
All About Capital Campaigns: Nonprofits, Fundraising, Major Gifts, Toolkit
Capital Campaign ProAudio
- Format:
- Podcast
- New episodes:
- Weekly
- Typical length:
- about 20 minutes
- Latest episode:
About this show
All About Capital Campaigns is your weekly source for nonprofit fundraising advice. Each week hosts Andrea Kihlstedt and Amy Eisenstein, co-founders of Capital Campaign Pro (capitalcampaignpro.com) and special guests, provide practical tips about raising more money for your nonprofit organization. Topics include capital campaigns, feasibility studies, working with your board, donors, major gifts, volunteers, and more. This is a great resource for nonprofit Executive Directors/CEOs, Development Directors, Board Members, or others looking to learn about nonprofit fundraising.
Covers: nonprofit fundraising, capital campaigns, major gifts, board giving, feasibility studies, donor engagement, philanthropy, nonprofit management
Show details and episodes come from the publisher's public feed at anchor.fm. Last updated . Names, artwork and text belong to their publishers.
Recently on this show
Summary of recent episodes, drawn from the publisher's feed.
This podcast gives nonprofit leaders practical fundraising advice, especially on capital campaigns, feasibility studies, and major gifts. Recent episodes cover endowment campaign strategy, measuring annual philanthropic revenue, and why charitable funds held in foundations are not reaching nonprofits.
Cosmos
Similar in subject
- Nonprofit Lowdown
Both cover: major gifts, nonprofit management, philanthropy - Nonprofit Hub Radio
Both cover: capital campaigns, nonprofit management, philanthropy - The Cause+Effect Podcast
Both cover: capital campaigns, nonprofit management
Similar shows
- Responsive Lab Podcast
- The Fundraising Masterminds Podcast
- Nonprofit Nation with Julia Campbell
- Hey Fundraiser!
- A Modern Nonprofit Podcast
- Break Fake Rules: Change Big Giving For Good
- We Are For Good Podcast - The Podcast for Nonprofits
- Nonprofits Are Messy: Lessons in Leadership | Fundraising | Board Development | Communications
Explore more
Episodes
The Capital Campaign Book Every Board Member Should Read
· 20 min
Board members play a critical role in every successful capital campaign—but too often, they're expected to lead without ever being taught how campaigns actually work. What if there were a practical guide written specifically for them? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Andrea Kihlstedt interviews Amy Eisenstein and Sarah Plimpton about their new book, A Board Member's Guide to Capital Campaign Fundraising: How to Raise Game-Changing Money for Your Nonprofit. Drawing on decades of experience advising hundreds of nonprofit organizations, Amy and Sarah explain why they wrote the book, what board members need to know before a campaign begins, and how nonprofit leaders can use the book as a practical tool to educate and engage their boards. Board members are often enthusiastic supporters of their organizations, yet many have little or no experience with capital campaigns. They may wonder why campaigns unfold the way they do, what they're expected to contribute, how fundraising actually works, or why campaign consultants and feasibility studies are necessary. Those unanswered questions can create uncertainty and anxiety at exactly the time organizations need confident, informed leadership. Amy and Sarah explain how the book was designed to meet board members wherever they are in their fundraising journey. Rather than assuming prior campaign experience, it answers the most common questions boards ask in clear, approachable language. The book covers campaign fundamentals, board leadership responsibilities, fundraising expectations, campaign strategy, feasibility studies, common misconceptions, and practical advice for navigating challenges that arise during a campaign. One of the most distinctive features of the book is the discussion questions included at the end of every chapter. Rather than simply providing information, the authors encourage executive directors, development directors, board chairs, and campaign leaders to use the book as the foundation for ongoing board education. Amy and Sarah discuss how organizations can incorporate the chapters into regular board meetings, committee discussions, and campaign planning over the course of many months. The conversation also offers practical advice for nonprofit leaders preparing for a future campaign. Rather than waiting until fundraising begins, Amy recommends introducing the book to board members a year or more before launching a campaign, creating shared understanding long before major decisions and solicitations take place. Whether you're a nonprofit CEO, executive director, development professional, campaign volunteer, board chair, or trustee preparing for a capital campaign, this episode offers valuable insight into one of the most overlooked ingredients of campaign success: an informed, confident, and engaged board. In this episode, you'll learn: - Why board members often struggle during capital campaigns - What inspired the creation of A Board Member's Guide to Capital Campaign Fundraising - The questions board members ask most often - How the book is organized for practical use - Why readability matters when educating volunteers - How to use the discussion questions during board meetings - When organizations should introduce campaign education to their boards - Why campaign preparation should begin long before fundraising starts - How board education reduces anxiety and improves campaign leadership - Practical ways executive directors and development staff can use the book throughout a campaign If you've ever wished your board better understood capital campaigns—or if you're a board member who wants greater confidence in your fundraising role—this episode introduces a resource designed specifically for you. To purchase A Board Member’s Guide to Capital Campaign Fundraising, visit https://capitalcampaignpro.com/books/board-members-guide-book/
Not rated yetWhen Your Campaign Plan Changes: Turning Roadblocks Into Opportunities
· 20 min
Think your capital campaign plan is set in stone? Think again. The most successful campaigns aren't the ones that unfold exactly as planned—they're the ones that adapt when reality has other ideas. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt explore one of the most important—and least discussed—truths about campaign fundraising: campaign plans change. Whether it's unexpected zoning challenges, rising construction costs, delayed approvals, shifting project scopes, lost funding sources, or entirely new opportunities that emerge along the way, nonprofit leaders must learn how to navigate uncertainty while keeping their campaigns moving forward. Most organizations begin a capital campaign with a carefully developed vision, a fundraising goal, and a project plan that has been tested through a feasibility study. Donors express enthusiasm. Leadership gains confidence. Momentum builds. But what happens when circumstances change after the campaign is already underway? Amy and Andrea share real-world examples from nonprofit organizations that encountered major obstacles in the middle of successful campaigns—and ultimately emerged stronger because of them. One organization faced an unexpected opportunity to purchase a neighboring property while already stretching to fund a major building project. Another struggled with escalating construction costs that threatened the viability of its entire campaign. In both cases, leadership teams discovered that the answer wasn't to retreat, panic, or hide the problem from donors. Instead, they invited donors into the conversation and treated them as true partners in solving the challenge. The discussion highlights a common mistake nonprofit leaders make when campaign plans encounter difficulties: circling the wagons and attempting to solve problems internally before communicating with supporters. While the instinct to protect donors from bad news is understandable, Amy and Andrea explain why transparency often leads to better outcomes. Donors who have already invested in a project want it to succeed. When organizations openly share challenges and seek advice, donors frequently contribute ideas, connections, resources, and solutions that leadership teams would never have discovered on their own. Listeners will also learn why feasibility studies are about much more than testing fundraising potential. They're actually designed to test a specific project plan and gather feedback before an organization commits to a final direction. That's why campaign plans should always be viewed as drafts rather than fixed blueprints. As circumstances evolve, leaders must remain willing to adjust their plans while staying focused on the mission and desired impact. Throughout the conversation, Amy and Andrea emphasize the importance of flexibility, creativity, and resilience. Sometimes the very obstacle that seems most threatening becomes the catalyst for a better solution. A construction cost crisis can lead to a more efficient project design. A property challenge can open the door to a more strategic opportunity. A setback can spark innovation that would never have emerged otherwise. If your campaign isn't unfolding exactly as planned, you're not alone. This episode will help you approach challenges with greater confidence, creativity, and optimism—and may inspire you to see opportunity where you once saw obstacles. To ensure your campaign ends in a celebration, download our free Capital Campaign Step-by-Step Guide & Checklist (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/). This intuitive guide breaks down each step of your campaign, and the timeline allows you to visualize your whole campaign, from start to finish!
