Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Did Plato Believe In The 'Noble Lie?' - with Tim Blake Nelson & Agnes Callard

From Classical Wisdom Speaks · · 39 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Did Plato Believe Society Needs Lies? | Agnes Callard & Tim Blake Nelson on the Noble Lie

👉 FULL Episode Available Here for Classical Wisdom Members: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/p/the-noble-lie-platos-most-dangerous

👉 Become a Classical Wisdom Member: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=b28f7da1

What if the stories holding our society together aren't actually true?

And what if the ancient Greek philosopher Plato understood this more than 2,000 years ago?

In Book III of Plato's Republic, Socrates introduces one of the most controversial ideas in Western philosophy: the Noble Lie.

It's a founding myth designed to convince citizens that they have different kinds of metals in their souls—gold, silver, bronze, or iron—and that these differences help determine their roles in society.

But why would a philosopher devoted to truth propose deliberately deceiving people?

And could society function without such myths?

In this episode of Classical Wisdom Speaks, host Anya Leonard is joined by Agnes Callard, philosopher at the University of Chicago and author of Open Socrates, and Tim Blake Nelson, acclaimed actor, writer, director, and classics graduate.

Together, they explore Plato's Republic, the nature of political deception, and the invisible assumptions that shape our everyday lives.

Agnes offers a fascinating interpretation of the Noble Lie: perhaps Plato recognized that much of what we consider natural or inevitable about society is actually constructed through shared beliefs and conventions.

Tim considers the role of organizing myths in human civilization, from religion to political institutions, while questioning whether these narratives are necessary for collective life.

But the conversation doesn't stop at politics.

Are we telling little lies in almost every social interaction?

Agnes suggests that even ordinary conversations depend on shared pretenses that we rarely notice.

The discussion also explores Plato's strict educational system, whether governments should influence our health and lifestyle choices, and whether political leaders should be tested for wisdom and character before assuming power.

From ancient Athens to modern social media, the questions are remarkably relevant.

Who decides what society should believe? Can a lie ever serve the common good? And how do we distinguish necessary social conventions from dangerous political deception?

Join us for a thought-provoking conversation about Plato, truth, power, and the stories we live by.

⏱️ Timestamps

00:00 Meet Agnes Callard and Tim Blake Nelson 01:28 Exploring Plato's Republic 02:09 Should the state control our lives? 05:57 Plato's City of Pigs 07:20 Freedom versus conformity 11:10 Health, fitness, and the soul 15:30 Should leaders be tested? 18:15 Education and social hierarchy 21:34 What is the Noble Lie? 22:13 Why societies need shared myths 25:01 Are all social systems built on lies? 27:16 The lies we tell every day 30:43 Why read Plato so closely? 31:28 Tim on the value of philosophy 33:17 Agnes on reading The Republic 37:24 Plato's troubling political legacy 38:38 Final reflections

What Do You Think?

Can a society function without shared myths—or are some forms of deception unavoidable?

And should political leaders ever be allowed to tell a lie for the supposed greater good?

Share your thoughts in the comments!

👉 Subscribe to Classical Wisdom Speaks for conversations about ancient philosophy, Greek history, political thought, and timeless ideas that continue to shape our world.

👉 Discover our free newsletter and more ancient wisdom: https://classicalwisdom.substack.com

👉 Watch Tim & Agnes' podcast, Exploring the Greats: https://ExploringTheGreats.com

About Our Guests

Agnes Callard is a philosopher and professor at the University of Chicago. She is the author of Open Socrates and explores questions of ethics, aspiration, and the Socratic philosophical tradition.

Tim Blake Nelson is an actor, director,…

Back to Classical Wisdom Speaks · Report a problem