Cosmos
Podcasts and channels like Gary's Scaries
About Gary's Scaries: Caitlyn reads spine-chilling true paranormal stories to her co-host Gary - who hates scary stuff. Gary listens (sometimes reluctantly), then rates just how terrifying each tale really is. Expect an hour of hair-raising tales overtop nervous laughter as they explore the creepy, the weird, and the unexplained
The Cosmos is the same for everyone. It does not depend on who is looking. It is not symmetric: a show can be near another show without that show being near it.
Rated alike
These shows tend to be rated similarly.
No close matches yet.
Similar by topic and creator
Shows that share a topic or a creator with this one. This list uses no ratings.

Thrilling Threads - Conspiracy Theories, Strange Phenomena, True Crime, Unsolved Mysteries, etc!
Byte & PiecesAudioLast show:
Prepare to be captivated, surprised, and enlightened as we shed light on the shadows of the unknown.
Shares the topics Science and True Crime.
Not rated yet
NIGHTMARE 20ZZ
Récits BibliquesAudioLast show:
Every episode of NIGHTMARE 20ZZ pulls you into the darkest corners of the internet, where disturbing confessions, terrifying true stories, unexplained encounters, and…
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and True Crime.
Not rated yet
Dark Mysteries — Unsolved Mysteries. Forgotten Secrets. Unanswered Questions.
Darkest Mysteries OnlineAudioLast show:
Dark Mysteries — Unsolved Mysteries. Forgotten Secrets. Unanswered Questions. Step beyond the ordinary.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and True Crime.
Not rated yet
KURIOUS: Strange. Unusual. Unbelievable.
KURIOUS: Strange and Unusual StoriesAudioLast show:
KURIOUS STORIES: Strange. Unusual. Unbelievable. Real events. Strange encounters. Stories that shouldn't be true—but are. A normal day that bends.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and True Crime.
Not rated yet
Scary Stories
FlokyAudioLast show:
Free scary stories for you. Become a supporter of this podcast: (
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and True Crime.
Not rated yet
Viti Daily – Viticulture & Wine News & Research
Viti DailyAudioLast show:
Welcome to Viti Daily, your go-to podcast, generated using AI voice and scripting for the latest in viticulture, wine industry news, and cutting-edge grape and wine…
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and Science.
Not rated yet
Red Onion Randy - Life in a Supermax Prison
Michael Garbutt, Randall Via,AudioLast show:
Randall Via, known as Red Onion Randy, is currently incarcerated at Buckingham Correctional Center in Virginia.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and True Crime.
Not rated yet
MYSTERIOUS CRIMES AND HORRORS
MYSTERIOUS CRIMES AND HORRORSAudioLast show:
MYSTERIOUS CRIMES AND HORRORS 🔎🌑 Step into the dark world of unsolved mysteries, chilling crimes, unexplained phenomena, and terrifying real-life stories.
Shares the topics Science and True Crime.
Not rated yet
Nature in Crisis
London Review of BooksAudioLast show:
In a time of climate breakdown and mass extinction there is a new urgency to environmental writing, both as literature and as science.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and Science.
Not rated yet
Crew Collective
RocketgeniusAudioLast show:
Crew Collective is a podcast dedicated to the art of storytelling. Hosted by Stuart Barefoot, each episode will explore some kind of story about outer space.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and Science.
Not rated yet
Food Talk with Dani Nierenberg (by Food Tank)
Food TankAudioLast show:
Food Tank's Danielle Nierenberg chats with the most important folks in the food industry about the most important food news, released every Thursday.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and Science.
Not rated yet
Food Talk with Dani Nierenberg (by Food Tank)
Food TankAudioLast show:
Food Tank's Danielle Nierenberg chats with the most important folks in the food industry about the most important food news, released every Thursday.
Shares the topics Arts and Culture and Science.
Not rated yet
Questions about Gary's Scaries
- What podcasts and channels are like Gary's Scaries?
- On AmigoFish, shows like Gary's Scaries include Thrilling Threads - Conspiracy Theories, Strange Phenomena, True Crime, Unsolved Mysteries, etc!, NIGHTMARE 20ZZ, Dark Mysteries — Unsolved Mysteries. Forgotten Secrets. Unanswered Questions., KURIOUS: Strange. Unusual. Unbelievable. and Scary Stories.
- How does AmigoFish choose shows like Gary's Scaries?
- "Similar by topic and creator" lists shows that share a topic or a creator. These lists do not use popularity charts.