Not rated yetHow a Small Development Team Raised $10 Million for a Youth Shelter Campaign
· 32 min
What happens when a nonprofit thinks it's ready for a capital campaign—but discovers it still has critical groundwork to complete before moving forward? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein sits down with Jacqueline House, Vice President for Communications and Community Engagement at Safe Children Coalition, and Paula Peter, Capital Campaign Pro Campaign Advisor, to explore the remarkable story behind a campaign that grew from an initial $3 million goal to nearly $10 million raised for a new youth shelter serving vulnerable children across Florida's Suncoast region. Safe Children Coalition serves more than 10,000 children each year through foster care, adoption, prevention, and diversion programs. Faced with the need to replace an aging youth shelter originally built in 1959, the organization embarked on a capital campaign that would ultimately far exceed its original fundraising expectations. But the path to success wasn't straightforward. Jacqueline shares how her organization initially believed it was already in campaign mode when, in reality, important campaign planning and donor development work still needed to be completed. Rather than rushing ahead, the organization made the difficult decision to pause for six months and focus on strengthening the foundation necessary for long-term campaign success. Listeners will learn why strategic pauses are often a sign of campaign strength—not weakness—and how organizations can use these periods to clarify project plans, secure key assets, build internal alignment, strengthen campaign leadership, and prepare compelling answers to donor questions. The conversation also explores one of the most important shifts in modern capital campaign fundraising: the evolution of the feasibility study process. Jacqueline explains how conducting donor interviews herself, rather than relying on an outside consultant, helped her build meaningful relationships with prospective major donors, gain candid feedback, and increase both her confidence and effectiveness as a fundraiser. Paula offers a fascinating perspective from her decades-long career in campaign consulting. Having conducted traditional confidential feasibility study interviews since the early 1990s, she candidly discusses why she initially resisted the guided feasibility study model and what ultimately convinced her that empowering nonprofit leaders to conduct their own donor conversations produces stronger fundraising outcomes and more confident campaign leaders. The episode also provides valuable insights for nonprofit executives, development directors, and campaign volunteers working in organizations with limited fundraising infrastructure. Jacqueline describes how she navigated a campaign with a relatively small development operation, a board that was supportive but inexperienced in fundraising, and a leadership team that was simultaneously managing a major construction project. Whether you're planning your first capital campaign, evaluating campaign readiness, considering a feasibility study, or looking for strategies to strengthen donor relationships, this episode offers practical lessons and real-world insights from a nonprofit that transformed its fundraising capacity while successfully completing a major campaign. If you're preparing for a capital campaign or looking to improve your campaign strategy, this conversation offers valuable guidance from leaders who successfully navigated the challenges and opportunities of a transformational fundraising effort. To ensure your campaign ends in a celebration, download our free Capital Campaign Step-by-Step Guide & Checklist (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/). This intuitive guide breaks down each step of your campaign, and the timeline allows you to visualize your whole campaign, from start to finish!
Not rated yetThe Natural Ebbs and Flows of a Capital Campaign (And How to Use Them to Your Advantage)
· 17 min
What if the “slow” periods in your capital campaign are actually some of the most productive opportunities for building donor relationships and campaign success? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, hosts Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt explore the natural ebbs and flows that every capital campaign experiences—and why nonprofit leaders should stop viewing slower periods as setbacks. Whether you're in the quiet phase of a campaign, preparing for a major fundraising push, or wondering how seasonal changes affect donor engagement, this conversation offers practical insights that can help you manage campaign momentum more effectively. Many nonprofit leaders assume a capital campaign should operate at full speed all the time. But campaigns are multi-year endeavors, and maintaining maximum intensity for years simply isn't sustainable. Amy and Andrea discuss why successful campaigns naturally move through periods of high activity and quieter stretches, and how understanding these cycles can reduce stress, prevent burnout, and improve fundraising outcomes. The discussion begins with an examination of seasonal fundraising patterns. Is summer really a slow time for fundraising? The answer depends on your organization, your donors, and your community. For some nonprofits, summer presents unique opportunities to connect with donors who are more relaxed and available. For others, donor travel patterns may create different challenges. Either way, making assumptions about donor availability can cause organizations to miss valuable opportunities. Amy and Andrea share examples of nonprofits that successfully leveraged summer activities and informal gatherings to deepen donor relationships and move campaign conversations forward. They discuss how cultivation often works best during periods when both staff and donors feel less rushed and more open to meaningful conversations. The conversation also addresses an important but often overlooked reality of campaign leadership: the emotional and organizational strain that accompanies major fundraising efforts. Capital campaigns involve large goals, significant stakes, and extended timelines. Amy and Andrea explain why nonprofit leaders should intentionally build breathing room into their campaign plans rather than attempting to maintain constant pressure throughout the life of a campaign. Listeners will learn how to identify productive ways to use quieter campaign periods, including donor cultivation, strategic planning, relationship building, and organizational reflection. Rather than viewing slower seasons as lost time, nonprofit leaders can use them to strengthen the foundation that supports future campaign success. If you're leading a capital campaign, preparing for a feasibility study, managing campaign volunteers, working with major donors, or looking for ways to sustain fundraising momentum over the long term, this episode provides valuable perspective on the rhythms and realities of campaign fundraising. In This Episode, You'll Learn: - Why every capital campaign experiences natural ebbs and flows - How seasonal timing affects donor engagement and fundraising activity - Why summer can be an ideal time for donor cultivation - Jerry Panas's powerful donor meeting scheduling strategy - How to avoid campaign burnout while maintaining momentum - Ways to use quieter periods productively - How to balance urgency and sustainability in campaign leadership - Why strategic pauses can strengthen campaign results To ensure your campaign ends in a celebration, download our free Capital Campaign Step-by-Step Guide & Checklist (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/). This intuitive guide breaks down each step of your campaign, and the timeline allows you to visualize your whole campaign, from start to finish!
