Cheap Turkeys, Thanksgiving Myths & the Butterball Talk-Line
From Always Hangry · · 30 min
This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.
Description
Thanksgiving dinner for 10 for under $80? George Duran and Karla Walsh dig into why turkey is so cheap right now. A new Wells Fargo analysis says the classic meal costs a little less than last year, Lidl sold turkey for a quarter a pound in 2025, and stores are happy to lose money on the bird if you buy everything else from them. Karla also comes clean: the food writer has her Thanksgiving catered.
Then the myths. Do you really need to baste? Is white meat healthier? Should you wash your turkey (78% of people do)? And can you trust that little pop-up timer? Plus a round of Foul or Fiction, where Karla has to guess which turkey recipes are real: Mountain Dew-brined, glitter-coated, reheated in the dishwasher, or stuffed with Munchkins and served with coffee gravy.
Finally, George calls in to Nicole Johnson, director of the Butterball Turkey Talk-Line. She explains how the hotline works, what to do with a frozen turkey on Thanksgiving morning, the microwave turkey trend, and her mom's secret stuffing ingredient. Then she takes George's questions about butter, in-laws and a 25-pound turkey for four people.
Need help this Thanksgiving? Call the Butterball Turkey Talk-Line at 1-800-BUTTERBALL or visit butterball.com.
Key Takeaways
- Thanksgiving dinner got a little cheaper. Wells Fargo puts a traditional dinner for 10 at $78.93, down 0.4% from last year. Turkey is down 0.5%, cranberries 6.6% and frozen vegetables 4.2%; pumpkin pie and gravy mix went up.
- Turkey is a loss leader. Stores price the bird low to win your whole Thanksgiving basket, which matters this year: in a Harris Poll for Instacart, 74% of Americans said they worry about grocery costs affecting Thanksgiving, and half said turkey is one thing they won't cut back on.
- Everyone buys a thermometer at the last minute. On Instacart, whole turkeys ran 1,651% above their usual share in Thanksgiving week 2025, and food thermometers jumped more than 3,500% on Thanksgiving Day itself. George owns eight.
- The meal deals are real. Amazon has a $25 Thanksgiving meal built around an 8-pound Butterball, and Walmart's $35 basket feeds 10 with 26 items.
- Turkey has rarely been cheaper. Adjusted for inflation, turkey in the 1930s through the 1950s cost several times what it does now. Lidl sold whole turkeys for 25 cents a pound in 2025 with its app.
- Skip the constant basting. Opening the oven costs heat; George dry-brines instead.
- Dark meat isn't the villain. It has more vitamins and minerals than white meat; it's just a bit fattier.
- Don't wash the turkey, or at least be careful. Food safety agencies say washing spreads germs. Karla notes the habit has deep cultural roots for some families; if you do it, avoid splashing and wash your hands well.
- Don't trust the pop-up timer alone. It pops when a small piece of metal alloy melts, at about 180°F, which is well past the 165°F a turkey needs. Check with a real thermometer.
- Thawing is the #1 question at Butterball. In a cold-water bath, a 12-pound turkey takes about six hours. Stuffing cooked inside the bird should reach 165°F in the center.
- There's no butter in a Butterball. The turkeys are pre-brined.
- Yes, you can microwave a turkey if it's small enough. It won't brown, but it can save the day if the oven breaks.
- Save the giblets. Nicole's mom chops cooked giblets into her stuffing; George calls them concentrated turkey flavor.
- When the mother-in-law insists on eight hours: gift her a thermometer and have a good gravy recipe ready. "The mother-in-law is going to win."
- Hosts want help but don’t ask. Butterball conducted a survery that 85% of Thanksgiving hosts prefer guests to offer help, but only 38% actually ask them to pitch in.
People & Companies Mentioned
- George Duran: host, Always Hangry; chef and TV personality
- Karla Walsh: food and wellness writer, Level One Sommelier; recurring Always Hangry co-host
- Nicole Johnson: director, Butterball Turkey Talk-Line; registered dietitian,…