Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Are We Ready for Mushroom Meat?

From Enlightened Omnivore Podcast · · 56 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

I spend a lot of time on Enlightened Omnivore talking about meat. I am a former butcher after all. I love eating meat, but I am also deeply curious about what role meat should play in our agricultural system, our food economy, and ultimately on our plates. Should we be eating less of it? Raising animals differently? Finding entirely new ways to produce the foods we love?

And the more I learn, the more I find myself sitting on the fence between two seemingly opposing solutions.

On one side are the people who believe we should stop eating animals altogether. That the environmental and ethical costs of raising billions of animals for food are simply too great, and that the future of food needs to be plant-based.

On the other side are people who believe we should raise animals better. Restore our grasslands, rebuild healthy soil, support farmers and ranchers who are working with nature rather than against it to repair the damage already done.

I’ve spent a lot of time talking to people on both sides of these arguments. And frankly, at the highest level, I find myself agreeing with much of what each of them has to say.

But here’s what troubles me: Why do these solutions so often seem to be in conflict with one another?

Enlightened Omnivore is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Why does supporting regenerative animal agriculture have to mean rejecting alternative proteins? And why does advocating for plant-based foods so often mean dismissing the possibility that animals can play a beneficial role in a healthy agricultural ecosystem?

Maybe we’re asking the wrong question.

Instead of arguing about which foods we need to give up, what if we spent more time figuring out what we could add?

Imagine a protein that’s naturally occurring, renewable, packed with nutrients and fiber, and can be grown in a fraction of the time and space required to raise livestock.

Something that isn’t assembled from a long list of isolated proteins and ultraprocessed additives, but grown as a whole food through using a production method humans have perfected over thousands of years: fermentation.

And what if that ingredient could be used to make a convincing burger or chicken nugget? Or, perhaps more interestingly, what if we could combine it with real meat to make something that tastes familiar but uses fewer animals?

Would that be a compromise? Would it be gross? Or could it actually be progress?

Today’s guest is trying to do exactly that.

Paul Shapiro is the founder of BMC Ingredients, previously known as The Better Meat Co., a and he’s making food out of mycelium, the root-like structure of fungi.

Paul is most definitely on one side of that animal husbandry fence. A longtime animal-rights advocate, a vegan of more than three decades, and the author of Clean Meat, a book exploring the future of meat grown in a lab rather than on pasture.

But I gave him the benefit of the doubt, and visited The Better Meat Co’s production facility in Sacramento a couple of years ago, and I was fascinated by what I saw. Rather than raising animals or growing crops in fields, his company cultivates fungi in giant fermentation tanks—like beer—producing 9,000 liters of protein in less than a day.

But as promising as this technology sounds, of course I have questions.

Now, that sounds promising, but of course, I have questions. Is it really better for the environment? Can it compete with conventional meat on price? ? Aren't there concerns about patenting such an important part of our food supply? And do we improve the food system if it becomes more technologically complicated?

Paul and I don’t agree on everything. But that’s precisely why I wanted to have him on the pod. Because I suspect the future of food won’t be found on one side of the fence or the other.

It’s more likely to be found in the messy middle.

PLEASE RATE THE PODCAST OR LEAVE A REVIEW

Please don’t forget to…

Back to Enlightened Omnivore Podcast · Report a problem