Not rated yetHow a Capital Campaign can Turbo-Charge a Modest Fundraising Operation
· 31 min
What does it actually take to launch a $40 million campaign when your organization has almost no fundraising history? Andrea Kihlstedt sits down with Wendy Connors, CEO of the Hertz Foundation, for a candid, behind-the-scenes look at one of the most remarkable campaign transformations in recent memory. The Hertz Foundation supports science and engineering PhD students — but for most of its history, it barely fundraised at all. When Wendy joined to lead development, the board didn't even know the difference between an annual gift and a campaign gift. What happened next is a masterclass in what capital campaigns can actually do for an organization. In this episode, you'll learn: - Why Wendy refused to outsource the feasibility study interviews — and what she gained by doing them herself - How the Hertz Foundation tripled its volunteer force and what it did to giving - The pivotal moment two co-chairs made major gifts that unlocked the entire public phase - How a community that preferred anonymity and didn't pledge learned to give at a transformational level - Three things Wendy says every nonprofit leader should do before launching a campaign This is a must-listen for any nonprofit leader who wonders whether their organization has what it takes — and wants to hear from someone who found out firsthand. Ready to start your own campaign study? Get the full guide at capitalcampaignpro.com/feasibility-study-ultimate-guide/ (http://capitalcampaignpro.com/feasibility-study-ultimate-guide/)
Not rated yetThree Myths About Where Your Biggest Campaign Donors Come From
· 18 min
Where are your biggest campaign donors going to come from? If you're like most nonprofit leaders, the answer feels like "somewhere out there" — a major philanthropist who just needs to hear your story. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt are here to challenge that assumption — and bust the three most common donor myths that derail capital campaigns before they even get started. In this episode, you'll learn: - Why your low-level annual donors may have far more major gift capacity than you realize - The real reason most nonprofits haven't unlocked big gifts from their existing base (hint: it's not the donors) - Why Mackenzie Scott, Oprah, and Bill Gates are not your campaign strategy — and what is - The truth about what campaign consultants actually do (and what they absolutely don't) - How one couple made one of the campaign's largest gifts after years of $50 donations — and why the organization almost missed them This is a must-share episode for board members, executive directors, and leadership teams who are still waiting for a magical major donor to show up. Ready to find out where your campaign really stands? Start with our free Campaign Readiness Assessment at capitalcampaignpro.com/assess (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/assess)
Not rated yetWhen Your Campaign Goes Over Goal: What to Do Next
· 17 min
Three clients. One week. All of them over goal. And then the question no one fully prepares for: what do you do the day after? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt celebrate a remarkable milestone — three CCPro clients crossed their campaign finish lines in the same week — and walk through exactly what nonprofits should do in the hours, days, and weeks that follow. Because going over goal is not just a moment to celebrate. It is a pivotal window for relationship-building, staff recognition, and strategic communication that will shape your organization’s fundraising future. This episode is your guide to handling it well. In this episode, Amy and Andrea cover: - Why your first move should be a prioritized list — not a press release or social post - How to identify and personally reach out to the 20-30 people who made your campaign possible - The “onion” communications strategy: sequencing your outreach from innermost stakeholders outward - How to meaningfully recognize staff before they transition into months of pledge collection - How challenge gifts can push a campaign across the finish line at the critical moment - Why how you handle this milestone affects donor retention, volunteer loyalty, and future campaigns Whether you’re wrapping up a campaign right now or still years away from your finish line, this episode will help you plan for the moment that makes all the hard work worth it. Ready to start planning? Visit capitalcampaignpro.com/board-members-guide (http://capitalcampaignpro.com/board-members-guide) to download the free Board Member’s Guide to Capital Campaign Fundraising.
