Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Can Regenerative Agriculture Grow Up Without Selling Out?

From Enlightened Omnivore Podcast · · 1 hr 4 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

More than a decade ago, when I co-owned Electric City Butcher, we started buying chickens from a little Southern California farm called Pasturebird (http://pasturebird.com).

And when I say little, I mean little.

Founder Paul Greive and his family had started out raising 50 chickens in the backyard because they couldn’t find the kind of pasture-raised chicken they wanted to eat. Eventually they started selling a few birds to friends and family. Then a few more. Then a few more. Paul had grown big enough to start selling wholesale, and Electric City Butcher became one of its very first customers.

The chicken was great. The farming made sense to us. The birds actually lived on pasture and were moved onto fresh ground every day. This was exactly the kind of farm we wanted to support, and we did for almost seven years.

Then, I heard Pasturebird had joined forces with Perdue. And I’ll admit what went through my head: Paul sold out to the evil empire.

We did keep carrying Paul’s birds but then COVID happened, and the butcher shops closed. I didn’t connect with Pasturebird again until I saw their products on the shelves at my local grocery store. A small farmer had finally made it to the big show. But was it the same chicken that I’d fallen in love with so many years ago?

So naturally, when Paul agreed to join me for the first episode of Season 3, I had to ask him what happened. His answer made me reconsider some of my own assumptions about what it actually means to build a better food system.

What happens when the little guy gets big?

We love small farms. We love the folksy farmer at the farmers market who knows your name, the pasture you can actually visit, and the chicken that costs more because you understand exactly how it was raised.

I built an entire butcher shop around that idea. But there’s a problem. If these farming systems really are better—for the animals, the land and the people eating the food—do we actually want them to remain small?

How does an everyday consumer trying to put food on the table reconcile supporting a favorite brand once it’s no longer small? And more importantly, what if partnering with members of the industrial food system that I—and countless others—have spent years fighting, actually becomes a way to change it for the better?

Better doesn’t have to mean perfect

Paul said something during our conversation that stuck with me. Years ago, he was much more absolutist about farming. If it wasn’t regenerative or pasture based, he wanted nothing to do with it. It may not surprise you that now working with Big Ag, his thinking has changed a bit.

He still believes deeply in regenerative agriculture. He still wants chickens on pasture. But he’s become much more focused on demanding transparency from a food system that likes to hide its processes and details in the shadows.

I appreciate that.

It’s also a conversation I very much what to expand on for this new season of the Enlightened Omnivore Podcast. I’m not particularly interested in finding the one perfect way to eat. I’m interested in the messy middle. The tradeoffs. The contradictions. The compromises that happen when an ideal encounters economics, infrastructure, and eight billion hungry people.

This season I’ll be talking with regenerative agriculture experts and pasture-raised farmers, journalists and food writers, leading climate experts, people working on alternative meat and new food technologies, and some old friends I’ve met over the years who’ve devoted their lives to making our food system better, with our without the help of Big Ag.

We’ll talk about how food is made, where it comes from, who produces it—and why all of that matters. And, of course, there will be a few surprises along the way.

So, did Paul sell out?

You’ll have to listen and decide for yourself. But I came away from our conversation thinking that “selling out” might be the wrong question. Maybe the more interesting question is what happens when the little food…

Back to Enlightened Omnivore Podcast · Report a problem