Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Episode 34: Joke Theft, Lies and the Comedy Business

From Fool Me Twice with Bradford Oakes and Steve Van Aperen · · 50 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

When does inspiration become imitation, and when does imitation become theft? In their longest episode yet, comedian and comedy coach Bradford Oakes and Steve Van Aperen tackle plagiarism, joke stealing and the awkward business of telling the truth.

The conversation begins with a question every coach faces: how honest should you be with someone who wants to make people laugh? Bradford explains why he believes most people can become funnier, even when progress is slow. Sometimes a comedian needs clearer communication or a different coach, rather than a verdict that they simply are not funny. Steve brings his perspective on lies, honesty and the clues people leave when a story does not ring true.

From there, they enter the murky world of borrowed material. Bradford describes the painstaking process of building a routine, often testing jokes over months, and why it stings when someone else delivers the finished work as their own. He recalls returning from a tour to discover that one of his signature jokes had appeared on The Footy Show. The audience had heard it on television first, making his own joke fall flat. He also recounts confronting other performers over material he recognised.

The pair discuss Jordan Parris, the Australia’s Got Talent comedian whose routines were reported to closely resemble material by Lee Mack and Jeff Keith. Bradford and Steve examine his response to the controversy, including a later joke about “copy and paste” writers that was itself identified as an existing Jeffrey Ross line. For them, the issue is the impression a stand-up gives an audience when presenting someone else’s words as original material.

But not every similarity is deliberate theft. Bradford explains parallel development, where people independently arrive at similar jokes about the same subject, and cryptomnesia, where a forgotten idea can feel new. They range beyond comedy to Men at Work’s “Down Under”, the children’s song “Kookaburra”, the origins of “Waltzing Matilda”, parody songs and bootleg cassette tapes.

Along the way, expect detours, some spectacularly bad jokes, and a frank look at how creative work travels. Who owns a punchline? What happens when a writer is hired to create one? And how can comedians protect their livelihood while still sharing a stage? Bradford and Steve have more questions than easy answers, and they would love a copyright lawyer to join the conversation.

LINKS

Book Steve Van Aperen as your next keynote speaker: Click here (https://www.stevevanaperen.com/)

Book Brad Oakes for your next event: Click here (https://bradoakes.com/)

Learn stand-up comedy with Brad Oakes: Click here (https://hardknockknocks.com/)

Learn more about Fool Me Twice by visiting www.foolmetwice.com.au (https://foolmetwice.com.au/)

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy (https://acast.com/privacy) for more information.

Back to Fool Me Twice with Bradford Oakes and Steve Van Aperen · Report a problem