321s) - 15:57 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=957s)). - The Witness: Roy Kidd, a friend who was with Amber on the night of the incident, is frequently mentioned in defense arguments, though he is not a defendant (6:15 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=375s) - 16:31 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=991s)). - The Legal Proceedings: The case is being presided over by Special Judge Eddie Coleman, with Brent Turner serving as the Commonwealth's attorney and Stephen Romines representing MK (16:39 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=999s) - 19:35 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=1175s)). Key Dispute Areas: - Emergency Response: The family and the public have questioned the handling of 911 calls from the night of the incident, leading to a separate civil lawsuit (30:07 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=1807s) - 36:34 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=2194s)). - Evidence Tampering Allegations: The prosecution alleges the removal of clothing, cleaning of blood, destruction of surveillance equipment, and the planting of a fake knife to misdirect the investigation (37:03 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=2223s) - 44:44 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=2684s)). - DNA Evidence Battle: A major focal point of the recent hearing was the defense's request for changes to MK's pre-trial conditions based on new DNA results, which they argue point toward Roy Kidd. The Commonwealth countered this by labeling the defense's interpretation as "selective" and highlighting evidence that excludes Kidd (53:58 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=3238s) - 1:15:46 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=4546s)). Outcome of the Hearing:Following the October 30 hearing, Judge Eddie Coleman immediately denied the defense motions for bond and home incarceration modifications (1:16:41 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=4601s) - 1:16:55 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=4615s)). The jury trial is currently scheduled for January 11, 2027 (1:15:46 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=4546s) - 1:16:01 (https://www.youtube.com/live/XoTe8yTTeLY?t=4561s)). -
Not rated yet