Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Disc Method or Shell Method? The Secret to Rotating y = sin(x^2)

From blackpenredpen · · 8 min

The player loads from YouTube only when you click. It uses YouTube's privacy-enhanced mode.

If the video does not play, the owner may have turned off embedding. Watch it on YouTube instead.

Watch on YouTube

Not rated yet

Description

When calculating volumes of solids of revolution, student frustration rarely comes from setting up the integral—it comes from getting trapped in an integral you cannot solve. Rotating y=sin(x^2) about the x-axis forces you into the disc method and an unmanageable integrand. But rotating about the y-axis introduces the cylindrical shell method, where dx integration creates the perfect setup for u = x^2. Here is the step-by-step breakdown comparing both rotations side by side, showing you exactly how to spot which method unlocks a clean evaluation every time.

Shop math t-shirts & hoodies: https://amzn.to/3qBeuw6 ----- *This channel is dedicated to creating helpful calculus tutorials for high school and college students around the world. Thank you to these Patreon members for building this with me* 3Blue1Brown • Ahmad syafi • Allison Lamery • Angel Avila • Anthony Hunting • Anyway • Ben Delo • bontle sjm • Cameron Quinn • charlie lewinski • Corey Rufener • David I Miller • Doc Ockey • exchsac • Glenn X • Gramps • Hayden S • huguens nevelus • Jake Albert • jappiesaus • Jessica • Joel Wong • Johan Renko • Karl Tang-Wang • Manil Trivedi • Mark Pagura • MarkM • Mas • Matt • Matthias Beeler • Michael ZHOU • Michelle Liang • Mizel Cluett • Nerd • Nicolai Lilly • Paul Lyon • Ricardo Murillo • Rohan • SaltyFishbutwithDream • Sebastian Correa • Sharnay Ampos • Steven McEwan • Subotai Baghatur • Terry Chang • Thế Quân Lê • Tomaz Mevlja • Torbjörn Karlsson • Zero • Zhansu • 博鈞 林 (Updated: 11/1/2026 https://www.patreon.com/blackpenredpen) ----- #calculus

Back to blackpenredpen · Report a problem