Weird Islands
From Divided Argument · · 1 hr 14 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
It's the last opinion day of the term, and the big one landed: Trump v. Barbara (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/trump-v-barbara/), the birthright-citizenship case. We read the majority as the rare easy case and spend most of the episode on why the four dissents each end up somewhere different — and trying to figure out exactly where they actually land. Along the way: a bogus Nina Totenberg story, a Landor (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/landor-v-louisiana-department-of-corrections-and-public-safety/) GVR that might quietly unsettle a chunk of Spending Clause criminal law, and whether the professors who defended the order deserve the "legal scholarship police."
Highlights
- [00:00:27] The bogus Nina Totenberg wire story that Justice Alito was retiring — "Fake news, Dan."
- [00:02:03] The Justice Alito / Justice Sotomayor bench-dissent dust-up from the immigration hand-downs
- [00:03:11] Last opinion day — 3 opinions, 4 cases; NRSC v. FEC and West Virginia v. B.P.J. / Little v. Hecox flagged for later
- [00:05:27] A significant new grant teed up on possession of semi-automatic rifles (AR-15s)
- [00:06:43] A GVR in light of Landor in a federal arson case, and the narrow-vs-broad theory of what a GVR means
- [00:09:34] Whether Landor's narrowing of Sabri could upend a swath of Spending Clause federal criminal law
- [00:10:58] Why RLUIPA reaches prisoners — Chuck Colson's post-Watergate lobbying (courtesy of a listener, Emma Kaufman)
- [00:12:55] Trump v. Barbara — Trump loses, but closer than predicted: "Trump beats the spread"
- [00:15:25] Should professors who defended the order be punished? — "we don't need legal scholarship police"
- [00:19:58] The majority's walk: common law → Dred Scott → the 14th Amendment → Wong Kim Ark
- [00:26:21] Wong Kim Ark as linchpin, and whether its "domiciled here" language was doing any work
- [00:36:48] Justice Kavanaugh concurs in the judgment on the statute, then dispatches the constitutional question breezily
- [00:42:05] New states, Hawaii, and Living Originalism — when may you add new exceptions? "Weird islands you can't drive to"
- [00:48:33] The 91-page Justice Thomas dissent, the facial-challenge pivot, and the reserved domicile question
- [00:56:40] Justice Alito's Civil Rights Act / "not subject to any foreign power" reading, and the statelessness caveat
- [01:00:11] Justice Gorsuch's 3-page solo dissent: if not domiciled here, then where? — a jab Thomas may not share
- [01:05:33] Justice Jackson's anti-subordination concurrence, and whether it lands against Thomas
- [01:10:24] "I feel proud to be an American, Dan" — hail to the Chief, and to Justice Barrett; sign-off
Relevant links
Cases
- Trump v. Barbara (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/trump-v-barbara/) — slip opinion (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-365_4hdj.pdf)
- Landor v. Louisiana Dept. of Corrections (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/landor-v-louisiana-department-of-corrections-and-public-safety/) — slip opinion (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/23-1197_h3ci.pdf)
- Sabri v. United States (https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/541/600/) (2004)
- United States v. Wong Kim Ark (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Wong_Kim_Ark) (1898)
- NRSC v. FEC (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/national-republican-senatorial-committee-v-federal-election-commission/) — slip opinion (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/24-621_h315.pdf)
- West Virginia v. B.P.J. (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/west-virginia-v-b-p-j-2-2/) / Little v. Hecox (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/little-v-hecox/) — slip opinion (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/24-43_2b35.pdf)
Commentary & articles
- SCOTUSblog opinion recap: "Supreme Court strikes down Trump's order ending birthright citizenship" (https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/06/supreme-court-strikes-down-trumps-order-ending-birthright-citizenship/)
- Ilan Wurman & Randy Barnett's NYT essay defending the order…