Skip to main content
AmigoFish

The Limits of Prediction: Math vs Reality

From Arvin Ash · · 18 min

The player loads from YouTube only when you click. It uses YouTube's privacy-enhanced mode.

If the video does not play, the owner may have turned off embedding. Watch it on YouTube instead.

Watch on YouTube

Not rated yet

Description

Thanks again to our sponsor of the day CyberghostVPN, you can take advantage of an 84% discount, i.e. $2.03 per month + 4 months free by clicking on this link: https://cyberghostvpn.com/ArvinAsh

TALK TO ARVIN https://www.patreon.com/arvinash

FURTHER VIEWING: Copenhagen vs Many Worlds: https://youtu.be/OjrEudqgZ1M Pilot Wave theory: https://youtu.be/eNJFUo7yHhQ Goodbye determism: https://youtu.be/EyvZ8F3qLx8 Quantum mechanics intro: https://youtu.be/fP2TAw7NnVU Superdeterminism: https://youtu.be/tzPqOS8HC8o Butterfly Effect: https://youtu.be/XjxNjspwebU

CHAPTERS 0:00 The future from numbers? 1:17 Laplace's Demon and Predictability 4:35 Chaos: the first "problem" 6:48 BUT Chaos is predictable in theory 8:18 Quantum Mechanics and predictability 10:20 Heisenberg Uncertainty principle: limit on precision 10:58 Even weirder quantum mechanics 12:04 How quantum mechanics be deterministic 13:54 "known" laws of physics could be wrong 16:03 Verdict on macro scale predictability

SUMMARY Can Physics predict the future? Is the universe fundamentally predictable? Sir Isaac Newton found that his laws could explain most things through mathematical laws. Pierre-Simon Laplace. He imagined a super-intelligent being, Laplace’s demon, who if he had Newton’s equations and unlimited brainpower, could use them to compute the past and the future of the entire universe with perfect accuracy. What’s the problem?

Well, there’s a catch. Knowing “perfect information” about every little particle is practically impossible. This is Chaos theory, where a tiny difference in initial conditions, can lead to a totally different outcome down the line. This is called the butterfly effect. It’s “sensitive dependence on initial conditions.” Even though the weather obeys deterministic equations, in practice we can’t measure the starting conditions perfectly enough to predict the distant future. Other systems are also chaotic: the turbulent flow of water, the stock market. So, even though Newton’s equations are deterministic, our ability to use them as a crystal ball is limited.

But even though systems like the double pendulum, weather, and turbulent fluid flow, are unpredictable, they are unpredictable only because we cannot measure the smallest variations in their initial conditions. But if we had perfect information or perfectly precise measurement tools, all these systems would be predictable. So the future behavior of macroscale chaotic phenomena like these are predictable in principle.

A big problem to predictability is from quantum mechanics. At a microscopic scale, nature is not deterministic but probabilistic. It appears to be a fundamental feature of the universe, not lack of knowledge. One can experiment with an atom or electron exactly the same way each time, but get different results in a random pattern. We can calculate the odds of each result, but we cannot predict the behavior of individual particles. Take radioactive decay. We can measure a half-life – the time by which half of them will have decayed on average – but we have no way to know when an individual atom will decay. This fundamental randomness is a built-in limit on predictability. #determinism Also, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, shows that we also have a limit on the precision with which we can know certain pairs of properties. We can’t know a particle’s position and momentum with infinite precision. If you can’t know them exactly now, you can’t plug them into an equation to predict the future exactly either.

It gets weirder: quantum mechanics, says a particle doesn’t even have a definite position or outcome until you measure it. It exists in a sort of superposition of possibilities. We can call it a wave of probability. The Schrödinger equation lets us predict how this wave of probability evolves over time, so that part is deterministic.

Some scientists argue that we are just missing information in a fundamentally predictable universe. However, there’s no experimental…

Back to Arvin Ash · Report a problem