Season 2 (Episode 7): The Italian Beef vs. Cheesesteak: Two Iconic Sandwiches, Only One Crown
From Eating History · · 20 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
This week, Stephen and Adrienne dive into a fierce culinary showdown between two of America's most legendary regional heavyweights: Chicago’s Italian Beef and Philadelphia’s Cheesesteak. From underground gambling fronts and prison stints to decades-long street rivalries, discover the colorful, true-crime-adjacent histories behind these iconic sandwiches.
In this episode, we explore:
- The "Peanut Wedding" Origins: How immigrant families in 1920s Chicago stretched tough cuts of meat by slow-roasting and slicing them paper-thin for modest celebrations.
- The Bookmaker's Beef: The wild story of Al's #1 Italian Beef, which originally opened as a front for an illegal gambling operation.
- The Cheesesteak's Accidental Birth: How hot dog vendors Pat and Harry Olivieri accidentally invented the cheesesteak in 1930, and why it took over a decade for the sandwich to actually include cheese.
- The Great Philly Rivalry: How Joey Vento opened Geno's Steaks directly across the street from Pat's in 1966, funded by his bookmaker father-in-law.
- The Ultimate Verdict: Stephen and Adrienne break down the gravy, the giardiniera, the Cheez Whiz, and the bread to declare the ultimate sandwich winner.