Episode 187: A Suburban Nightmare - The Murder of Tabatha Bryant
From Evil Everywhere: A True Crime and Horror Podcast · · 55 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Why does it sometimes feel like its those with the most open hearts who are betrayed by those they care for? Tabatha Bryant was a energetic woman, a wife, mother and one such person with an open heart, always willing to help the people she loved. She opened her home to family in need, welcomed everyone into her life, and worked hard to keep her marriage together as it began to crumble. But in the summer of 2003, Tabatha was found murdered inside her own home. At first, there were more questions than answers. An affair, a troubled marriage, and a significant list of people who had complicated ties to Tabatha. But the more detectives dug, the more they uncovered a story far more disturbing than anticipated. The evidence took the case through a series of unexpected turns. But one aspect was clear: the murderer knew Tabatha well. In the end, 3 people would face prison time for their roles in Tabatha’s murder. This case is an example of how far someone could go when jealousy, betrayal, and the fear of losing everything took over. Tabatha Bryant’s murder reveals just how dangerous the people closest to us can actually be.
Sources:
“Sex And Coke-Addicted New York Attorney Hires Wife’s Half-Brother To Kill Her” by Erik Hawkins on Oxygen True Crime on February 16, 2020 (https://www.oxygen.com/killer-affair/crime-news/tabatha-bryant-kevin-bryant-murder-cyril-winebrenner-affair-hire)
“Slain ‘Tabby’ had ‘zest for life’” by Patrick Flanigan in The Democrat and Chronicle on July 19, 2003
“She Crossed Him — and He Couldn’t Deal: Inside the Tabby Bryant Murder Case” on Medium on November 10, 2025 (https://medium.com/@pieduplessis/she-crossed-him-and-he-couldnt-deal-inside-the-tabby-bryant-murder-case-140de86e25af)
“Murder Arrests Stun Penfield” by Doloros Orman and Corydon Ireland in The Democrat and Chronicle on August 4, 2003
“The Truth is in the Blood: The Murder of Tabatha Bryant” by Olivia Mason on The Lineup on June 6, 2018 (https://the-line-up.com/betrayal-in-blood)
“Penfield Neighbor Recalls Slain Mom” by Patrick Flanigan in The Democrat and Chronicle on July 17, 2003
“Lawyer’s arrest is problem for clients” by Will Astor on Rochester Business Journal on August 15, 2003 (https://rbj.net/2003/08/15/lawyers-arrest-is-problem-for-clients/)
“Papers Outline Penfield Murder” by Greg Livadas and Jeffrey Blackwell in The Democrat and Chronicle on August 5, 2003
“Decision on Death Penalty Postponed” by Michael Zeigler in The Democrat and Chronicle on December 2, 2003
“Murder Suspect Faces 2 lawsuits” by Steve Orr and Greg Livadas in The Democrat and Chronicle on September 7, 2003
“The Wolf and The Sheep” on Someone You Thought You Knew, Season 1, Episode 3 on Discovery+
“Murder in the suburbs” on Killer Affair Season 1, Episode 11 on Fandango, January 18 2020
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/71701903/tabatha_marie-bryant
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/269714903/kevin_charles-bryant
Stella Rosa Website - https://stellarosa.com/
Back to Evil Everywhere: A True Crime and Horror Podcast · Report a problem