Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Was Joseph Smith a Socialist?

From Gospel Tangents Podcast · · 20 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Was Joseph Smith a socialist? Economist Mark Skousen was surprised—and more than a little irritated—when he discovered that a BYU economics professor had classified the founder of Mormonism as a utopian socialist. But when I challenged Mark about Joseph Smith's economic teachings, his answer was more complicated than a simple yes or no.

https://youtu.be/J9AVMBliFvo Don’t miss our other conversations with Mark Skousen: https://gospeltangents.com/people/mark-skousen Copyright © 2026

Gospel Tangents

All Rights Reserved

In Part 3 of our four-part Gospel Tangents interview, Mark Skousen examines the economics of early Mormonism, including the law of consecration, the United Order, private property, and tithing. We also discuss Adam Smith, Karl Marx, John Maynard Keynes, and whether Joseph Smith's economic experiments were closer to socialism or capitalism.

And Mark offers a surprising criticism of Joseph Smith's plans for building Zion. Was Joseph Smith a Socialist? Mark Skousen Responds The question began with a poster at Brigham Young University.

Mark recalls that economist Val Lamson had created a chart showing different schools of economic thought. To Mark's astonishment, Joseph Smith appeared among the utopian socialists.

Mark strongly objected.

However, he acknowledged that Joseph Smith briefly experimented with economic arrangements that could be described as utopian socialism.

Early Latter-day Saints sought to eliminate poverty and create a community in which members shared their resources. But according to Mark, Joseph Smith eventually moved toward an economic system that preserved private property and individual stewardship.

So where does Joseph Smith fit economically?

Mark suggests that communitarian may be a better description than socialist.

He points to the work of historian Leonard Arrington and argues that Joseph Smith wanted a cooperative religious society without eliminating individual responsibility.

But that raises another question.

If the early Saints were trying to build Zion, why didn't their economic system last? Why Did the United Order Fail? One of the most interesting parts of our conversation concerns Mark's explanation for the failure of the United Order.

Under early consecration arrangements, members contributed their property and received stewardships intended to meet their needs. Surplus resources were supposed to support the Church and assist others.

Mark argues that this arrangement created an economic problem.

If people were expected to contribute all their surplus, what incentive did they have to produce more than they needed?

He compares that arrangement to a 100% marginal tax rate.

Mark also notes that many early Church members were poor. There simply wasn't enough surplus wealth to sustain the system as envisioned.

He contrasts these experiments with tithing, which allows individuals to retain most of their income while contributing a portion to the Church.

From Mark's perspective, tithing creates a better balance between supporting a religious community and encouraging individual initiative.

Of course, historians and economists may disagree about whether incentives alone explain the difficulties of the United Order. But Mark's interpretation raises important questions about the practical challenges of communal religious economies. Was the United Order Really Socialism? Mark also discusses a distinction emphasized by LDS leader Marion G. Romney: the United Order and socialism were not necessarily the same thing.

One important difference, according to Romney, involved private property and voluntary consecration.

Mark argues that Joseph Smith's stewardship system preserved an important role for private ownership, even while encouraging members to devote their resources to the common good.

We also discuss the scriptural ideal of having no rich or poor among the people, as described in Fourth Nephi and the New Testament book of Acts.

Was Joseph Smith trying to establish…

Back to Gospel Tangents Podcast · Report a problem