Not rated yetWhen Big Donors Push Back: Navigating Ethics in Your Capital Campaign
· 25 min
What do you do when your biggest donor wants to fund something that isn’t in your campaign plan? Or when a wealthy prospect makes you uneasy but you can’t quite explain why? These are the kinds of ethical gray areas that surface in nearly every capital campaign—and most organizations aren’t prepared for them. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Andrea Kihlstedt and Amy Eisenstein tackled the uncomfortable but essential topic of fundraising ethics. Prompted by the ongoing Epstein revelations—where major institutional leaders maintained relationships with a known bad actor long after red flags surfaced—the conversation expanded into the everyday ethical dilemmas that development directors and nonprofit leaders face during campaigns. The Epstein case is extreme, but the underlying dynamic is common: a donor with deep pockets and wide influence offers access, introductions, and large gifts. When something feels off, the temptation is to look the other way because the money is too important. Andrea and Amy’s message was clear—if you have a feeling in the pit of your stomach, pay attention to it. And more importantly, don’t carry it alone. Surface your concerns to board members, your executive director, or an ethics committee. These decisions should never rest on one person’s shoulders. But ethics in campaigns aren’t always about bad actors. More often, they show up as values conflicts. Andrea and Amy walked through a real scenario from a current client: a private school running a capital campaign received a million-dollar offer from a parent—but only if the money funded a new gymnasium, which wasn’t part of the strategic plan. The gift sounds generous, but accepting it could siphon other donors away from the campaign’s actual priorities, leaving science labs, scholarships, and teacher training underfunded. For organizations preparing for these kinds of board-level decisions, Capital Campaign Pro’s guide for board members offers a practical framework. Their recommended approach: don’t say no outright, and don’t say yes in isolation. Take it to the campaign committee. Consult lead donors. Explore a “yes, and” response—perhaps the gym becomes the next project after this campaign, and the donor leads that effort. The key is making it an organizational decision, not a one-person call. Andrea also shared a cautionary story about a community youth orchestra whose founding values of inclusivity were overridden by a small group of wealthy parents who wanted the orchestra to pursue elite performance. They gained board seats, shifted the mission, and eventually forced out the founders. The community ended up with two competing organizations, neither of which survived. It was a stark illustration of what happens when money is allowed to override mission. The practical takeaway: don’t wait for an ethical dilemma to arrive before figuring out how to handle it. Build the framework now. Discuss scenarios with your board before the campaign launches. Establish who gets consulted when a donor’s request falls outside the plan. Create a small committee or protocol for when something feels wrong. You don’t need all the answers in advance—you just need a process for finding them together. Planning a capital campaign? Download Capital Campaign Pro’s free Campaign Planning Checklist to make sure your team is prepared for every stage—including the conversations nobody wants to have: https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/
Not rated yetNot Every Capital Campaign Builds a Building — But This One Changed 800 Lives
· 28 min
When most nonprofit leaders hear "capital campaign," they picture a new building. A groundbreaking ceremony. Architectural renderings. But what if the most transformative investment your organization could make isn’t a building at all — it’s the people who do the work? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Andrea Kihlstedt spoke with Esther Landau, Senior Director of Advancement Services at the Arc San Francisco, about a $3.3 million capital campaign that had nothing to do with bricks and mortar. Instead, the campaign funded staff pay increases to reduce crippling turnover and shrank a waitlist that was keeping adults with developmental disabilities from accessing services they needed. The Arc San Francisco, now celebrating its 75th anniversary, serves roughly 800 adults across three Bay Area counties. When their strategic planning process surfaced the root problem — staff wages were not sustainable, which meant they couldn’t hire enough people, which meant the waitlist grew — the campaign became the solution. Of the $3.3 million goal, $2.5 million went directly to increasing staff compensation, and $800,000 funded program growth including a new internship program with San Francisco Rec and Park. With one month left in the campaign and only $150,000 to go, Esther reflected on the surprises along the way. One donor she’d prepared to ask for $7,500 immediately responded with $25,000. Clients of the Arc — people the organization serves — asked to donate to the campaign themselves, raising important questions about ethical fundraising and the universal desire to contribute to something meaningful. For organizations considering whether they have the internal capacity to run a campaign, Capital Campaign Pro’s campaign resources offer a practical starting point. Not every moment was easy. Esther described stretches that felt like dragging a bag of rocks — donors who answered every email except the one about making a gift, months of cheerful persistence before a single meeting materialized. Her advice: the campaign moves at the speed of your donors, not the timeline your board wants. And if you haven’t gotten a no, the answer isn’t yet no. Some of the most creative work happened in cultivation. For the public phase launch, Esther’s team built an immersive experience where attendees assumed the identity of someone trying to access disability services and navigated real-world barriers — bureaucracy, transportation, waitlists — with outcomes determined by a roll of the dice. Some didn’t make it through. The ten-minute exercise gave donors a visceral understanding of the problem the campaign was solving. Esther also championed low-tech, high-touch donor outreach. When emails went unanswered, she recorded short personal video messages — casual, unpolished, like popping into someone’s office to say hello. Donors watched them. And they responded. As she put it: people feel it when you’ve made the personal effort to do something just for them. The takeaway from the Arc’s campaign is simple but powerful: capital campaigns don’t have to be about buildings. They can be about building capacity, building wages, and building the ability to serve more people. And sometimes that’s the most important building you can do. Considering a capital campaign for your organization? Download Capital Campaign Pro’s free campaign resources to explore your options and plan your path forward: https://capitalcampaignpro.com/campaign-resources
Not rated yetThe 10-Year Rule: How Often Should Your Nonprofit Run a Capital Campaign?
· 15 min
Most nonprofit leaders think of a capital campaign as a one-time event — a massive push that happens once, maybe twice in the life of an organization. But that mindset can actually hold organizations back. The most effective nonprofits treat campaigns as a recurring cycle, and understanding the right cadence can make the difference between an organization that grows strategically and one that stalls. On a recent Capital Campaign Pro podcast episode, Andrea Kihlstedt and Amy Eisenstein explored the timing and rhythm of capital campaigns—how often to run them, when to start planning, and what to do in between. Their core message: campaigns are healthy for organizations, and you should be running one at least every ten years. Why ten years? The math is simpler than you might think. You need roughly three years to plan what your organization will do next — strategic planning, building design, community input. Then you need three to four years to plan and execute the campaign itself. After that, donors need time to fulfill their pledges, which typically stretch over three years. Add a year to build, open, and steward, and you’re at about a decade. That doesn’t mean ten is a magic number. Some organizations move on a 12- or 15-year cycle. Others run mini campaigns in between major ones — a focused $1-2 million effort to fund a specific need like transportation, technology, or a program expansion. These smaller lifts keep donors engaged and organizational momentum alive without requiring the scale of a comprehensive campaign. For a step-by-step overview of how to prepare, see Capital Campaign Pro’s campaign planning checklist (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/). One of the