Ep. 56 - The Lindsay Clancy Trial Part 1: The State's Case, Postpartum Psychosis & Premeditation
From Come Back With a Warrant · · 58 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In this episode of Come Back with a Warrant, criminal defense attorneys Monica Ishak and Brandon Dinetz break down Part 1 of the Lindsay Clancy trial: the state's case in chief, how the insanity defense actually works, and the question at the center of it all — was she criminally responsible? Lindsay Clancy, a 36-year-old labor and delivery nurse, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the January 2023 deaths of her three young children at their Massachusetts home. Nobody disputes that she caused their deaths — this trial is about criminal responsibility: whether postpartum psychosis and bipolar disorder, worsened by a cascade of psychiatric medications, left her unable to appreciate the wrongfulness of her conduct or conform it to the law. Monica and Brandon explain how the insanity defense works in Massachusetts — once the defense raises it, the commonwealth must prove criminal responsibility beyond a reasonable doubt — and why pleading it is anything but risk-free: it requires the client's actual consent, because the outcome is either prison or potentially decades in a psychiatric institution. They walk through the commonwealth's 14-day, 71-witness case piece by piece: the digital forensics timeline built from Apple Watch data and internet searches, the takeout order and CVS run the state says was a plan to get her husband out of the house, the providers who testified she showed no psychosis at 20-minute telehealth visits, the toxicology report, and the state's claim that a suicide attempt that left her paralyzed was contrived. From a criminal defense perspective, they call out what worked, what backfired — playing the 911 call, the jury view of the house, the courtroom theatrics — and the strategic gamble they cannot explain: the state resting its case in chief without a single mental health expert. Plus the motion for a required finding of not guilty, the mistrial motion, and why closings — and maybe a verdict — are just days away. Part 2 covers the defense case, the rebuttal, and the verdict. Topics covered in this episode include: the Lindsay Clancy trial in Massachusetts, three counts of first-degree murder, postpartum psychosis and bipolar disorder, the insanity defense and criminal responsibility, who really bears the burden of proof, Apple Watch data and digital forensics evidence, premeditation versus psychosis, HIPAA and why her medical records became fair game, the state's no-expert gamble, the contrived suicide argument, the 911 call and courtroom theatrics, the required finding of not guilty motion, the mistrial motion, and the criminal defense perspective on trying a mental health case. This is a heavy episode about mental illness, postpartum psychosis, and suicide. If you or someone you love is struggling, call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. Listen to Come Back with a Warrant for legal commentary, criminal defense insight, true crime breakdowns, and real conversations about the justice system. Subscribe, leave a five-star review, and sign up for our weekly newsletter for more criminal defense stories, legal insight, and unfiltered courtroom commentary. 🎧 Leave us a 5 Star Review! Follow us for legal hot takes, episode updates, and a peek into our lawyer lives. 📺 YouTube: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Podcast 📸 Instagram: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Pod 🎵 TikTok: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Pod Find us everywhere and join the conversation!
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.