Smart Microwave
From Divided Argument · · 1 hr 25 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
After a quick check on the Nina Totenberg embargo kerfuffle and one more revelation from Justice Thomas's memoir, we devote the episode to Chatrie v. United States (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf), the Court's first major Fourth Amendment decision in years. We trace how the geofence-warrant ruling builds on — and goes beyond — Katz (https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/389/347/), United States v. Jones (https://www.oyez.org/cases/2011/10-1259), and Carpenter v. United States (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-402_h315.pdf), and what's left of the third-party doctrine and the mosaic theory. Will explains the positive law model of the Fourth Amendment; Dan tries to claim Justice Gorsuch's separate opinion for his general-law approach. We close with the dissents, the advisory-opinion objection, and whether the Court should be saying more about the Fourth Amendment or less about everything. Along the way: Venmo heroin deals, smart microwaves, whether Will has genuinely forgotten his passcode, and a field-trip assignment for Chicagoland listeners.
Highlights
- [00:00:21] Cold open: three recording sessions in three days, and the theories swirling around the Nina Totenberg screw-up
- [00:02:04] Justice Alito's embargo story: the press-room idea he liked until he learned they have to let the journalists out of the room
- [00:03:04] My Grandfather's Son follow-up: Justice Thomas's over-cautious marijuana confession
- [00:04:35] Cleanup-order watch: GVRs still owed in light of Slaughter, Landor, and B.P.J.
- [00:04:57] The main event: Chatrie v. United States, the geofence-warrant case — and why a 5-Justice Fourth Amendment majority is a good get for Justice Kagan
- [00:06:51] What a geofence actually is (there is no fence) and the three-step Google Location History protocol
- [00:13:52] General warrants, particularity, the University of Chicago backpacks hypo, and Ybarra v. Illinois — with a field-trip assignment to the Aurora Tap House
- [00:21:09] Three questions — search, reasonableness, exclusion — and the clever cert grant that fenced out the exclusionary rule
- [00:25:52] The setup: Jones and the two tracks of Fourth Amendment doctrine, step 0 (the third-party doctrine), then Carpenter
- [00:33:13] Will's positive law model of the Fourth Amendment, and Justice Gorsuch's Carpenter dissent
- [00:36:29] Orin Kerr's mosaic theory: "building out the mosaic Byzantine style, it starts to become searchier"
- [00:39:15] Kagan shuts the mosaic door: where the Fourth Amendment applies, it applies regardless of quantity — a fortiori from Carpenter
- [00:47:36] What survives of the third-party doctrine: Strava, public Venmo feeds, and the "For heroin" hypo
- [00:50:53] Why it's a big deal: the anti-mosaic holding, and a majority of Justices revealed as Carpenter people
- [00:54:48] Tangent: Face ID, the Fifth Amendment, Will's forgotten passcodes, and his enemies
- [00:56:55] Does the Stored Communications Act make all this academic?
- [00:58:34] The Jackson concurrence's particularity nudge, en banc remand practice, and Levy & Newman on unwritten circuit rules
- [01:00:43] The Gorsuch concurrence: papers, effects, property — Will disowns it and gives it to Dan's general-law approach
- [01:08:36] The Alito dissent: the advisory-opinion objection, footnote 4, the Davis carve-out, and the NRA v. Vullo precedent for a do-over remand
- [01:18:59] Justice Barrett's à-la-carte joins and her one-paragraph dissent — "we should have more dissents like this"
- [01:22:31] Two kinds of law professors, "The Supreme Court Flunks Trusts," and whether we're good on law
- [01:24:15] Sign-off: the rare promise of a schedule — a fourth recording session this week
Relevant links
Cases
- Chatrie v. United States (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/chatrie-v-united-states/) — slip opinion (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf)
- Ybarra v. Illinois…