Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Untold Story of U.S. Intelligence, Part III: The Civil War & Reconstruction (A Heroes' Path Webinar with Jeff Steinberg)

From Heroes' Path Podcast · · 1 hr 2 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Here’s a fact I did not know until last Thursday night: in 1863, at the height of the Civil War, a foreign navy sailed into New York and San Francisco carrying sealed orders. Those orders, if opened, would have placed the entire fleet under the command of Abraham Lincoln.

It was front-page news in every major paper on both coasts. Then it vanished from the story we tell ourselves about the war.

That’s one of perhaps a dozen moments in this session where I found myself saying, out loud, “I had no idea.” If you’ve followed the first two parts of Jeff Steinberg’s series, you know that’s the whole point. Jeff goes past the textbook version and into the letters, the reports, the newspaper archives, and comes back with something richer and stranger every time.

Part III is the strongest yet. It’s also the one with the hardest lesson.

A war on two fronts

We think of the Civil War as North versus South. Jeff makes the case that it was something bigger: the third and final war for American independence. While the armies fought in Virginia and along the Mississippi, a second, quieter war was being waged across the Atlantic, where Britain and France were actively looking for a pretext to break the Union apart and reclaim a foothold in North America.

The Union’s answer was a spy network run out of embassies in London, Liverpool, Brussels, and St. Petersburg, staffed by diplomats who were not really diplomats. On the other side, the Confederacy’s man in London was running a shadow navy out of British shipyards. His name will surprise you. So will his nephew’s.

I won’t spoil how the European front was won. But it involved an abolitionist ambassador, a Russian tsar, and a conversation that may have shaped the timing of the Emancipation Proclamation.

The First All-Source Intelligence Organization in American History

Back home, the early war went badly, and Jeff is unsparing about why. The Union commander was relying on a private contractor for his intelligence, and that contractor kept telling him what he wanted to hear. Opportunities to end the war early were thrown away on the basis of enemy troop counts that were pure fiction.

What replaced that was built by a New York lawyer almost nobody has heard of. In a matter of months he assembled scouts, cavalry, balloons, signal corps, systematic prisoner debriefings, and a small team of analysts cross-checking every source against every other. It was the first time an American army could truly see the battlefield in front of it, and Jeff walks through exactly how that edge decided Gettysburg.

The most important source in that network wasn’t a balloon or a cavalry scout. It was the men and women the Confederacy had enslaved. One Confederate general wrote a bitter letter to Jefferson Davis describing what he called an “omnipresent spy system” that his army had no way to guard against. Jeff reads it aloud during our webinar. Listen for it.

And then there’s the woman in Richmond, and the freed slave she placed inside the Confederate White House. I’ll leave that one entirely to Jeff.

What Happens When You Throw It All Away

Within a year of Appomattox, the Union Army went from two million soldiers to 54,000. The intelligence bureau that won the war was dismantled. The men who built it went on to build railroads and run ports. We had done exactly the same thing after the Revolution, and we were about to pay for it exactly the same way.

Into that vacuum came the Klan, an insurgency across the South, and a decade-long fight to hold Reconstruction together with a fraction of the tools the country had just proven it knew how to build. Jeff traces that fight through the Freedmen’s Bureau, which quietly became something more than a relief agency, through the first presidential impeachment, and finally to the election of 1876, where a backroom deal ended Reconstruction and the promise of equal citizenship for the better part of a century.

He closes with two chapters I’d never encountered: a…

Back to Heroes' Path Podcast · Report a problem