Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Episode 177 - Dead Calm in Cape May - Kimberly Holton

From Evil Everywhere: A True Crime and Horror Podcast · · 52 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

The quiet Victorian resort of Cape May, NJ was shattered when a body was discovered floating in the Atlantic Ocean, just a few miles from shore. The victim was 16-year-old Kimberly Holton, a teenager from Dover, Delaware. Despite having been submerged in water for a time, investigators managed to identify her. The autopsy revealed a number of concerning factors: multiple skull fractures but no water in her lungs. The most concerning, were the chains found wrapped her ankles. These chains led to a local hardware store where surveillance footage showed who had purchased it. But it was 2 men, unknown to detectives. One of them came into the police, to clear his name and identified who the other man in the video was. Jacob Jones, the pilot instructor boyfriend of Kimberly’s foster sister. After obtaining enough evidence to arrest Jacob, he committed suicide, but not before confessing to his father and revealing who his accomplice was. Why would this straight A, quiet college student commit such a heinous crime against the foster sister of his girlfriend?

Sources:

“Before Disappearing, Teen had Accused Guardian of Abuse” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on October 15, 2003

“16-Year-Old Girl Murdered, Then Thrown Off Plane into the Ocean: "Nightmarish Scene"” by Jax Miller on Oxygen True Crime on June 22, 2024 (https://www.oxygen.com/deadly-waters-with-captain-lee/crime-news/body-of-kimberly-holton-found-off-cape-may-coast)

“Two States Probing Death of Dover Girl” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on October 14, 2003

“My Boyfriend Killed My Sister: The Tragic Case of Kimberly Holton” by True Crime Lounge on Medium on August 4, 2024 (https://truecrimelounge.medium.com/my-boyfriend-killed-my-sister-the-tragic-case-of-kimberly-holton-8cfce9ab6efe)

“Police say Shoppers may have Clues to Dover Teen’s Final Days” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on October 17, 2003

“Accused Killers Dump Body From USAF Aero-Club Aircraft” on Aero News Network on November 9, 2003 (https://www.aero-news.net/FullsizeImage.cfm?do=main.textpost&id=54dd2978-de51-4cfc-a669-9999d6518c70)

“Dover man Charged in Slaying of Girl” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on October 29, 2003

“Kimberly Holton Was Murdered in 2003 — Her Friend Knew Something Was Wrong” by Jennifer Tisdale on June 21, 2024 (https://www.distractify.com/p/what-happened-to-kimberly-holton)

“Tips Surface from Video in Teen Death” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on October 18, 2003

“Kimberly Holton Murder: Where is Michael Keyser Now?” by Viswa Vanapalli on TheCinemaholic on August 4, 2021 (https://thecinemaholic.com/kimberly-holton-murder-how-did-jacob-jones-die-where-is-michael-keyser-now/)

“Man Accused in Girl’s Death Tries Suicide” by Robin Brown in The News Journal on October 30, 2003

“Teen’s Body Thrown Out of Plane” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on November 8, 2003

“A Young Life Taken” by Terri Sanginiti in The News Journal on November 9, 2003

https://www.oxygen.com/deadly-waters-with-captain-lee/season-1/episode-4/videos/kimberly-holtons-first-foster-mother

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/273518867/kimberly_lynn-holton

https://www.oxygen.com/deadly-waters-with-captain-lee/season-1/videos/who-was-kimberly-holton

“From the Deep” on Homicide Hunter: American Detective Season 1, Episode 4 on Discovery+

“A Killing off Cape May” on Bodies in the Water, Season 1, Episode 7 on Discovery+

***Cellar 54 Website - https://cellar54wines.com/?srsltid=AfmBOoqgQ1J6pQYC0svfz2TK_hHINr9vFTvETJ5F9rNRTKqOInvbSy9X

Back to Evil Everywhere: A True Crime and Horror Podcast · Report a problem