Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Does Society Create the Crimes It Punishes? | Thomas More 2

From Beyond the Text: The Intellectual Historian's Podcast · · 22 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Send us Fan Mail (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2238237/fan_mail/new)

Why punish theft without asking what drives people to steal?

Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson turn to Book One of Thomas More’s Utopia. Through the conversation between More, Peter Giles and Raphael Hythloday, we explore enclosure, poverty, harsh punishment and the claim that private property prevents a just commonwealth.

Is Raphael speaking for More—or is the book testing competing arguments? We consider humanist friendship, the layers of irony in Utopia, the objections to common ownership, and the difficulty of offering philosophical advice to political power. We finish by looking ahead to Book Two and the tensions between human dignity, forced labour and slavery.

Thomas More • Episode 2 of 3

CHAPTERS 00:00 Introduction 00:22 More, Giles and Raphael 04:02 Theft, poverty and punishment 05:35 Enclosure and the sheep that devour people 09:45 Whose voice is Thomas More? 11:48 Private property and the fallen world 12:53 Property and the common good 13:54 Raphael’s argument and More’s objections 17:36 Philosophy, patronage and political power 20:47 Human dignity and the problems of Book Two

WATCH ON YOUTUBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcjJ3HRXaig

CONTINUE THE SERIES Thomas More 1 — Who Was Thomas More, and Why Did He Imagine Nowhere? https://www.buzzsprout.com/2238237/episodes/20098815

READING Thomas More, Utopia (1516), especially Book One. Gilbert Burnet’s public-domain translation: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/2130

EXPLORE BEYOND THE TEXT https://beyondthetext.co.uk https://theintellectualhistorian.com https://thehistoryofideasclub.co.uk

CREDITS Hosts: Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson Intro/outro music: “Queens Arrival” — Red Planet / TakeTones Episode artwork: AI-generated stylised illustration.

Support the show (https://www.buzzsprout.com/2238237/support)

Back to Beyond the Text: The Intellectual Historian's Podcast · Report a problem