HE VS. SHE: Dublin Was a R*pe Club and a Payday
From American Regret · · 9 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
FCI Dublin was nicknamed the r*pe club, and it earned the name. The warden went to federal prison. So did the chaplain. The government paid $116 million to 103 women. I was the unit legal clerk in Danbury when the Dublin women transferred in, and at least four of them told me, in their own words, what they did with the payday. If you came here with a side in the gender war already picked, I’m about to take it from you.
The Pattern What happens when a real prison sexual abuse scandal turns into a payout, and everyone involved does the same math: what do I want, and is the door open? Guards, inmates and the Bureau of Prisons all answered it. The gender war needs FCI Dublin to be he versus she. Every person in it was on their own side.
Questions This Episode Answers
- What happened at FCI Dublin, the women’s prison called the r*pe club?
- Why did the government pay $116 million in the FCI Dublin settlement?
- Can a prison inmate legally consent to sex with a guard?
- Did women file false claims in the FCI Dublin settlement?
- Why does every gender war argument turn into men versus women?
Key Moments
- 00:00 — “FCI Dublin was nicknamed the r*pe club, and I did time with women who turned it into a payday.” Both camps get told to stay.
- 00:01 — The scoreboard. Cornell goes on one board, Lindsay Clancy on the other. Nobody keeps a scoreboard of their own side’s worst day.
- 00:02 — Who holds the pen. A guard decides when you eat, who you call, and whether your release date holds. That’s why the law says you can’t say yes to him.
- 00:03 — The Lambo. She seduced the guard on purpose, sued, won, and bought the car. The law calls her a victim. She’d call herself a businesswoman.
- 00:04 — The DNA. A garment, a split sample, two women, two six-figure settlements. Nobody had touched either of them.
- 00:05 — Voluntary opportunists. Every dollar drawn against the complaint of a woman who really was assaulted.
- 00:06 — The final score. Gender has nothing to do with it.
- 00:07 — How one prison becomes a verdict on half the species, and who pays for it: the next woman who reports a guard.
The Fairy GodFelon Take Everyone in Dublin made a decision, and the gender war erases every one of them. The guard who knew the law and decided she was worth the risk made a choice. So did the woman who decided what she would trade for a lifestyle waiting on the outside, and the woman who heard the BOP was writing checks and wrote herself a story to match. The Bureau of Prisons made one too: it bought its way out of a scandal rather than fix the place that produced it. A slogan lets you skip every one of those decisions and go straight to a verdict on half the species, which is exactly why slogans sell. Score the decision, and the he-versus-she board stops working.
What To Do With This Pick the slogan you reach for when a story like this breaks. Men are predators. Women lie. Whichever one feels true to you. Now name one person you actually know who breaks it. Then ask yourself why arguing about half the species feels easier than looking at what that one person decided.
Resources & Related Mentioned in this episode:
- FCI Dublin prosecutions: former warden Ray Garcia (70 months), former chaplain James Highhouse (80 months)
- The $116 million settlement with 103 women (2024)
- The Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA)
- The Cornell Chi Phi case, reopened September 2026
- The Lindsay Clancy mistrial, September 2026
Next Episode Tease The Dublin staff knew how to keep a secret. Next time: the guards’ brotherhood.
Credits Host: Deana Martin, The Fairy GodFelon.
Production: American Regret.
Follow & Listen Listen everywhere: pod.link/6788405697 (Apple, Spotify, iHeartRadio, Podbean, and more)
Watch on YouTube: youtube.com/@AmericanRegret
Instagram: instagram.com/fairygodfelon
TikTok: tiktok.com/@americanregret
Facebook: facebook.com/AmericanRegret
Reddit: reddit.com/r/AmericanRegretPod