Skip to main content
AmigoFish

E70: When Chartering Becomes Public Infrastructure

From Bold By Choice Podcast · · 41 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

What does accountability need to become when chartering is no longer a small experiment on the edges of public education, but part of the public infrastructure families rely on every day?

In this episode of the Bold by Choice Podcast, Vashaunta Harris and Jim Goenner, Ph.D. sit down with Dr. Michelle Walker Davis, Executive Director of the D.C. Public Charter School Board, to explore how authorizing must evolve as chartering matures.

Washington, D.C. offers a particularly powerful place to have that conversation. DC PCSB serves as the city’s sole charter authorizer, overseeing a diverse portfolio of schools that educate nearly half of the city’s public school students. That makes accountability more than a technical exercise. It becomes a question of public trust, transparency, autonomy, equity, stewardship, and the promise made to students and families.

Dr. Walker Davis begins by sharing how her own educational journey shaped her belief in access, opportunity, parent choice, and high-quality learning environments. She then brings that perspective into the work of modern authorizing and explains why accountability should not be viewed simply as consequence or compliance. When it works well, schools understand the expectations, have space to organize around their mission, and engage in an ongoing relationship with the authorizer around performance and improvement.

In this episode:

- Why D.C. provides a unique case study for the future of charter authorizing

- How access, opportunity, and parent choice shaped Dr. Walker Davis’s leadership

- What “autonomy in exchange for accountability” means in practice

- Why strong accountability requires clarity, partnership, and public trust

- How DC PCSB’s ASPIRE framework is evolving the way school quality is measured

- Why student growth, school mission, and performance all matter

- How school-specific measures can honor what makes individual charter schools unique

- What quantitative data can tell us—and what it cannot

- Why school visits, student experience, and family judgment still matter

- How authorizers can balance rigor with flexibility

- Why the next phase of authorizing may require greater awareness of the larger education ecosystem

- What it means for authorizers to help create the conditions where excellence can thrive

One of the most important ideas in the conversation is that data matters, but data is not the whole story.

Dr. Walker Davis explains that accountability systems can show important indicators such as academic performance, attendance, discipline, and growth. But they cannot fully replace the experience of walking into a school, observing the learning environment, talking with students and educators, and understanding whether that school feels like the right place for a child.

The conversation also explores DC PCSB’s move toward a more nuanced accountability framework through ASPIRE, including greater attention to student growth, students furthest from opportunity, statewide comparisons, and school-specific measures tied to each school’s unique mission.

Looking ahead, Dr. Walker Davis challenges authorizers to think beyond simply waiting to see whether schools succeed or fail. Modern authorizing, she argues, also requires understanding the larger conditions affecting schools and students, advocating for the resources and supports schools need, and participating in broader conversations about what makes success possible.

At your next board meeting, authorizer conversation, or leadership team meeting, consider this question:

Are we using accountability only to monitor performance, or are we using it to build public trust, support learning, and keep the promise made to students and families?

The Bold by Choice Podcast, powered by the National Charter Schools Institute, brings together leaders, ideas, and conversations that challenge us to advance excellence and expand what is possible for students.

Subscribe, share this episode with another…

Back to Bold By Choice Podcast · Report a problem