Ep. 63 - Mike Caruso: Palm Beach County's Clerk of Courts Arrested — Cruise Ship Jurisdiction & a Death Penalty Irony
From Come Back With a Warrant · · 56 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In this episode of Come Back with a Warrant, Palm Beach County criminal defense attorneys Monica Ishak and Brandon Dinetz break down the case that hits closest to home in the show's history: the arrest of Mike Caruso, Palm Beach County's own Clerk of Courts — the office that holds every court file the hosts have ever touched. Caruso, a 67-year-old CPA and former Republican state representative appointed Clerk by Governor DeSantis, was arrested on child sex abuse charges and suspended by the Governor the same morning. The alleged victim is his young grandson, and everything in this episode comes straight from the arrest warrant affidavit the Governor's office attached to the executive order — because in Florida, that's public record.
Monica and Brandon are clear up front: these are allegations, Caruso has pleaded not guilty, he has hired excellent counsel, and he is presumed innocent. What makes the case legally fascinating is where the alleged conduct happened — beginning in Orange County and culminating aboard a Royal Caribbean cruise ship out of the Port of Miami, in international waters. That sets up a genuine jurisdictional puzzle: Florida's special maritime jurisdiction law for cruise ship crimes, the "continuing offense" theory the State actually chose instead, why the case landed in Orange County rather than Miami-Dade or federal court, and why the kidnapping count — which rests entirely on what allegedly happened on the ship — may be the most vulnerable charge in the case.
The hosts also dig into the evidence problems on both sides: why the cruise ship's CCTV footage was almost certainly recorded over before anyone asked for it, the recorded statements Caruso made to family and on a controlled call — and why talking that much is never the move — the Williams rule fight over prior allegations that were investigated and closed as unfounded, the no-bond detention motion, and the fact that Florida has no parole. And then the twist nobody could script: the State's motion notes this case could carry a death sentence under Florida's 2023 law making sexual abuse of a child under 12 a capital offense — a law Mike Caruso voted for as a state representative, and one that sits on a collision course with existing U.S. Supreme Court precedent. Plus the Marsy's Law controversy over the victim information released with the executive order, and who's running the Clerk's office now.
Topics covered in this episode include: the Mike Caruso arrest explained, the Palm Beach County Clerk of Courts charges, jurisdiction for crimes on cruise ships, Florida's special maritime jurisdiction law, the continuing offense theory, kidnapping and lewd or lascivious molestation charges, life felonies in Florida, Williams rule evidence and prior bad acts, pretrial detention and no-bond motions, Florida's death penalty law for child sex crimes, Marsy's Law and victim privacy, and Florida public records law.
🎧 Leave us a 5 Star Review! Follow us for legal hot takes, episode updates, and a peek into our lawyer lives.📺 YouTube: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Podcast📸 Instagram: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Pod🎵 TikTok: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Pod Find us everywhere and join the conversation!
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.