Ep. 66 - The Crash on Netflix: Mackenzie Shirilla — Murder or Accident?
From Come Back With a Warrant · · 47 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
In this episode of Come Back with a Warrant, criminal defense attorneys Monica Ishak and Brandon Dinetz break down The Crash, the Netflix documentary about Mackenzie Shirilla — the Ohio teenager convicted of murder after driving 100 mph into a brick building, killing her boyfriend and their friend.
Was it murder, or a tragic accident? That question split the internet when the verdict came down, and the documentary reopened the debate for millions of viewers. Monica and Brandon walk through the 17-count indictment — murder, felonious assault, aggravated vehicular homicide — and what it took to prove an intentional murder with no eyewitness: the surveillance video, and the black box showing her foot 100 percent on the gas. But as they put it, a black box is a fact, not a witness — you cannot cross-examine it about what was in her head.
From a criminal defense perspective, they dig into the decision that defined the case: waiving a jury for a bench trial, and when putting your client's fate in a single judge's hands makes sense. They also cover the Rule 404 character-evidence fight over her past threats to her boyfriend, the defense's neurological "leg lock" theory and why no expert ever testified to it, the judge who branded her "literal hell on wheels" at sentencing, the 15-to-life sentence, the appeal that has already been denied — and what her former cellmate says she is doing in prison now.
Topics covered in this episode include: The Crash on Netflix and the Mackenzie Shirilla case, the Strongsville, Ohio crash, the 17-count indictment explained, intentional murder versus DUI manslaughter, proving intent with no eyewitness, black box and surveillance video evidence, bench trials versus jury trials, Rule 404 character evidence and prior threats, the leg lock defense theory and the missing expert, the hell on wheels sentencing, 15 years to life and the denied appeal, and the criminal defense perspective on young defendants.
Listen to Come Back with a Warrant for legal commentary, criminal defense insight, true crime breakdowns, and real conversations about the justice system. Subscribe, leave a five-star review, and sign up for our weekly newsletter for more criminal defense stories, legal insight, and unfiltered courtroom commentary.
🎧 Leave us a 5 Star Review! Follow us for legal hot takes, episode updates, and a peek into our lawyer lives.
📺 YouTube: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Podcast 📸 Instagram: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Pod 🎵 TikTok: @ComeBackWithAWarrant.Pod
Find us everywhere and join the conversation!
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.