Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Episode 31: The Scream Tragedy

From Crime Daddies · · 36 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Some horror movies are meant to scare us. But what happens when someone decides to take that fiction and turn it into reality?

This week on Crime Daddies, Hunter tells Jacob the heartbreaking story of Cassie Jo Stoddart, a 16-year-old Idaho high school student whose life was brutally cut short in September 2006. What should have been an ordinary weekend house-sitting for family turned into a real-life nightmare that shocked a community and left a lasting impact on everyone who heard her story.

At the center of this case were two teenagers fascinated by horror movies and true crime. Inspired by the fictional killers they admired, they made a decision that would have devastating consequences. Cassie became the victim of a plan that blurred the line between horror entertainment and real-world violence.

Hunter walks Jacob through the events leading up to Cassie's murder, the investigation that followed, and the chilling details that helped investigators piece together what happened that night. It's a case that raises disturbing questions about obsession, influence, and what can happen when someone stops seeing the difference between fiction and reality.

Cassie Jo Stoddart was more than the subject of a true-crime story. She was a daughter, a friend, and a young woman with her whole life ahead of her. This episode remembers Cassie while examining the choices that led to an unimaginable tragedy.

As our October spooky season continues, this case reminds us that sometimes the scariest stories aren't the ones on a movie screen. They're the ones that happen in real life.

Find everything Crime Daddies in one place:

crimedaddies.riverside.com

Visit our website to subscribe for free on Riverside for exclusive content, follow us on social media, suggest a case through our tip line, shop our merch, and find all the ways to support the show.

Every dollar from merch goes back into Crime Daddies to help us keep the podcast going.

Grab a drink, hide the evidence, and join us for another episode of Crime Daddies.

Takeaways

- Tragic nature of senseless murders

- Impact of crime on communities

Chapters

- 00:00 Introduction to the Scream Murder

- 03:08 The Allure of Horror Movies

- 04:31 The Story of Cassie Joe Stoddard

- 07:50 Pocatello: A Community's Shock

Back to Crime Daddies · Report a problem