Skip to main content
AmigoFish

As a Civilian Are Battle Rifles Worth It?

From Garand Thumb · · 1 hr 4 min

The player loads from YouTube only when you click. It uses YouTube's privacy-enhanced mode.

If the video does not play, the owner may have turned off embedding. Watch it on YouTube instead.

Watch on YouTube

Not rated yet

Description

Are battle rifles still worth it for civilians in 2026? Today we’re putting the classics head-to-head with modern heavy hitters—FAL, G3, and M14 versus newer platforms like the HK417, SCAR 17S, MR762, and SIG Spear. We break down recoil, weight, accuracy, suppression, and real-world practicality to answer the question: are these full-power rifles still relevant, or just relics of a different era?

From cold-war warhorses to modern gas guns, we run drills, push distance, and look at what actually matters for civilian use—home defense, rural property, and realistic scenarios. If you’ve ever wondered whether .308 battle rifles still make sense in a world dominated by lighter carbines, this is the no-BS breakdown.

The most awesome gaming computers made by ardent 2A supporters in Utah! www.xidax.com/garandthumb

Our Company and Merch! Onward Research http://onwardresearch.com/

www.xidax.com/garandthumb

Insta: https://www.instagram.com/garand_thumb/

GarandThumb on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/garandthumb1

00:00 Amazing Intro 00:12 opening thoughts on battle rifles 03:51 Primer on Battle Rifle Test 08:50 THE FAL 09:55 Classic FAL Drill 10:54 Upgraded FAL Drill 11:40 FAL OSW Drill 13:59 THE HK G3 15:54 HK G3 Drill 18:15 The M-14 20:14 The M-14 Drill 21:05 M-14 Scout Variant 21:15 M-14 Scout Drill 23:20 Modern Battle Rifles 26:10 SCAR-H / SCAR17S Drill 27:35 MR308 / HK 417 29:09 AR 308 / Larue MRGG 30:15 SIG SPEAR 31:40 Long Range Battle Rifles 35:05 Black Screen Autistic Battle Rifle Breakdown 36:06 FAL Deep Dive 40:32 HK G3 Deep Dive 43:17 M-14 Deep Dive 46:05 SCAR 17S / SCAR H Deep Dive 53:15 HK 417 / MR308 Deep Dive 56:15 SIG SPEAR Deep Dive 58:32 AR308 / MRGG / SR25 Deep Dive

Back to Garand Thumb · Report a problem