biggest mistakes nonprofits make is losing donor relationships between campaigns. Staff turns over, stewardship lapses, and the connections that powered the last campaign fade. Andrea shared a real story from just last week: a former client called to explore a second campaign after one of their major donors reached out proactively, offering to fund the next phase. That only happened because the organization had kept the donor closely involved—inviting her to events, sharing results, and maintaining a genuine relationship. Timing matters in another way too. A campaign is not a rescue plan. If your annual fundraising is struggling or your organization is operating at a deficit, a campaign will not fix that. Campaigns are designed to accelerate growth, not dig you out of a hole. The organizations best positioned for a campaign are ones with stable operations, engaged donors, and a clear vision for what comes next. The bottom line: don’t think of your campaign as a one-time event. Think of it as part of a cycle—plan, campaign, steward, repeat. If it’s been more than ten years since your last campaign, it may be time to start planning your next one. Wondering whether your organization is ready for a campaign? Take Capital Campaign Pro’s free Campaign Readiness Assessment to evaluate your position and identify your next steps: https://capitalcampaignpro.com/assess
Not rated yetWhy More Nonprofits Are Ditching the Traditional Feasibility Study
· 30 min
Before launching a capital campaign, most nonprofits hire a consultant to conduct a feasibility study. The consultant interviews donors, disappears for a few weeks, and returns with a report and a number. It’s the way it’s been done for decades. But a growing number of organizations are choosing a different path—and getting dramatically better results. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Andrea Kihlstedt sat down with Emily Cozart Mohammed, Vice President of Development at the Center for Investigative Reporting, to discuss her experience completing a Guided Feasibility Study for a $50 million campaign. The conversation made a compelling case for why the guided model is replacing the traditional approach. In a traditional feasibility study, an outside consultant conducts every donor interview, compiles the data, and delivers a final report. The organization gets a number and some general feedback, but the staff never hears directly from donors and often has no idea who said what. Emily put it bluntly: not having that intel within your own system feels backwards. The Guided Feasibility Study flips this model. Instead of outsourcing donor conversations, the organization’s own leaders—the VP of development, the CEO, trained board members—conduct the interviews themselves, with structured coaching and support from a Capital Campaign Pro advisor. The result is threefold: better data, deeper donor relationships, and a team that’s ready to fundraise. Emily’s team completed 55 interviews with a 2% decline rate—a remarkable response that reflects both donor engagement and organizational credibility. Donors told her repeatedly how much they preferred speaking directly with organizational leaders rather than, as one donor put it, another guy in a suit pitching one organization after another. For a deeper look at how feasibility studies fit into the campaign planning process, see Capital Campaign Pro’s ultimate guide to feasibility studies (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/feasibility-study-ultimate-guide/). The guided model also produced tangible early results. One donor made an early gift of $420,000 during the study. The team documented $8.5 million in planned gifts against a $10 million planned giving goal. And because every conversation was led by someone who knows the organization deeply, Emily reported a higher degree of certainty that stated gift intentions would hold. Perhaps most importantly, the process doubled as professional development. Gift officers who had never worked on a high-level campaign gained firsthand experience. The CEO became a vocal advocate for the process. Board members who participated in interviews arrived at the approval vote already informed and confident—so much so that Emily’s board presentation was met with almost no questions. Emily’s advice for organizations considering a campaign: if you’re hesitating between a traditional consultant-led study and a guided approach, don’t overthink it. The guided model is more work, but it’s not overwhelming—and the intelligence, relationships, and team readiness you gain are worth far more than a number in a report. Thinking about a feasibility study for your next campaign? Download the free Feasibility Study Ultimate Guide (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/feasibility-study-ultimate-guide/) to understand the process, prepare your team, and set your campaign up for success.
Not rated yetFrom Ghost to Host: 7 Strategies to Re-Engage Donors Who’ve Gone Silent
· 23 min
Every fundraiser has been there. A donor expresses interest, maybe even during a feasibility study, and then goes completely silent. Emails go unanswered. Calls aren’t returned. You’re being ghosted. It’s one of the most frustrating experiences in nonprofit fundraising, and one of the most common. On a recent Capital Campaign Pro podcast episode, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt shared a real client story and practical strategies for re-engaging donors who’ve gone dark. The story is worth telling. A client completed a guided feasibility study, during which a donor expressed strong interest in supporting the client's campaign. When the quiet phase began, and the team reached out to discuss his gift, they heard nothing. Emails, texts, calls—silence. Then, a board member who happened to know the donor asked him to host a cultivation event at his home with a celebrity chef. He said yes immediately. By changing the ask and the asker, they turned a ghost into a host. That’s strategy number one: Change the channel. If your development director has been emailing with no response, try a different person and a different request. A board member inviting someone to host an event is fundamentally different from a staff member following up on a pledge. Sometimes the shift in messenger and message is all it takes. Strategy two: Don’t make assumptions. You don’t know what’s happening in someone’s life. They may be overwhelmed at work, caring for a sick family member, or simply have a communication style that doesn’t match yours. Andrea shared a story about a longtime friend and major donor whose habit was simply not to confirm things—ever. Knowing that pattern prevented her from reading rejection into silence. Before you assume the worst, consider whether you’re actually being ghosted or just dealing with a slow responder. Strategy three: Keep your messages short. If a donor opens your email on their phone and has to scroll, they’re less likely to read it, let alone respond. Write your message, save it as a draft, come back, and cut it in half. One clear sentence with one clear ask will outperform a three-paragraph update every time. Strategy four: Propose a specific time. Fundraising legend Jerry Panas taught that the two best windows for scheduling are tomorrow and four to six weeks out. Tomorrow works because everyone knows their schedule. A month out works because calendars are open. The dead zone is the in-between. So instead of “let’s find a time,” try “I’m free tomorrow afternoon—what time works for you?” For more approaches to confident donor conversations, explore Capital Campaign Pro’s campaign planning checklist (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/). Strategy five: Give them a graceful exit. Say: “If this isn’t the right time, I completely understand—just let me know so I’m not pestering you.” You’ll get either relief or reassurance. Either answer moves you forward. Strategy six: Try a new subject line. “Are you okay?” works surprisingly well because it signals genuine concern rather than a follow-up ask. It reframes the outreach from transactional to relational, which is exactly where nonprofit fundraising should live. Strategy seven: Remember that persistence is not pestering. One client reached out to a board member six times with no response. When confronted at a board meeting, the member said, “What do you mean? You only emailed me once.” She had no idea. Your outreach may feel repetitive to you, but donors are busy. Keep showing up. Ghosting stings. But in most cases, it’s not personal. The donors who go quiet are often still reachable—you just need to find the right door. Ready to build a fundraising strategy that keeps donors engaged from feasibility through close? Download our free Capital Campaign Planning Checklist (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/checklist/) to map out every phase of your campaign with clarity and confidence.
