Trial Breakdown: $2,000,000 Verdict | Gray Broughton Injury Law Team
From Courtroom Stories & Tactics · · 1 hr 17 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In this trial breakdown, Sharif Gray, Shea Gibbons and Nathan Hittle walk through a recent premises-liability trial led by the Gray Broughton firm. Their client, Joseph Max, fell about five and a half feet when a railing on a portico at the Richmond Public Library gave way in December 2024.
The case didn't look like a textbook personal injury claim. There were gaps in treatment, no surgeries, limited lost wages, and a serious criminal history. The team talks openly about how they built a damages theory around those facts instead of hiding from them, and how, as a result, those facts made their client feel like a real person to the jury.
The pretrial offer was about $19,000, rising to $50,000 just before trial.
The jury returned a $2 million verdict.
The key takeaway? Jurors respond to a real person, and the "imperfect" parts of a case can be what makes it believable.
Tune in to learn how it unfolded, and what you can apply to your next trial.
"You've got to take people as they are. And the reality is, this thing could have happened to somebody who had lived a perfect life and suffered the same exact injury in the same exact way." - Nathan Hittle
In this episode, we discuss:
◼️ What matters pretrial (treatment gaps, medical bills, records), versus what matters to a jury. ◼️ Get in front of the issue. You can't just hope that it works out. ◼️ The decision not to claim medical bills as damages. ◼️ "Value the diamond, not the owner" - why the same injury is worth the same, regardless of the plaintiff's past. ◼️ How the settlement opportunity packages escalated, from about $1.1 million to $1.3 million to $1.5 million.
Chapters
00:00 Trial breakdown intro and the team 03:26 The case: Joseph Max and the library railing collapse 07:39 Client "issues" and why they humanized him 10:38 Offers vs. the $2 million verdict 13:24 City admits liability a month before trial 18:09 Contributory negligence and the broken window analogy 27:33 "His life isn't worth as much" and disarming it in voir dire 37:12 Voir dire: late jury list and jury research debate 50:20 Opening statement structure 55:40 Framing the four defense issues in advance 60:07 Why the plaintiff testified last 65:23 Courtroom moment: the tissues and Joseph's yelp 67:22 Closing argument and the "feather" burden of proof 73:03 Pending motion and final takeaways
Courtroom Stories & Tactics | RVA Trial Lawyers Available on Spotify (https://open.spotify.com/show/7DH4Jp8slQmDZlYvQ4eVxk), Apple (https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/rva-trial-lawyers-richmonds-trial-lawyer-podcast/id1669382040), YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLzzssdlP05OMOcojnYu33QPoaytO9-po6), and at RVATrialLawyers.com (https://rvatriallawyers.com/podcast/)
Based out of Richmond, Virginia, Courtroom Stories & Tactics by RVA Trial Lawyers exists for lawyers who try cases to juries on behalf of people. Through our podcast, we hope to learn from them, support them, connect them, inspire them, and preserve their work for future trial lawyers.
If you are willing, we would greatly appreciate it if you left us a 5-Star Google Review by clicking here (https://g.page/r/CZFMhk8lPPEMEBM/review). Your review will help people find us.
Thank you!
Sharif Gray and Nael Abouzaki