Skip to main content
AmigoFish

Michelle Parker: The People's Court Disappearance | 15 Years Later

From 13th Juror Podcast · · 56 min

This plays from the publisher's own server. We do not host a copy.

Open at the source

Not rated yet

Description

Michelle Parker: The People's Court Disappearance | 15 Years Later

On November 17, 2011, millions of viewers watched Michelle Parker and her ex-fiancé, Dale Smith Jr., argue over a $5,000 engagement ring on The People's Court.

Just hours later, Michelle disappeared.

The 33-year-old mother of three had dropped her twins off at Dale's Orlando townhome before heading home to prepare for work. But she never made it home. Her abandoned Hummer was discovered the following morning, and Michelle was never seen again.

For nearly 15 years, Dale Smith Jr. remained the primary suspect. Then, in October 2026, investigators finally arrested him and charged him with second-degree murder.

So what changed?

In this episode of 13th Juror Podcast, Brandi Churchwell takes a deep dive into the newly unsealed 46-page arrest affidavit, examining the evidence investigators say helped them piece together Michelle's final known movements.

Cell phone records. Surveillance footage. Deleted messages. Conflicting timelines. Allegations of domestic violence. And a series of details that raise serious questions about what really happened on the afternoon Michelle vanished.

But the story doesn't end with Michelle's disappearance.

Following Dale's arrest, renewed attention has turned to the mysterious circumstances surrounding the 2001 death of his former wife, Shannon Collins-Smith. Originally ruled accidental, her death is now receiving another look from investigators.

Two women. Decades of unanswered questions. And a murder prosecution nearly 15 years in the making.

What happened to Michelle Parker? And will the evidence finally bring her family the answers they've waited so long to hear?

Back to 13th Juror Podcast · Report a problem