How Helen Mar Kimball Joined Wives of Joseph Smith
From Gospel Tangents Podcast ·
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Wives of Joseph Smith
How did Helen Mar Kimball end up on listed on the wives of Joseph Smith? In Part 5 of my conversation with Michelle Stone, I finally asked the big question: was Helen married to Joseph Smith? Michelle’s paper, “Constructing Helen (https://journalofmormonpolygamy.org/jmp/article/view/32),” doesn’t answer that directly. It traces why we tell the story we do, and she plans to take on the question itself in a second paper. But in our conversation, she let her own view show.
Don’t miss our other conversations with Michelle: https://gospeltangents.com/people/michelle-stone/
Copyright © 2026
Gospel Tangents
All Rights Reserved
Helen Named Joseph’s Wife
Michelle says the first time Helen was publicly named as Joseph’s wife was in the William Clayton affidavit. She and Cheryl Bruno argued in the first issue (https://journalofmormonpolygamy.org/jmp/article/view/4) of the Journal of Mormon Polygamy that Joseph F. Smith drafted that affidavit and Clayton copied and signed it. Joseph F. Smith published it after Clayton’s death, around 1886 by Michelle’s recollection, naming several women without their knowledge or consent.
That same decade, Helen was writing more in defense of polygamy than almost anyone: articles in the Woman’s Exponent from 1881 to 1886 and two pamphlets. She insisted Joseph was a polygamist. But Michelle says she never wrote that she was married to him, at a time when being one of Joseph’s wives brought real honor in Utah.
1st List: Wives of Joseph Smith
Michelle also points to what happened next. Andrew Jenson, who compiled the first list of Joseph Smith’s wives, came to Helen twice for her testimony, and she turned him away, the second time giving him the history of a different woman instead. Jenson listed Helen anyway, based on the Clayton affidavit, and his reading of its reference to May 1, 1843, is where the traditional May 1843 date comes from, Michelle says. When depositions were taken for the Temple Lot case in 1892, Helen, then the youngest of Joseph’s living wives in Salt Lake City, wasn’t asked to testify.
Jubilee Box Letter
The one document in Helen’s handwriting that says she was Joseph’s wife is a letter dated 1881, often called the “jubilee box” letter. It didn’t surface until a master’s thesis by Daniel Bachman in the 1970s, and Todd Compton made it widely known in In Sacred Loneliness (https://amzn.to/3EedEdP). Michelle notes that Helen’s patriarchal blessing was filed in the Church History Library the same year as that letter and was ignored. She says the letter became “the interpretive lens” for everything else Helen wrote.
The familiar story is that Helen was kept from dances after her sealing. But Michelle says Helen’s own records show her going to balls and parties for eight months after the latest possible date of a marriage, until her father stopped her, and that her real resentment was toward a brother who lied his way out of the same rule. Helen also had a boyfriend in Nauvoo, a young lawyer she was seen with publicly until they broke up during the succession crisis.
Michelle doesn’t throw out the other evidence. Catherine Lewis wrote in 1848 that she overheard Helen tell her mother she would not have agreed to the sealing if she had known it was more than a ceremony. And Helen was sealed to Joseph by proxy in the Nauvoo Temple in February 1846, the night she was sealed to Horace Whitney. Fawn Brodie was the first to count everyone in those sealing records as Joseph’s wives, which Michelle says we know isn’t right. She calls these “complicated sources” that are “definitely not proof,” and she points out that Emmeline B. Wells wrote Helen’s obituary without calling her a wife of Joseph Smith.
Historians like Todd Compton (https://gospeltangents.com/people/todd-compton) and Brian Hales (https://gospeltangents.com/people/brian-hales) read these same sources very differently. I took the traditional side for the sake of argument in…