Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Episode 24: The Black Witch

From Crooked Tree: A West Memphis 3 Podcast · · 1 hr 16 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

In this episode of Crooked Tree, hosts Paul Day and Kristin Rich descend into one of the darkest and most consequential chapters of the early investigation.

On May 11, 1993, sixteen-year-old Deanna Jane Holcomb—Damien Echols’ former girlfriend, already whispered about as a “black witch” from Marion—is pulled from school and brought into the West Memphis Police Department. What follows is a high-stakes, unrecorded interview that leaves investigators with a radically altered picture of Damien, the occult scene in Crittenden County, and the possibility that the murders of Christopher Byers, Stevie Branch, and Michael Moore were ordered rather than carried out by a single person.

Drawing on sparse, conflicting handwritten notes from Detectives Bryn Ridge and James Sudbury, polygraph results, and the same cult-focused questionnaire used on other witnesses, Paul and Kristin reconstruct Deanna’s account: claims of black magic and power rituals, sewers and manholes as hiding places, the alleged plan to kill a firstborn child, and the first time a third party points investigators toward Jason Baldwin as someone who might act on Damien’s behalf. The same day, weapons linked to Baldwin surface in Lakeshore, and police begin searching storm drains near the crime scene.

The episode also explores the local folklore surrounding Martha’s Bridge (sometimes called Mary’s Bridge), a lonely crossing near the site known as Stonehenge or Hangman’s Gin, where decades of ghost stories, crybaby legends, and midnight rituals still linger in the collective memory of Marion and West Memphis.

Dark, unsettling, and meticulously documented, “The Black Witch” examines how one teenage girl’s statements helped cement the occult theory that would dominate the case—and how the West Memphis Police Department’s incomplete notes still force us to piece together what was really said in that interrogation room.

Back to Crooked Tree: A West Memphis 3 Podcast · Report a problem