Podcast #1271: Consumer Reports HDTV Ratings
From HDTV and Home Theater Podcast · · 36 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
On this week's show we take a look at the consumer reports ratings for 70 inch and larger TVs. We also read your email and take a look at the week's news.
News:
- Your Google Home can now take orders from Claude and other AI agents
- Roku Adds 30 New Bundles To Premium Subscriptions
- Element Launches New TiVo-Powered Smart TVs in the U.S.
- Paramount Settles States' Antitrust Suit, Clearing Way for Warner Megadeal
Consumer Reports Ratings for 70-inch and larger TVs: On this week's show we take a look at the consumer reports rating for 70 inch and larger TVs. This list was sent to us by Dermot who thought it may make a nice topic. We took the list and only updated pricing. So how does Consumer Reports determine a score for their TV ratings?
Consumer Reports builds each TV's Overall Score from three buckets: lab performance, member surveys, and (for smart TVs) privacy/security. They do not accept manufacturer samples. Secret shoppers buy the sets at retail so they test the same units you would buy.
They run 200+ TVs a year. Each set goes through 20+ tests and more than 500 data points in their Yonkers labs. Picture settings are optimized with the on-screen user controls only—not a full professional calibration. If a set needs a calibrator to look good, that hurts it.
What the lab actually measures
- HD and UHD picture quality — test patterns plus real movie/TV clips for detail, black level, contrast, and color accuracy after the set is optimized.
- HDR — peak brightness (measured with a Photo Research PR-740 spectroradiometer), plus how well highlights and shadows hold up in dark and bright scenes.
- Viewing angle — color and contrast from both horizontal and vertical off-axis positions.
- Motion blur — how clean moving text and action stay.
- Sound quality — built-in speakers: clarity, bass, volume range, and distortion, compared against reference sets in the lab.
- Features / versatility — inputs, smart-TV functions, ease of use, etc.
- Data privacy and data security — whether the TV collects extra data, how easy it is to control that, encryption, known vulnerabilities, update practices. These scores are folded into the Overall Score.
A viewing panel then watches real content side-by-side after the meter work is done.
Survey piece
Predicted reliability and owner satisfaction come from CR member surveys, not from the lab unit they bought.
- Reliability is brand-level, not model-level. A statistical model estimates the chance a new set from that brand will have a problem in the first five years. They control for age, how often it's used, and whether it has an extended warranty.
- Owner satisfaction is how likely members are to recommend that brand. It is weighted at 5% of the Overall Score for every product category.
- Reliability's weight varies by category (typically 10–20%). For TVs it sits toward the lower end of that range because members rate reliability about even with picture performance.
If a brand scores Poor or Fair on predicted reliability, that model cannot get a CR "Recommended" badge, no matter how well it tested.
When they don't have enough survey data for a brand (like on some Roku sets), they plug in category-average survey scores.
How it becomes one number
Overall Score is a weighted mix of the lab scores plus those two survey scores (and privacy/security). Models are then ranked against others in the same size group.
That's why two 91-point sets can sit at very different prices: one won on lab performance plus surveys at a lower street price; the other is a more expensive flagship that still maxed the same scoring formula.
Brand Model Overall Score Price LG (https://amzn.to/4AqPC9R) OLED77C5PUA 91 $1,800 Samsung (https://amzn.to/4a5hFRx) QN77S95F (https://amzn.to/4a5hFRx) 91 $3,000 Samsung (https://amzn.to/46DiA8T) QN77S90F (https://amzn.to/46DiA8T) 90 $2,500 Samsung QN77S90H 89 $2,600 LG OLED77G6WUA 89 $3,800 LG (https://amzn.to/4Anxk9s) OLED77G5WUA 88 $3,150 LG…