Episode 28: The Lover In The Attic
From Crime Daddies · · 1 hr 12 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
What would you do if you found out your wife's lover had been secretly living in your attic for years?
Yeah… that's not a hypothetical.
This week on Crime Daddies, Jacob tells Hunter one of the strangest true-crime stories to come out of 1920s Los Angeles — the bizarre love triangle involving Fred Oesterreich, his wife Dolly, and Otto Sanhuber, the man who secretly lived in the attic of their home.
The story begins years before the murder, when Dolly meets Otto, a teenage sewing-machine repairman who works at Fred's factory. What starts as an affair eventually turns into something almost impossible to believe: Otto moves into the attic of the Oesterreich home, staying hidden from Fred while Dolly lets him out when her husband is away. The arrangement would continue for years, eventually following the couple from Milwaukee all the way to Los Angeles.
Then, on August 22, 1922, everything falls apart.
Fred is shot and killed inside his Los Angeles home. Dolly tells police that a burglar broke into the house, killed her husband, and locked her in a closet. But investigators aren't completely convinced by her story. And what they don't know yet is that there's another person connected to the house — a man who has been hiding in the attic.
As the investigation unfolds, the secret relationship between Dolly and Otto comes to light, along with the bizarre circumstances surrounding Fred's death. The case would eventually lead to arrests, courtroom battles, conflicting stories, and a secret that had been hiding above Fred's head for years.
In this episode, Jacob takes Hunter through the strange history of Dolly and Otto, the murder of Fred Oesterreich, the investigation that finally exposed their secret, and what happened when the whole unbelievable story made its way into the courtroom.
It's one of those cases where, every time you think you've heard the craziest part… there's somehow another attic waiting around the corner.
Grab a drink, hide the evidence, and welcome back to Crime Daddies.
Want to keep up with the Crime Daddies outside of the podcast?
Everything you need is in one place:
🌐 Website: crimedaddies.riverside.com
At our website you can:
- 📱 Find and follow us on social media
- 🎙️ Get access to exclusive Crime Daddies content by subscribing for free on Riverside
- 💡 Suggest a case through our Crime Daddies tip line
- 👕 Check out our merch
- ❤️ Find other ways to support the podcast
- 🔎 Keep up with everything happening with Crime Daddies
And if you've got a case you think we should cover, send it our way through the tip line. You never know — your suggestion might become our next episode.
Thanks for listening, and thanks for being part of Crime Daddies.
Grab a drink. Hide the evidence. We'll see you next week.
crimedaddies.riverside.com