Not rated yetWhat to Do When a Donor Gives Before You Ask
· 16 min
What do you do when a donor gives before you even ask? In this episode, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt explore one of the most overlooked—and potentially costly—moments in capital campaign fundraising: the preemptive gift. While it may feel like an easy win, an early donation can actually limit a donor’s full potential if not handled strategically. Amy and Andrea walk through a real-world story and break down how experienced fundraisers navigate these situations with confidence, clarity, and intention. You’ll learn why donors give before being asked, how to respond in the moment, and how to keep the door open for a larger, more meaningful commitment. This conversation is especially valuable for executive directors, development leaders, and campaign volunteers who want to avoid common pitfalls and build stronger donor relationships. In this episode, you’ll learn: - Why preemptive gifts are often smaller than a donor’s true capacity - How to respond when a donor hands you a check unexpectedly - What questions to ask to understand donor motivation - How to reframe an early gift as part of a larger commitment - Why preparation is key for your entire campaign team If you’re preparing for a capital campaign, this is exactly the kind of real-world scenario your team needs to be ready for. Start by assessing your campaign readiness here: https://capitalcampaignpro.com/assess
Not rated yetTranscend or Transmit: How Nonprofit Leaders Can Break the Burnout Cycle
· 27 min
You got into nonprofit work to make a difference. So why does it feel like you’re running on empty most days? On this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein sat down with Indra Lahiri — an organizational psychologist, certified traumatic stress specialist, and founder of Indraloka Animal Sanctuary — to talk about what burnout really looks like, why it’s more dangerous than most leaders realize, and what you can actually do about it. Most people think of burnout as simply being tired. And while exhaustion is part of it, Lahiri explains that burnout is more nuanced than that. It shows up as cynicism about your work, loss of motivation, and behavioral shifts you might not even recognize in yourself—like becoming overly controlling or short-tempered with colleagues and donors. For nonprofit professionals, burnout often stems from financial strain, overwhelming caseloads, or the emotional toll of serving people in crisis. But there’s a related condition that’s even more insidious: secondary traumatic stress. This occurs when you absorb the trauma of the people you’re trying to help. Unlike burnout, which builds gradually, secondary traumatic stress can rewire your brain in ways that mirror the effects of direct trauma. Your amygdala—the part of your brain responsible for detecting danger—gets stuck in fight-or-flight mode. And when that happens, your prefrontal cortex, the region you rely on for strategic thinking, clear communication, and relationship-building, gets hijacked. Think about what that means for fundraising. The skills you need most—asking donors for major gifts, coordinating with board members, explaining your capital campaign vision with clarity and confidence—are exactly the skills that suffer when your nervous system is in overdrive. You might think you’re functioning normally, but the people around you can tell something is off. Lahiri frames the choice every leader faces in stark terms: when you encounter trauma or chronic stress, you will either transcend it or transmit it. Transmitting looks like snapping at staff, micromanaging, withdrawing from donor relationships, or creating a culture of fear and reactivity. Transcending means doing the internal work required to regulate your nervous system, process what you’ve experienced, and lead from a place of stability rather than survival. That framing matters because it makes burnout a leadership issue, not just a personal one. When a nonprofit leader transmits their stress, it ripples through the entire organization—staff morale drops, donor relationships suffer, and the mission takes a hit. When they transcend it, they model resilience for their team and create the conditions for everyone to do their best work. So what does transcending actually look like in practice? Lahiri offers several accessible starting points. First, give yourself permission to take time—even an hour—that is entirely for you, not for your team, your board, or your donors. Second, learn basic nervous system regulation techniques. Deep breathing, meditation, physical movement, or even turning on music and dancing around your living room all count. The point is consistency, not perfection. One of her most practical recommendations is creating what she calls a self-care itinerary. Think of it like a project plan, but for your own wellbeing. Identify the emotional states you need throughout the day—calm, energized, soothed—and map specific activities to each one. Then schedule three small acts of self-care daily: morning, midday, and evening. Treat them as non-negotiable appointments, the same way you would treat a meeting with a major donor. If you’re preparing for or in the middle of a capital campaign and wondering whether your organization—and your team—are truly ready, start with a clear-eyed assessment. Take our free Capital Campaign Readiness Assessment to identify strengths, uncover gaps, and build a stronger foundation for success.…
Not rated yetIs the Sky Really Falling?
· 16 min
When the economy dips, political tensions rise, or a major funder pulls back, nonprofit leaders often hear the same refrain from anxious board members: "Maybe we should stop fundraising until things settle down." It sounds reasonable on the surface. But reacting out of fear rather than strategy is one of the most damaging things a nonprofit can do—especially in uncertain times. The instinct to hunker down is understandable. When headlines are alarming and the mood in the boardroom turns nervous, it can feel like the sky is falling. But is it really? And even if parts of your world are shifting, does pulling back on fundraising actually protect your organization—or does it make things worse? The truth is, at least half of what feels like a crisis is emotional rather than factual. Fear is contagious. All it takes is one or two board members raising alarms—"We need to stop asking for money right now"—for that anxiety to ripple through your staff, your volunteers, and your entire culture. If you haven’t thought through your response in advance, you’ll find yourself speechless when a respected board member suggests putting the brakes on your campaign or your annual fund. That’s why preparation matters so much. Before the next wave of uncertainty hits, nonprofit leaders need to separate emotion from evidence and have a clear-eyed view of their organization’s actual position. Are donations truly dropping—or did you lose one grant that felt bigger than it was? Are community members disengaging—or are you hearing secondhand anxiety that doesn’t match your data? The distinction between a real organizational threat and a contagious mood is critical, and it’s one that too few leadership teams take the time to draw. Andrea recommends building this kind of engagement into your organization’s annual rhythm. Instead of conducting a strategic planning process once every three to five years, consider hosting an annual planning day where you bring together board members, key funders, and community leaders to look at the landscape, assess what’s changed, identify emerging challenges, and gather advice. When that kind of conversation is already part of your culture, the next time someone cries "the sky is falling," you can point to the work you’ve already done and the partners who are already at the table. If you’re wondering whether your organization is ready to weather the next storm, start by assessing where you stand. Take our free Capital Campaign Readiness Assessment (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/assess) to identify your strengths, uncover gaps, and get a clear picture of your fundraising foundation.
Not rated yetWhy Capital Campaigns Should Start with Ideas Instead of a Campaign Brochure
· 22 min
Many organizations assume a polished campaign brochure is one of the first things they must create for a capital campaign. That assumption can slow down the most important work of building a compelling campaign. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Andrea Kihlstedt talks with Sarah Plimpton, Vice President and Chief Happiness Officer at Capital Campaign Pro, about campaign communications and why the traditional campaign brochure is often the wrong place to start. Drawing on conversations with many campaign leaders, Sarah explains why organizations frequently rush to produce glossy materials and how that instinct can interfere with stronger donor engagement. The discussion begins with a common scenario. Boards and campaign committees often want a sophisticated brochure they can show friends and donors. The thinking is simple: a professional-looking document signals credibility and readiness. Andrea and Sarah explain why this approach misses a critical opportunity early in the campaign process. A campaign case for support is not a single document. It is a clear set of ideas that explain why the campaign matters, what it will accomplish, and how the funding will make that vision possible. The early phase of campaign planning should focus on developing those ideas. Andrea describes how organizations benefit when board members, staff leaders, and volunteers participate in shaping the argument for the campaign. When people wrestle with the core questions of purpose, impact, and urgency, their own commitment grows. The process builds understanding and enthusiasm long before the first major donor conversation takes place. Sarah shares why producing a finished brochure too early can limit flexibility. Campaigns unfold over time and plans often evolve. Project costs shift. New opportunities appear. Certain elements gain traction while others fade. Printed materials that lock in a specific version of the campaign can make it harder to adapt as those changes occur. There is also a deeper strategic reason to avoid a polished brochure at the start. Early campaign conversations should invite donors into the thinking behind the campaign. When organizations present a finalized document, the message to donors is that the organization has already solved the problem and simply needs financial support. When donors see draft materials and evolving ideas, they can take part in shaping the effort. That approach encourages donors to act as partners in the work rather than sources of funding. As the campaign progresses, communication strategies shift with each phase. Early stages focus on developing ideas and testing them with lead donors. Later phases introduce broader materials such as campaign websites, videos, or printed pieces that reach a wider community. The underlying case for support remains consistent while the communication tools expand to match a growing audience. Sarah closes the conversation with practical guidance for campaign leaders who are beginning to think about communications. Start with the ideas behind the campaign. Gather board members, volunteers, and staff to clarify why the campaign matters, what impact it will create, and how the fundraising will make that vision possible. When those ideas become clear and widely understood, the rest of the campaign communication process becomes far more effective. For nonprofit leaders preparing for a capital campaign, this conversation offers a practical reframing of campaign communications. Strong campaigns begin with clear ideas and collaborative thinking. The brochure can wait. To see how this philosophy plays out in a feasibility study, be sure to download our free Ultimate Guide to Capital Campaign Feasibility Studies (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/feasibility-study-ultimate-guide/).
Not rated yetStop Nagging Your Campaign Committee and Start Getting Results
· 17 min
If your campaign committee members agreed to make calls but nothing is happening, this episode will change how you respond and improve your results. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, co-founders Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt tackle a common frustration in capital campaigns: committee members who accept prospect portfolios and then stall. The assignments are clear. The meeting is approaching. The report forms are empty. The development director is wondering how often she can “bug” people before the relationship starts to fray. Sound familiar? Andrea shares a real scenario from a weekly client support call where a lead gift committee of eight capable volunteers had one simple task: reach out to people they already knew and set up introductory conversations with the executive director. These were not solicitation calls. They were warm introductions. And yet, no one had made a move. Instead of offering tactics for stronger reminders or tighter accountability systems, Amy and Andrea propose something more effective: a shift in frame. What if the development director stopped thinking in terms of assignments and started thinking in terms of partnership? What if the question changed from “Why haven’t you done this yet?” to “What’s getting in your way?” In this practical and insightful conversation, you will learn: - Why even seasoned board members and major donors hesitate to make simple outreach calls - How anxiety and uncertainty quietly stall campaign momentum - The right way to check in with volunteers without damaging relationships - How to offer scripts, practice, and side by side calling sessions that actually move people into action - Why sitting in someone’s office while they make calls can dramatically increase follow through - How to use email, text, phone, and in person outreach strategically - Why getting a clear no is often more valuable than chasing a lingering maybe - How to structure committee meetings so members learn from one another instead of feeling compared Amy and Andrea explain that volunteers rarely resist out of indifference. More often, they feel unsure about how to start the conversation or nervous about how it will be received. A short opening script, a few bullet points, or a scheduled “call time” with staff support can remove that barrier. Once the first call is made, confidence builds quickly. You will also hear why development staff must resist the urge to become the schoolmarm. Campaign leadership works best when staff position themselves as allies. When volunteers sense that staff understand their hesitation and want to help them succeed, progress accelerates. This episode also explores a powerful campaign truth: clarity is everything. A yes allows you to move forward. A no allows you to move on. The maybes are what drain energy and stall campaigns. Teaching committee members to seek clarity liberates both staff and volunteers. If you are preparing for a capital campaign, leading a lead gift effort, or struggling with committee accountability, this episode offers practical guidance you can apply immediately. The strategies shared here are the same approaches Capital Campaign Pro uses with clients across the country to keep campaigns on track and relationships strong. Listen in to learn how to replace pressure with partnership and transform your committee from hesitant to confident ambassadors for your mission. For more free capital campaign resources, visit https://capitalcampaignpro.com/campaign-resources.
Not rated yetWill Your Capital Campaign Cannibalize Your Annual Fund? What Really Happens
· 24 min
Will a capital campaign drain your annual fund or strengthen it in ways you never expected? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Andrea Kihlstedt talks with Hilary Jansen, Director of Philanthropic Engagement at Community MusicWorks in Providence, Rhode Island, about what actually happens to annual fundraising during and after a major capital campaign. Community MusicWorks recently completed a $15 million building campaign and has now lived through the results. If you worry that campaign gifts will replace annual gifts, this conversation offers real-world clarity. Community MusicWorks is a classical music performance, education, and social justice nonprofit with a powerful community presence. Before launching its campaign, the organization operated on an annual budget of $1.2 million. After opening its new 24,000 square foot home, that budget grew to $2.3 million. With 40 percent of revenue coming from individual giving and no tuition income, the stakes were high. Leadership had a legitimate concern: Would asking donors for larger, multi year capital gifts weaken annual support? Instead, the opposite occurred. Hilary shares how the campaign became a catalyst for annual giving. Annual fund goals increased. Donors continued to give. Many increased their annual contributions even after making significant campaign commitments. The campaign did not erode trust. It strengthened it. Why did this happen? First, seasoned philanthropists understand the difference between capital and annual support. They recognize that both are essential. Second, Community MusicWorks had invested for years in deep, authentic relationships. Donors trusted the leadership and believed in the mission. When the organization expressed a need, supporters understood it as genuine. The new building itself also transformed fundraising. The campaign was about bricks and mortar on paper, but in reality it was about mission growth. The building created a visible, tangible home for programs that were once harder to picture. Concertgoers now see lessons in action. Families gather in shared spaces. Community members walk in off the street and discover the work. The physical space provides context for larger annual asks and attracts new supporters who experience the mission firsthand. Andrea and Hilary also discuss the post campaign moment. After a successful $15 million effort, Community MusicWorks faced a higher operating budget and expanded programming. Would donors feel fatigued? Would they say enough? In practice, very few pushed back. Most understood that a larger organization requires greater annual investment. The building was not the end goal. It was the platform for expanded impact. Hilary reflects on lessons learned after stepping into development without prior fundraising experience. She emphasizes that fundraising is relationship work at its core. The success of the campaign rested on years of trust, stewardship, and shared belief. She also shares a critical insight for campaign leaders: You are not raising money for a building. You are raising money for what that building makes possible. This episode is essential listening for nonprofit leaders, development directors, board members, and executive directors who fear that launching a campaign will jeopardize annual revenue. Hear a candid account of what actually happens when relationships, mission clarity, and thoughtful planning come together. If your organization depends heavily on annual giving and you are considering a capital campaign, this conversation will reshape how you think about donor behavior, growth, and long term sustainability. To see what the research truly says about the impact of capital campaigns on the annual fund, download the State of Capital Campaigns Benchmark Report (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/research-2026/).
Not rated yetThe Secret to Major Gifts Success is Making Time for Donor Conversations
· 16 min
What if the biggest barrier to your capital campaign success is the phrase “we don’t have time”? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt pull back the curtain on a truth that experienced fundraising consultants see every day: organizations that prioritize real conversations with major donors outperform those that try to outsource or avoid them. Drawing from their work with nearly one hundred small and mid sized nonprofits at a time, Amy and Andrea unpack the mindset shift that separates stalled campaigns from fully funded ones. As nonprofits consider a capital campaign or feasibility study, leaders often split into two camps. Some are eager to sit down with their largest prospective donors and hear their thoughts. Others insist they are too busy running programs, managing staff, and keeping up with daily demands. Amy and Andrea challenge that assumption directly. Every leader has twenty four hours in a day. The question is not about time. It is about priority. You will hear why treating donor conversations as optional or delegating them to a consultant is a serious warning sign for campaign readiness. While there are tasks that can and should be outsourced, building relationships with top campaign prospects is not one of them. Major gift fundraising depends on authentic connection between organizational leadership and donors. When that relationship is handed off, a powerful opportunity is lost. Amy explains the Capital Campaign Pro guided feasibility study model, which equips executive directors and board members to lead strategic donor conversations themselves. Rather than sending in an outside consultant to gather feedback, leaders receive coaching, structure, role play, and debrief support so they can confidently meet with their top prospects. These early conversations take place before any formal ask, creating a lower pressure environment where leaders can listen, build trust, and gain insight into donor interests. Andrea shares a story from the early days of this model. A nonprofit leader insisted that he did not want a consultant talking to his donors. He understood that the moment of conversation was an opportunity to strengthen real relationships. Years later, that campaign remains one of the most successful they have seen, with donors giving generously and repeatedly. The reason was simple: relationships were formed and nurtured by the people closest to the mission. The episode also addresses the emotional side of major gifts. When you only have a small number of prospects capable of giving six figure gifts, the stakes feel high. Anxiety can hold leaders back. Amy and Andrea describe how coaching and preparation build confidence over time. Leaders who begin the feasibility process feeling nervous often finish it energized, surprised by how meaningful and even enjoyable the conversations have become. By the time the formal ask happens, it is no longer the first meeting. The donor has been heard. The leader has practiced. Trust has been established. That shift changes everything about a capital campaign. You will also hear Andrea outline three types of nonprofit leaders: the rare few who are excited to talk to major donors from the start, those who resist and prefer to hand fundraising to someone else, and the large group in the middle who are anxious yet willing to grow. The transformation happens in that middle group. When leaders commit to regular, thoughtful donor engagement, fundraising capacity expands long after the campaign ends. If you are planning a capital campaign, conducting a feasibility study, or trying to strengthen your major gift fundraising program, this episode offers a clear message. Sustainable campaign success begins with leaders who make time for donor relationships and treat those conversations as central to their role. For more free capital campaign resources, visit https://capitalcampaignpro.com/campaign-resources.
Not rated yetWhat the Data Really Says About Capital Campaign Success
· 22 min
Most capital campaign advice comes from stories and experience. This episode brings three years of real data that confirms what actually works and what common fears miss. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, host Amy Eisenstein is joined by Steven Shattuck, Director of Engagement and Technology at Capital Campaign Pro, to share findings from the third annual Capital Campaign Benchmark Report. Drawing on responses from more than 650 organizations, they explore what successful campaigns have in common, how annual funds perform during and after campaigns, and why gift distribution follows a predictable pattern that boards need to understand. Amy and Steven begin by explaining how the research is conducted and why the consistency across three years matters. Organizations at every stage were surveyed, from early planning to post campaign completion, creating a living dataset that reflects how campaigns actually unfold. With that foundation in place, they tackle one of the biggest questions nonprofit leaders ask. Are capital campaigns successful? The answer from the data is clear. An overwhelming majority of completed campaigns report success, even when final totals land below the original goal. Many organizations still complete transformative projects, expand services, and raise more money than ever before. The conversation then turns to a long standing concern that often stops campaigns before they start. What happens to the annual fund? The research shows that for most organizations, annual giving holds steady or increases during a campaign, followed by strong growth after the campaign concludes. Amy and Steven discuss why this happens and how thoughtful campaign planning strengthens donor relationships, systems, and staff capacity in ways that support long term fundraising health. They also break down one of the most misunderstood elements of campaign strategy. Where the money really comes from. New data confirms that a small group of lead donors provides the majority of campaign dollars, reinforcing the importance of a disciplined quiet phase, early leadership gifts, and a realistic gift range chart. This section offers clear language leaders can use with boards to explain why campaigns are built from the top down and inside out. Throughout the episode, the focus stays on practical insight backed by evidence. From feasibility studies to board expectations, this conversation equips nonprofit leaders with credible data they can use to plan, explain, and lead campaigns with confidence. You can download the full 2026 Capital Campaign Benchmark Report here (https://capitalcampaignpro.com/research-2026/) and share it with your leadership teams as a grounding tool for smarter decisions.
Not rated yet